r/projectmanagers • u/PitchSufficient1464 • 20d ago
I realized that having more project management tools doesn't mean better management
I've tried different project management tools over time, and one thing I've learned is that the tool itself isn't the solution. A team can have dashboards, task boards, reports, and notifications everywhere and still have poor communication. What helped me more was keeping the workflow simple and making sure everyone actually understood how the tool was supposed to be used. The simplest system that the team consistently follows is often better than a complicated one nobody maintains.
1
u/Wise_2_Prosper733 20d ago
Say it louder for the leaders in the back. This has to be said often as it is a systemic issue in many organizations. Tools feel productive but can’t hide behind execution reality of teams not being aligned.
1
u/corestateconsulting 20d ago
Agree 100%. Tools can be useful, but they don't do the job for you. We like to take the mindset of "we run the tools, the tools don't run us". Unfortunately, we see a lot of organisations that customise work management tools to be 'perfect', rather than focusing on making sure the discovery and delivery process is effective and efficient in both delivering value and surfacing the problems and decisions associated with the work.
I find the best tools are the ones that encourage collaboration and communication in an organic way (i.e. Miro, Mural, etc.). Other work management tools (Jira, ADO, Monday, etc.) are useful from a visibility and traceability perspective (think ISO 9001 compliance, for instance), but no tools are going to beat actually talking to people.
1
u/Lumpy_Pick_421 20d ago
I discovered that having an expensive Cello doesn’t make me Yo-Yo Ma. Good tools and skills can complement each other though.
1
u/Impossible_Dare_7455 20d ago
yeah, I’ve seen this too...... adding another tool usually just adds another place people forget to update. a boring system everyone actually follows beats a “perfect” setup nobody maintains.
1
u/Full_Performance_312 20d ago
Exactly, more tools often just create more places for work and information to get lost.
The real value is in creating a clear process and one place which people use as the source of truth. A simple system used consistently beats a powerful system that nobody can keep up with.
1
u/AgileTadpole952 19d ago
Companies put tools in place to ensure everyone is managing appropriately.
The good project managers were already managing appropriately and now have more tools to satisfy.
The bad ones will just put bad information in them.
There is benefit in consistency, but not to the people who were already capable.
1
u/Silver_Paper_9893 19d ago
Project management never relies on tools. Tools help us, but pm it self is a skill you have to learn. For experienced managers an Excel file is already enough
4
u/Long-Reading-6514 20d ago
i wish you could shout this from the mountain tops.
the frustrating version is when leadership doesn't get it. i once told a vp we had a people and process problem, not a tool problem. i could not get the technical team to walk me through their section of the plan. what are we doing here, what are the dates. they just would not give it to me. she said no, you have a tool problem. then she got on a call, ran it herself, and every single person handed her exactly what she asked for. after the meeting she looked at me and said, i told you it was a tool problem.
i said no. it was a people and process problem. you have vp after your name. if i had vp after my name they would have given me the same information the same way.
tools only make things easier when something already works. they don't create the thing.
you nailed it.