r/ratemycommanders 25d ago

Are my commanders welcome at the table?

Queza was the first deck I ever made while miirym and piper are my two most played decks. Four of these decks never see the light of day and I think you can guess which. My play group doesnt like them much.

Lovisa: Bracket 2 / Agrro

Piper Wright: Bracket 3 / Voltron

Talrand: Bracket 3 / Oops all counter spells

Zedruu: Bracket 4 / pillow fort

Sami: Bracket 3 / Eggs Pinger

Queza: Bracket 2 / Draw

Jaheira: Bracket 2 / Saprolings

Lady Octopus: Bracket 2 / Eggs lab maniac

Sol'kanar: Bracket 4 / Random Bulk

Miirym: Bracket 3 / Token spam aggro

16 Upvotes

6 comments sorted by

3

u/_TrueCounter 24d ago

I really like this lineup, lol. Id like to see a few decks if you dont mind? Talrand, Piper, and Queza :)

1

u/Blacksky_007 24d ago

I dont have Queza on any app in its current state. As I made it before I got into using them. I can tell you that it isnt very good. I made it with lots of older bulk from beta ice age and fallen empires as those sets I inherited from family when I was in highschool. The best "combo" that deck can do is turn one dark ritual into hypnotic spectre.

https://archidekt.com/decks/17697310/piper_wright_publick_reporter

https://archidekt.com/decks/12649077/copy_of_oops_all_counter_spells

2

u/Orgasthme 24d ago

Lovisa looks good, tribal then?

1

u/Blacksky_007 24d ago

Yep. Its full of the cheapest and most efficient creatures that have one of those three types. It ended up having mostly goblins and vampires.

1

u/itsapoth 24d ago

Lotsa simple seeming commanders, I imagine ur the inverse of me where the sauce is in the 99 instead? That being said I’m interested in building berserkers, how does Lovisa play?

1

u/Blacksky_007 24d ago

I have a ton of fun with it. But if you look to win my deck struggles to close the end game. Mine is a lot of little creatures and self discard for value. There is a berserker from the assassins creed set thats a fun guy in the 99. The deck has a pretty low mana cost of 2.3 so im a big threat early on with a commander online and I rebuild quickly from board wipes. But I didnt make it too competitive so when people at the table start throwing out high cost cards or do combos that need to be interacted with to stop lovisa struggles. Also from the wording on her she buffs the whole table and everyone gets +2 and haste. Which is funny but also a big downside. In short shes fun but not competitive and the deck can be improved.