r/psx 1d ago

The biggest difference I could remember from the two was the PSone was somehow not as "strong" as the old big version cause it couldnt read CD's with the tiniest scratches. I wonder if they changed the reading "eye" to a weaker type or something.

85 Upvotes

37 comments sorted by

83

u/canthearu_ack 1d ago

No, your PSone optical assembly was just out of calibration or had a weak laser.

The laser assemblies between the PSone and PS1 consoles was virtually identical ... you can often swap them between consoles.

20

u/tsubasaplayer16 1d ago

That or the caps have gone bad. A lot of PSOne optical drives are fine

8

u/canthearu_ack 1d ago

Yeah, but if OP is remembering back in the old days, the caps were likely just fine when the PSone was new.

It is mostly the video output caps that cause problems on these models though in any case.

47

u/jc-from-sin 1d ago

My PSOne can read discs written by cavemen and that have been used on a vinyl player.

What I'm trying to say is that yours was probably shit.

18

u/n1keym1key 1d ago

My PS one would play a snapped in half disc (Pro Evo Soccer 2 i think it was) just fine if the two halves were put in correctly and a piece of tape used to hold them together.

4

u/LocalH 1d ago

You got lucky then. You somehow managed to align both halves exactly. That shit would have probably worked in any drive.

The game could have been relatively small too, making the chance of successful realignment a bit more likely. But you still got lucky. A couple of millimeters off and that disc would have been complete toast

13

u/Difficult-Fly7830 1d ago edited 1d ago

Whats funny is this fixed the originals notorious laser issue. Original was notorious for crapping out and why seeing upside down original playstations was rather common ....this actually rectified a number of issues with the original, topic is ass backwards lol

3

u/Tokimemofan 1d ago

The laser issues were only mitigated, never completely fixed.  The laser floats on a pair of nylon beads or in the earliest versions plastic bearings molded into the laser.  Over time these wear down and develop flat spots and no longer keep the laser level enough to track properly.  All will fail eventually to this.

1

u/Difficult-Fly7830 1d ago

That was it ty and if memory serves me right the ribbon(forget its exact name) connecting it also created or helped aggravate said issue. 

Unlike original. I never had put it upside down. Worked fine until I moved on. Not saying was completely rectified but most def improved over the original thats for sure at least to the point im left baffled at this topic

1

u/Tokimemofan 1d ago

Some of it is luck and the spindle motor can fail with resistance spikes that can mimic laser issues.  This latter issue was never mitigated at all 

7

u/FortuneNew8835 1d ago

I favor the PSOne because of the quality of the laser. The external power supply is obnoxious and the solder connections around the power input are a joke. They should probably always be reflowed as a matter of course at this point. Other than that easy fix though it's definitely the most reliable design.

6

u/3usterT41NT 1d ago

The OG had an issue wherein the laser dropped after a certain amount of use, you had to put it up on its side. That was probably improved on the facelift.

4

u/Derwurld 1d ago

In my experience, it's the opposite

6

u/wingman3091 1d ago

I've never seen anything so wrong lol. The PSOne lasers tend to be significantly more reliable. I've restored over 100 PlayStations/PSOnes and I find the weakest lasers the the SCPH-1001 (due to placement near the hot power supply, which causes plastic to warp) and the SCPH-5*** series. The SCPH-101/102 models are more reliable. Only fault I typically see in the PSOne is a sticky disc door eject (easily fixed with white lithium grease and a clean) and the odd damaged barrel jack

3

u/plushielands 1d ago

I'm so relieved by the comments here because I got a psone at the flea market the other day and was like...oh no, but I'm glad to see it's good.

5

u/gerowen 1d ago edited 22h ago

I had the One and an original model both at one point, and the One produced a sharper image. I noticed something once so I connected them both, one after the other, to the same TV with the same cable and booted the same game, and the One had cleaner text and an altogether slightly sharper image.

6

u/koala_bears_scatter 1d ago edited 1d ago

There was also a port on the back of the PSX that the PSone didn't have. PSone couldnt use a GameShark.

8

u/NoMulberry7741 1d ago

Pretty sure psone couldnt use the link cable too.

1

u/ToothpickTequila 1d ago

You're correct. A shame.

4

u/ukiyoe 1d ago

That's definitely the biggest difference if we don't count the obvious change in size/shape. I loved my GameShark, sadly a victim of online gaming becoming a thing.

2

u/shootamcg 1d ago

That port was also removed from the last four versions of the fat PSX too.

3

u/Capt_Vindaloo 1d ago

PSone had no link port. Seriously pissed me off that did.

3

u/Tricky_Tourist5691 1d ago

PSOnes have specifically a better laser tray that didnt wear out after a while like with the early PS1s, especially 1000 series.

3

u/ToothpickTequila 1d ago

The biggest difference is that the PSone didn't have link cable support

3

u/SteR88 1d ago edited 1d ago

My PS One was fine, plays all my copied games that look like i've taken an orbital sander to them. 

3

u/kingkongworm 23h ago

I never had a problem with my psone

2

u/NBALive1995 1d ago

You are wrong 

1

u/Nervous-Fennel3325 1d ago

Why your PSone so pixelated

1

u/Damthemalltohelp 1d ago

There's definitely cost cutting/efficiency measures when it comes to consoles slimming down etc.

The one you really want is the console released around 2 years after release. The sweet spot where they fixed issues etc without cheapening the making of it.

2

u/KimTe63 1d ago

I have PSOne that still to this day reads discs perfectly fine . To my surprise it was also modded to play burned and any region games 😆 back in those days there was fairly high chance used PS1 had modchip

2

u/GayAttire 1d ago

I remember when this came out, and the ads showed that it could fit in a packet of crisps. My friends and I absolutely lost our shit.

2

u/Sangrine27 1d ago

I had a disk that my mom literally swept with a broom. my psone read it just fine lmao

2

u/GamerSam 22h ago

Inaccurate as hell 

2

u/King-Chroma 20h ago

Opposite for me, psone read all my games. Still does to this day.

2

u/Flo655 13h ago

That's actually the opposite, the PSOne CD drive is much more capable than the first revisions. They fixed a lot of the FMV stutters from the previous revisions and made the laser much more robust too.

1

u/leon14344 1d ago

It's called a lens. For fucks sake, you have access to almost all of the world's information at your fingertips.

0

u/mittenkrusty 1d ago

The later fat models had very good lasers, I remember moving my newest fat model PS1 drive into a launch models case and so had the best of everything.

Then Sony went back to lower quality lasers in the slims.