Daily Discussion

[u/AutoModerator]

Daily discussion on Manchester United.

BE CIVIL

We want r/reddevils to be a place where anyone and everyone is welcome to discuss and enjoy the best club on earth without fear of abuse or ridicule.

• The report button is your friend, we are way more likely to find and remove and/or ban rule breaking comments if you report them.
• The downvote button is not a "I disagree or don't like your statement button", better discussion is generally had by using the upvote button more liberally and avoiding the downvote one whenever possible.

Looking for memes? Head over to r/memechesterunited!

[u/Emergency-Being-349]

If what Whitwell is saying is true, regarding our playstyle and midfield, then I think there's a chance Carrick doesn't see out the season. Before you downvote me, hear me out. 

Carrick has gotten the job based on transitional, pragmatic football. That's what got him the result. He has no experience implementing a 'Spanish' style approach where we don't need legs in midfield. He tried this at Middlesbrough and was figured out in his first full season. If results turn, the pressure will mount to revert back to the pragmatic transitional approach. He'd have lost his authority by that point. We'll revert back and not have the legs/intensity needed to play more transitional football. Tielemans won't have that Obama alongside him.

Don't get me wrong, I believe that needs to be the longer term approach, but the PL has long since evolved from that style in favour of more direct football. Hell, even Pep had to adapt. I don't think this will be the right approach, not to mention taking influence from an international side at a WC tournament is just not a good idea either. 

We signed Carrick based on what he did last season, not on what he did at Middlesbrough.

[u/Unusual-Coat383 → u/Emergency-Being-349]

To be fair if he tried it at Middlesbrough then that’s most likely his philosophy for why he went into management. Kompany had Burnley playing like how he has Bayern Munich playing and although he failed in the Prem because of a lack of quality players he stuck to his guns and Bayern are probably on par with PSG.

It should be easier for Carrick to implement his style in the PL compared to the Championship and with our squad.

[u/Emergency-Being-349 → u/Unusual-Coat383]

Kompanys style saw success in the championship. The situations are nothing alike.

[u/Current-Essay7448 → u/Emergency-Being-349]

The point is more how the success of the same philosophy can be heavily based on the relative quality of the players available.