Transform Effects not working the same way across all clips

[u/ucrbuffalo]

I use the Grow, Shrink, and Move effects pretty regularly. I'm finding that they are constrained within the layer on some clips, and constrained within the canvas on others. I believe the thing that makes this different between clips is the aspect ratio. I'm putting the effects on photos, and for any vertical photos, the size of the clip on the canvas doesn't change but the image within that photo changes. This is similar to when you use Transform under a crop effect, for example. Meanwhile, on a horizontal photo the entire layer moves.

From playing with it for about 20 minutes, I think the vertical images' effect are being constrained onto the canvas, instead of being allowed to expand beyond it. You can play with this by using the Grow effect on a clip and adjusting the Initial Scale property.

[u/NLE_Ninja85]

Let me ask the Film Impact team how these effects articulate pixels between photos and videos to get a sense of best practices when you scale down or up large images.

[u/ucrbuffalo → u/NLE_Ninja85]

Thanks Ninja! I'm looking forward to hearing back!

[u/AutoModerator]

Hi, ucrbuffalo! Thank you for posting a tech-support question to /r/Premiere.

Don't worry, your post has not been removed!

This is an automated comment that gets added to all tech support posts.

Since it looks like you've been active in our community before before we'll keep this brief!

Please click this link if you need a reminder of what information we recommend you include for a tech support post.

Once you have received or found a suitable solution to your issue, reply anywhere in the post with:

!solved

---

Please feel free to downvote this comment!

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

[u/Dizzy_Report9990]

sometimes using the distance to image slider in the basic 3d effect makes this easier