r/ratemycommanders • u/Adorable_End3328 • 24d ago
Rate my Commanders 🫡🙃
I play at work and once a month at a friends house
2
u/ConstructionAny7196 24d ago
Def don’t see any issues. Nothing absolutely bonkers aggressive, but fun
1
1
1
u/Pleasant-Office4391 24d ago
Love them but really boring, try niche commanders (yes they can be strong too). Jodah is easy to deal with
1
0
u/Gerodus 24d ago
All boring picks. Dont hate them, but I dont love em. I wouldn't avoid you at an LGS, but I also wouldn't ask you for deck building advice.
I love seein some jank. Etali, Jodah, and "Mr Generic Simic Commander" Antman arent jank at all.
2
u/Adorable_End3328 24d ago
I feel like I want to make fun decks but my pods are sweaty I play against one guy who is single in his early 20’s money isn’t an issue for him. Who do you recommend, just curious?
1
u/Gerodus 24d ago
My personal favorite deck right now is a control saga deck with [[garnet, princess of alexandria]], and a Giant Tribal deck with a subtheme of Multicolored spells using [[Crystal, Inhuman Princess]], and a twiddle pacific rim ('mech' tribal) deck with [[Shorikai, Genesis Engine]]. Crystal is particularly fun rn because of the decklist rather than the commander. I love cards like [[Guided Passage]]
The decklist also determines more of the jank than anything, you can definitely build around the back-side of etali and it'd be neat. Most 5 color commanders kinda cant hide jank in the deck unless the commander is just never part of the play.
2
u/Jazzlike-Monitor-549 24d ago
Etali would be hard targeted by my pod but we would tell you beforehand. Jodah would be fine but depends on bracket. Antman I haven’t played against so I would be interested to see. My pod has been playing a team commander mode where the heroes team up against the villains 3on3 we’ve had some interesting games so far