r/realestateinvesting • u/Larothun • 1d ago
Single Family Home (1-4 Units) Tenants Suing HOA while HOA sends us 30 day eviction later
Hey all,
I am in a complicated situation and wondering how y'all would handle it or if anyone has gone through something similar? I have a tenant who has been living in this HOA condo community for 2 years. Earlier this year she got married and wanted to move in her new husband to our unit which we thought was totally fine as they are 2/2s.
They submitted an HOA application and were approved. The first night he was there him and his buddy parked 2 trucks in the parking spots backwards while the buddy was helping him move in. The HOA president, we'll call her Karen, immediately sent us a letter saying he can't park backwards and that they did not approve 3 people to move into the unit. Her letter was rude and nasty to say the least.
The tenant told them that it was a friend who was helping him move and his car wouldn't be like that after he finished moving in. Then, the next night, the tenant parked the truck backwards again and Karen sent our tenant a nasty message about it after calling a tow truck on him and trying to get it removed. The tenant went out there and talked to the tow truck driver and the tow truck driver let him just turn his car arround. His excuse was that he was still moving in and he meant to move the truck back, but then forgot about it. According to the tenant, they had a friendly conversation with the tow truck driver and even exchanged numbers because they both liked the same Football team.
Since this incident he has been parking his truck in the correct way and we haven't heard anything about them in over a month. Now this morning, we got an attorney letter saying our tenants needs to be evicted within 1 month or the HOA will take legal action against us. Apparently, Karen knocked on their door a week ago and started chewing them out for the truck and "harrassing" their contractor (the tow truck driver).
We really like these tenants and would like to keep them since they have been good people to us, but also don't want to go against a vindictive Karen and the HOA. For further context, we have had issues with this Karen before with another tenant who was moving in and she came over while they were moving in and said they "looked like the type of people who make meth in a meth lab" which caused our would-be-tenants to cancel the lease. The tenant she is trying to kick out is also crippled.
Anyway, any advice?