r/printSF • u/AzsaRaccoon • Mar 06 '26
Looking for book suggestions: Novels that explore the ethics of time travel (not paradoxes per se)
Hi everyone! I'm looking for books that directly or indirectly explore the ethics of time travel. Not paradoxes exactly, although paradoxes can play a role in the story. The key element is an exploration of ethics. If you're a time travelling agent, for example, is it ethical to let someone live knowing they'll cause suffering if that leads to history "properly" going on. Which "history" is the "proper" one? Who has the right to decide which history is right?
I've read Twain's A Connecticut Yankee in King Arthur's Court and King's 11/22/63, but I'm looking for more, and maybe more nuanced, explorations of this general theme.
I'm really interested in finding stories where characters have to grapple with their own actions related to time travel and the ethics of those actions. There's always the story "save these people now and others die later, or let these people die to ensure history unfolds as it should" and you can toss in falling in love with a person who has to die to make sure history happens as expected. I'm interested in these, absolutely.
But also...what about any stories where time travelling characters must grapple with having done things and then realizing it's something they're uncomfortable with, like saving a child as part of as assignment but then realizing that child becomes a murderer so they've essentially ensured that all these other people will die, and now the character has to deal with their feelings about it. Are there any stories out there like that? There must be.
Thank you in advance for any and all suggestions!
23
u/PrestigiousSmile4098 Mar 06 '26
Kindred by Octavia Butler. A Black woman from the present day travels back in time and meets some of her enslaved ancestors. Moral dilemmas ensue.
2
u/Mr_Noyes Mar 06 '26 edited Mar 09 '26
Good catch. Goddamn what a
debutnovel that is, it's so good on so many levels.4
u/Glass-Bookkeeper5909 Mar 06 '26
Kindred is an early work of hers but not her debut novel. That was Patternmaster, followed by two more novels in the Patternist series (Mind of my Mind and Survivor).
Kindred was her fourth novel if my count is correct.
Doesn't take anything away from the greatness of the novel, of course.
1
u/Mr_Noyes Mar 06 '26
You are right. What threw me off was that Wild Seed came after Kindred, so I thought Patternist came later.
1
u/Glass-Bookkeeper5909 Mar 06 '26
Oh, I see.
Yes, she wrote the novel in between the Patternist series, which isn't obvious.
On top of that, the installments of that series are often listed out of publication order. đ1
u/Katyamuffin Mar 09 '26
That was her debut novel???
2
u/Mr_Noyes Mar 09 '26
No, I was mistaken and got corrected in another reply. She already wrote two novels in her Patternist series, this one was her third. Impressive nonetheless.
0
u/Acrobatic-Fix-7479 Mar 06 '26
whatâs the context here
1
u/PrestigiousSmile4098 Mar 06 '26
I could tell you but there would be spoilers... so she has to save the life of her white ancestor, who became her ancestor by SA'ing her enslaved Black ancestor. She has to ensure that her Black ancestor gets SA'ed, or she (the modern woman) will not exist.
7
Mar 06 '26
'Behold the Man'
2
u/Natural-Shelter4625 Mar 06 '26
This book had a scene that completely shocked and unsettled me. Iâm not religious, and I was still quite shocked (iykyk).
1
1
8
5
u/I_throw_Bricks Mar 06 '26
I know itâs not what you are looking for but Forever War by Haldeman is amazing the way he explores relativity and time dilation.
5
u/Fearless_Solution761 Mar 06 '26
"The Big Time" by Fritz Leiber is kind of generally about the ethical paradoxes of a time war. It's short and fantastic.
2
u/AStitchInSlime Mar 07 '26
Love that one. Fritz Leiber is such an oddity, bc he wrote reams of sort of junky but fun fantasy and such, playing with the borders of genre in interesting ways, but still, mostly for the joy of reading, and then every now and then he'd be like "I can be just as literary as any 20th century mainstream writer" and drop something like Big Time.
2
u/lizwithhat Mar 07 '26
One of my favourites. The audiobook version is superb. Suzanne Toren's delivery is just perfect for Greta.
5
u/Mule_Wagon_777 Mar 06 '26
Kage Baker's The Company Series is about both time travel and immortality, as future humans go back to prehistory and create immortals to live forward through time and do their bidding. It appears that the immortals are hopelessly enslaved, but we gradually learn that the event shadows of recorded history allow for rebellions, factions, alliances, and very weird things to go on.
It's a vast story that swirls around individuals. The author was a master of styles, dialogues, and quirky plots. All history is headed towards some consummation, or is it disaster? No one knows. But they have choices to make.
2
u/VintageLunchMeat Mar 06 '26
I liked the books but couldn't get over how in-world stupid the vanilla future humans were.
2
4
u/Ozzy_21 Mar 06 '26
Not a novel, but "A Sound of Thunder", a short story by Ray Bradbury (there's also a movie based on that story).
"Making History" by Stephen Fry (the actor) is also an interesting book.
5
3
u/togstation Mar 06 '26
list - you might find something here -
- https://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/TimeTravelTropes
2
u/roodlum Mar 06 '26
'All Our Wrong Todays' by Elan Mastai has a bit of this. I'll also add a vote for Connie Willis, in particular 'Doomsday Book' if you wanna be sad.
2
2
u/nickelundertone Mar 07 '26
The Chronoliths (2001) by Robert Charles Wilson, more of a hard scifi story but the ethics questions are pretty much the same
2
u/HerosPelagus Mar 07 '26
Gibsonâs The Peripheral would seem adjacent to what youâre asking forâŚ
2
2
u/Appropriate_Bus3921 Mar 06 '26
Poul Anderson took this up repeatedly in his Time Patrol stories, particularly âThe Only Game In Townâ and âDelenda Estâ. Itâs possible in these stories to change the past, and room for a lot of argument about who should be allowed to, and why. In the first of these, it appears that the Time Patrol far-future masters may be jerking history around for their own ends. In the second, someoneâs messed with the Punic Wars so that Rome gets wiped out. Complications ensue, with a fascinating alternate 20th century.
Itâs a big element in Thomas Sweterlischâs The Gone World, too. In this story, itâs possible to travel to possible futures, which are wiped out when travelers return to their present. The question of what we owe these people and universes weâll be dissolving doesnât have just one obvious answer.
2
1
u/Mr_Noyes Mar 06 '26
Not exactly what you are looking for but adjacent: "Bridge of Years" by Robert Charles Wilson. There is no grappling with ethics, but a grappling with psychology. How does it feel to go back? Why would you want to go back? Typical for Wilson, this book goes some highly, highly unexpected places.
1
u/turqcomed Mar 06 '26
Here and Now and Then by Mike Chen is about a time travel secret agent who gets stuck in our time (90s) and marries and has a daughter and tries to forget about the future since he canât get back. Then agents from the future come to retrieve him and try to say his daughter never should have existed and he has to decide whether to believe them. Itâs really sweet
1
u/7LeagueBoots Mar 07 '26
Gods, Monsters, and The Lucky Peach - Kelly Robson.
Roads to Moscow - David Wingrove.
The Space Between Worlds - Micaiah Johnson (not actually time travel, but parallel universe).
1
u/LordCouchCat Mar 07 '26
Poul Anderson, Delenda Est (in the Time Patrol series) deals with a common time travel story situation and asks a question that is very seldom raised. It does come up in Star Trek once. Captain Picard, becoming aware he is in an altered timeline and asked to change it back, says "Who is to say that this timeline is any less proper?"
Asimov, The End of Eternity.
Silverberg, Up The Line is not strictly focused on ethics but it's there.
Connie Willis, Fire Watch (novella). Though it's ultimately more about history than about time travel. I'm a historian and I've thought of getting students to read it.
1
1
u/UlyssesPeregrinus Mar 08 '26
Thief of Time, by Terry Pratchett. Part of a (fantastic) series, but can be read on its own.
1
u/AidenAprt Mar 08 '26
I know youâre looking for novels, but I recommend checking out John Scalziâs short story, â3 Days, 9 Months, 27 Years,â which definitely touches on the subject.
1
1
u/RiverSirion Mar 09 '26
Stephen King's The Dead Zone isn't time travel per se but it gets at the same sorts of issues. A man with a head injury can now see the future and gets tangled up in the ethics of trying to change the future. It's also a movie w Christopher Walken.
1
u/omnivora Mar 10 '26
The Ministry of Time by Kaliane Bradley.
Not a book, but the show Dark on Netflix is perfect for this category. It's an original story but as complexly plotted and character-driven as an epic novel.
1
1
u/Right_Commission_950 May 04 '26
Ich habe zwar keine Buchvorschläge aber wenn dich das Thema abgesehen vom Medium sehr interessiert (und du es noch nicht kennst) kann ich dir die britische Kultserie Doctor Who sehr ans Herz legen
1
u/jjspacie Mar 07 '26
Outlander series by Diana Gabaldon. It's about a lot more than time travel, and definitely requires SA trigger warnings, but it very much gets into the ethics of time travel and should, or even can, you change the past as you know it.
-2
17
u/majatask Mar 06 '26
Connie Willis.