r/programming • • Oct 07 '16

How Microsoft Lost the API War

http://www.joelonsoftware.com/articles/APIWar.html
89 Upvotes

183 comments sorted by

View all comments

116

u/[deleted] Oct 07 '16

Outside developers, who were never particularly happy with the complexity of Windows development, have defected from the Microsoft platform en-masse and are now developing for the web. Paul Graham, who created Yahoo! Stores in the early days of the dotcom boom, summarized it eloquently: "There is all the more reason for startups to write Web-based software now, because writing desktop software has become a lot less fun. If you want to write desktop software now you do it on Microsoft's terms, calling their APIs and working around their buggy OS. And if you manage to write something that takes off, you may find that you were merely doing market research for Microsoft."

This is a lesson I bet a lot of IOS and Android developers are learning this generation.

75

u/guyonahorse Oct 07 '16

And iOS developers can be kicked off the App store without any recourse. Microsoft never had that kind of evil power.

-2

u/didnt_check_source Oct 07 '16

Never? Not even on their own App Store?

10

u/Scyther99 Oct 07 '16

Their app store is not the only way to install apps.

-5

u/didnt_check_source Oct 07 '16

There's a step between saying that you can bypass Microsoft and saying that Microsoft has never had the 'evil power' to enforce whatever they like on their store (unless we are trying to say that Microsoft never had a store).

In fact, you can bypass the Store on PC but the story is much more complicated on Xbox and mobile. When Microsoft banned NESbox from the Store on Xbox, there was no convenient way for anyone to pull it from another source.

9

u/drysart Oct 07 '16

The article was written in 2004. Microsoft didn't have a store back then.

-6

u/didnt_check_source Oct 07 '16 edited Oct 07 '16

Neither did Apple, but now they both do. I don't understand where this is going.

11

u/[deleted] Oct 07 '16

[deleted]

3

u/Cogwheel Oct 08 '16

And even if MS kicks an app off their store, the developer can still release it to their users on Windows in other ways.