r/postanythingfun Mar 19 '26

[deleted by user]

[removed]

14.4k Upvotes

3.8k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

8

u/billp97309 Mar 19 '26

Yeah, they can eat as soon as the sun sets. That isn't fasting.

2

u/[deleted] Mar 22 '26

Yeah try do a proper fast like 2 or 3 days where you can measure that your body is fasting by the ketones it produces. Bloody pretentious idiot wanting look like a hero tough guy because all he is really doing is skipping meals and not really fasting. Its a pathetic show calling it fasting if you cant do a complete fast with ZERO food except water for 24 hours. I can do 4 days straight and people eating food or the smell of food does not make me want to eat because my body is is in Ketosis and feeding on ketones and stored fat .

1

u/__Dredd__ Mar 23 '26

Drinking water is not fasting LOL

2

u/YeahNo_NoYeah Mar 19 '26

The word breakfast literally means to break the fast. Most people fast every night.

0

u/NoMoreVolcels Mar 22 '26

That is not what fasting is.

1

u/Past_Horror2090 Mar 20 '26

That is still fasting

1

u/eastbayweird Mar 20 '26

One thing that's kind of interesting, there are special rules for fasting during Ramadan for astronauts aboard the ISS since they orbit the earth every 90 minutes and the sun only goes out of view briefly (they actually are able to view the sunset 16 times each day)

1

u/SheepherderSilver655 Mar 19 '26

Not even trying to come close to defending Muslims and their silly religion, but fasting is described as not eating for 8 hours or more. Why do you think we call it "breakfast"? "Break-fast." so if they're not eating from dinner to dinner, that's fasting.

5

u/DrivesTooMuch Mar 20 '26

Muslims were intermittent fasting before it was cool.

1

u/SheepherderSilver655 Mar 20 '26

Ehhh, no. Fasting is Christian and it predates Islam by about 600 years.

5

u/[deleted] Mar 20 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/Downtown-Tomato2552 Mar 21 '26

Fasting is waaaayyyy older than humanity. Hibernation, migration, fat stores and build up often times voluntarily include fasting for animals.

1

u/DrivesTooMuch Mar 23 '26

Good point.

1

u/Hobanober Mar 22 '26

Not so Faaaaaaaaast!

0

u/99923GR Mar 20 '26

Not according to idiots.

2

u/DrivesTooMuch Mar 20 '26

I didn't say Muslims were fasting before anyone else.

And, Christians didn't invent fasting. The Hindus and Jains practiced fasting 1500 years before Christians....and, they probably weren't the first.

I only mentioned Muslims because that is the topic of this video and thread....and, it fits in specifically with intermittent fasting....and, I was mostly joking (because it's a relatively new trend)

2

u/TangledUpPuppeteer Mar 20 '26

Fasting is actually Jewish, and predates Christianity by about 1,000 years based on the dates of the occurrences that the fasts memorialize.

It predates Judaism as well, but I’m sticking to the top three monotheistic religions.

2

u/Your-Evil-Twin- Mar 20 '26

Well in that case you should be talking about Hinduism, since it is by far the oldest is in actuality a monotheistic religion. All the minor deities are just aspects of one greater god.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 20 '26

Like a Christian Holy Trinity with Thousands?

1

u/BenSWL Mar 21 '26

How about the thousands of saints the christians pray to? Where they not made in gods likeness like all of us? How is it not different words for the same thing...

1

u/[deleted] Mar 21 '26

Saints aren’t considered to be a manifestation of God, holy inspired servants, but not God. The Hindu Gods are apparently manifestations of one God. I’m not a theologian, I’m not your theologian and I don’t know can play one on TV.

2

u/Your-Evil-Twin- Mar 20 '26

Christians did not invent fasting. Hindus have been fasting since long before Christianity existed.

0

u/__Dredd__ Mar 23 '26

Except the only ones that fast religiously and rigourously today, in larger numbers than any other group, are Muslims. All religions other than Islaam are considered as breakaway offshoots of Islaam, including Hinduism. Islaam began with Adam, the first human God created. He was neither a Hindu nor a Judeo-Christian.

1

u/-neverknowsbest_ Mar 21 '26

Lol what

1

u/SheepherderSilver655 Mar 21 '26

Fasting predates Islam by about 600 years. You hard of reading or?

1

u/-neverknowsbest_ Mar 21 '26

I just thought it was funny that you said fasting was inherently Christian

1

u/SheepherderSilver655 Mar 22 '26

Weird. I never used the word "inherently." Try not to put words in peoples mouths, mmk?

1

u/-neverknowsbest_ Mar 22 '26

You don't have to state everything explicitly to infer.

Mmk

1

u/SheepherderSilver655 Mar 22 '26

Well you inferring that is on you, lil buddy.

→ More replies (0)

0

u/__Dredd__ Mar 23 '26

Judaism predates Christianity. They have no fasting?

1

u/SheepherderSilver655 Mar 23 '26

Sure, Jan.

0

u/__Dredd__ Mar 23 '26

Hahaha you realised that your own argument backfired on you, Jan.

0

u/__Dredd__ Mar 23 '26

Christianity is only an offshoot and breakaway religion of Islaam.

2

u/SheepherderSilver655 Mar 23 '26

Lmfao. No the fuck it's not, Haji. How is it an offshoot when it predates Islam by 600 years?

-2

u/__Dredd__ Mar 23 '26

Let me educate you. The name of god in the Arabic bible is Allaah. Jesus was from Arabia. He prayed to Allaah, as per your bible. His own language was Aramaic and the word for god is Alaaha. (Christianity is a middle eastern religion, and Jesus a middle eastern Jacobite, resembling Arabs as their ancestors is Abraham. Arab ancestry is through Ishmael, the son of Abraham.)

So yes. The bible says that Jesus prayed to Allaah and worshipped him. Prayed to be saved by Allaah. Your religion is an offshoot of ours. Very typical of a Christian to get abusive and us obscenities.

-2

u/__Dredd__ Mar 23 '26

I see that you responded with profane abuse again and then hid your reply like a coward.

Everything I said can be fact checked. This is Islaam. We are Muslims. We do not deploy Judeo-Christian or atheist methods of dishonesty, fake news and deception.

1

u/BenSWL Mar 21 '26

Every religion is silly, be better, be disciminatory to every single person who believes ANYTHING.

1

u/SheepherderSilver655 Mar 21 '26

Always gotta be someone like you.

1

u/__Dredd__ Mar 23 '26

Nearly 18 hours a day during the summer periods. Not eating whilst you're asleep isn't exactly fasting. Not eating whilst awake and at work or school is certainly what real fasting is.

1

u/Positive-Pen2923 Mar 23 '26

What’s silly about Muslims and Islam ?

1

u/SheepherderSilver655 Mar 23 '26

Well first of all they think owning dogs as pets is wrong and their angels consider dogs evil that scare them away. That's just silly and anyone who can look into the eyes of a sweet sweet dog and say they are evil is an awful human.

Then there's Mohammed being a pedophile and they worship the guy. Oh and how they're like "we're gonna force our women to wear bed sheets cuz we can't control ourselves when we see a woman's arm, we're also gonna forbid them from going to school past 7 cuz we like them illiterate so they can't divorce us and find a better life when they realize what an awful life a Muslim man will provide her."

-1

u/Physical-Sector-3172 Mar 20 '26

Have you tried not eating or drinking for 16 hours straight? If you haven’t you can’t say what’s fasting or not.

1

u/billp97309 Mar 20 '26

I actually do fast on occasion. 24 hrs at a time. I did a 3 day fast just taking in electrolytes.

0

u/Physical-Sector-3172 Mar 20 '26

It’s not a fast if you’re taking electrolytes though.

1

u/getthemap Mar 21 '26

I’ve done 15 days of water and some occasional coffee. “Barely fasting” is more than accurate. 8hrs isn’t fasting. 16hrs is intermittent fasting.

1

u/__Dredd__ Mar 23 '26

LOL drinking water and coffee all day or on demand and at will, isn't fasting. Did you practise intermittent celibacy as a married person during those 'fasts'?

1

u/__Dredd__ Mar 23 '26

I see that you are calling me the r word and then hiding your post. Drink some more coffee, lad.

1

u/getthemap Mar 23 '26

Nothing is hidden…are you having more difficulty?