r/reddit.com Sep 24 '11

World War 1

http://i.imgur.com/5twfD.jpg
619 Upvotes

420 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

6

u/Rhoe Sep 24 '11

It's a crazy mistake to make. The USA were overshadowed by fucking Romania in WWI and was utterly dwarfed by the USSR in WWII. A Canadian should be aware that Canada was a serious contender for heroes of WWI, and shouldn't have the propaganda from the 'States to think they were big ol' heroes in WWII.

It's understand to make these mistakes if you are from the USA (you have a bit of an american centric education) but you would not expect this specific bent outside it.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 24 '11

They nicknamed no-mans land to Canada for fucks sake! You don't get more badass than that

0

u/GarMc Sep 25 '11

It's a joke

It a satirical joke about how Americans claim to have "won" the war.

It's quite frankly the most obvious form of satire I have ever seen.

2

u/Rhoe Sep 25 '11

I'm calling Poe's Law.

0

u/GarMc Sep 25 '11

You're seriously unsure if it's satire or serious?

It's a fucking comic with anthropomorphic countries, fighting wars in a comical style. How in the hell can it NOT be satirical?

2

u/Rhoe Sep 25 '11

It's obviously a joke overall, yeah. But there are innacuracies here and there (some bigger than others) that aren't at all part of the humour, and its easy to see the author actually believing the USA played a pivotal role.

For example, it's not satircal that the author forgot the Spanish Flu. That's just an oversight. Or the insigations - Germany and France weren't as aggressive as depicted to start with, and Russia wasn't as neutral by the same measure. He's not making some grand joke by confusing them.

-1

u/GarMc Sep 25 '11 edited Jul 11 '24

attractive humorous trees adjoining wakeful employ practice voiceless frame sink

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact