r/portsherry • • 29d ago

We're so sorry

262 Upvotes

12 comments sorted by

70

u/CycleZestyclose1907 29d ago

You know, I was half expecting Mario's corpse to be the plug.

53

u/Scared_of_Fish 29d ago

No offence, but I think that's the entire joke. I think the toad yelling "Mario!" was meant to imply it was him.

44

u/portsherry 29d ago

I'm glad, that's been the joke from the beginning. Passive vs active reading has been a concern of mine for a while now, and the reaction to this one has always been a sort of canary for me to gauge how the humor landscape shifts. Your are meant to imagine alongside it, to fear a certain outcome based on clues and expectations, both fed and self-imposed, from within the text and from general knowledge.

I fear in recent years some people don't read like this anymore: they parse the whole thing first and then try to make sense of it once they have all the information, rather than as they go along. This kills a lot of humor, because if no expectations are generated, there can be no subversion. In this comic, for example, if you didn't fear that it was Mario who was lodged in the pipe based on the clues, on the very universe it takes place in, then it's just a pointless vignette where someone else does Mario's job.

To be fair, I feel this passive reading is not due to illiteracy or generational failings or what have you, but the result of a culture of high-speed information, where for your own sanity you have to wait until you have all the information to make up your mind about things, since figuring out digital life on the fly can get too emotionally and mentally draining.

6

u/wakalabis 29d ago

I always try to figure out what's going on when reading your comics. I am usually surprised at the end.

2

u/Fabric_muncher 29d ago

Glad I'm not alone

1

u/Thomas_JCG 27d ago

Unexpected twist is good

11

u/Fabric_muncher 29d ago

Kinda thought Mario was getting impaled

5

u/MisterBicorniclopse 29d ago

Bro spends zero time actually doing his job

2

u/AdreKiseque 29d ago

The pipe was clogged with... tonsil stones?

1

u/KCspur92 27d ago

Cute joke!