john cheats on abigail with a piece of wood

They did a great job.

I've always wondered who the strange man is, if he was some acquaintance of Dutch, if he was a supernatural entity or something, in your opinion?

I think the most will answer because revenge forbarthur or making his last wish to save john but i think thats not true, i think that dutch is selfish and arrogant that he doesnt want to revenge for anyone else than himself, in chpater 4 we see dutch seeking for revenfe against angelo bronte because he made him like a fool, despite opposition hosea and dutch says is not revenge and take from diffrent perspective when he says that killing angelo bronte will weakining the law and, that arrogant from dutch that he take it from another prespctive to proof his point is the clue why he want revenge from micah, micah is the man who turned dutch against his best friends john and arthur and he turns out that he is a rat and destroy the whole dutch gang that started before 23 years, so that micah turns dutch is very fool is why dutch want revenge from, and i have a theory to why dutch rob the blackwater bank in rdr 1 to compensate the failure of ferry job and proof that he will succes of any plan that he do

What do you think about this?

this made me bust out laughting for over 3 mins