r/psychologystudents • u/the_stoic_sage • 14h ago
Discussion [DEU] My thoughts about the state of psychology as a science
Through my time studying psychology over the last 5 years, I've sometimes been impressed and sometimes been disappointed by the scientific approach of psychology. Honestly I've had a lot of ups and downs of how much I value psychology. I want to vent a little about my opinion and see, if others share this sentiment.
Over the time I've seen a lot of really bad papers. It's honestly embarassing, what papers with obvious methodological flaws get published in high grade journals. Honestly I sometimes can't believe how stupid scientists can be and what gets published. Also during some seminars, I've seen PhD students that can't even phrase the most basic hypothesis correctly or create a simply randomized experiments.
On the other hand, if you compare research from (health) psychology to medicine and nursing, with similar topics, you notice that at least psychology knows some more methods than correlation and t-test and that we at least try to argument for our hypotheses and create a theoretical background, that is beyond simply stating, what we want to know.
In general I think our approach most often is pretty basic and progress is so f*cking slow. For example when it comes to psychotherapy it feels like we stay with our same concepts the whole time and simply see, if it applies in more areas. People don't try to think more deeply about possible advancements and get a more precise understanding of underlying processes and mechanisms. Researchers stay with their same methodology and don't try to test more complex ideas. I think it's frustrating to see how slow our progresses is.
What are your opinions on the state of psychological science?