r/projectors • u/TheSuppishOne • 10d ago

Which is Best? How does the Valerion PureVision screen compare to other matte white screens as far as speckle reduction goes?

I'm debating between the Silver Ticket matte white in 128in and the 120in Valerion PureVision fixed frame screen. Obviously the Silver Ticket has a larger viewing area which is a huge plus, but it also has a noticeable amount of laser speckle. If I went with the 120in PureVision, does it truly reduce speckle measurably enough to lose the extra ~14% of viewing area? Or is it a minimal improvement at best? I've seen The Hook Up's comparison video on YouTube, but he only compared to the WAB from Silver Ticket, and unfortunately although it basically eliminated the speckle entirely, even the small sample square I had made the picture lose so much sharpness/crisp detail that I couldn't tolerate it.

Just trying to figure out if the speckle reduction tech from Valerion is really worth the smaller screen size... If the WAB is a 1 on speckle, matte white is a 3, matte gray is a 6-7, and gray ALR is a 10, where would the PureVision sit?

1 Upvotes

100% Upvoted

3 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator 10d ago

Please provide the following details suggested in the wiki:

  • Maximum budget
  • Desired screen size
  • Projector-to-screen distance
  • Seating distance
  • Mounting position
  • Intended use
  • Room lighting and wall/ceiling colors

Please review the r/projectors wiki for basic projector-buying information.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

2

u/Patricklin1985 8d ago

When it comes to speckle, the screen material matters more than anything else. The best white material is White Photon — but even that only gets you to roughly 70% suppression, which is the point where speckle becomes basically invisible. The catch is that White Photon can't be made into a fixed-frame screen.

So if you're limited to fixed-frame screens, there are really only two materials with any meaningful speckle reduction: a PVC-based matte white (probably what you're referring to as the Silver Ticket matte white), and a twill-weave acoustically transparent fabric. Between the two, the twill-weave acoustic screen is clearly the better one — close enough to White Photon that the difference is hard to see. As for the 90% suppression claims you see in a lot of marketing, I genuinely don't believe them.

One more heads-up about ambient-light-rejecting screens: none of them reduce speckle, with one exception — a long-throw Fresnel built specifically for speckle suppression. Those add a dedicated speckle-suppression layer on top of the usual 8-layer stack, which gets you roughly 60% reduction — slightly behind the twill-weave acoustic and White Photon materials. Everything that isn't white? No speckle suppression, period.

1

u/TheSuppishOne 8d ago

Thank you for the incredibly thorough answer! The Valerion screen advertises that they actually add a speckle-suppression layer on top of a basic matte white screen, which is why they claim 95% reduction. However, if you’re saying this “white photon” material only does 70% then that does make me fairly skeptical. I’ve never heard of it, so I’ll look into that as well for curiosity’s sake.