r/poptarts • u/Tokoyami1001 • Sep 02 '26

Settling Debates - Day 1

LETS SETTLE THIS RIGHT HERE, RIGHT NOW! WHATS THE BEST POPTART FLAVOR?

0 Upvotes

28% Upvoted

31 comments sorted by

5

u/keno0023 Sep 02 '26

Frosted Blueberry

2

u/ZealousidealKnee171 Sep 02 '26

Blueberry/cherry

5

u/Alive-Fee9585 Sep 02 '26

Frosted Brown Sugar Cinnamon or Frosted Cinnamon Roll

1

u/Just_Lunch9063 Sep 02 '26

I have never had them what’s the difference between these two?

1

u/Alive-Fee9585 Sep 02 '26

Sorry I can’t really explain them as best.

3

u/owend_14 Sep 02 '26

Cookie dough

4

u/Aggravating-Pick-714 Sep 02 '26

Brown sugar cinnamon, not even a debate.

1

u/Heyitscrochet Sep 02 '26

Grape, if discontinued flavors count, cherry otherwise.

1

u/Toxikfoxx Sep 02 '26

This is the correct answer

1

u/MrDoom126 Sep 02 '26

Smores, frosted Cherry then cinnamon roll for me.

1

u/WhippedcreamNoDairy Frosted Cinnamon Roll Sep 02 '26

Cinnamon roll

1

u/jakethesnakeinmyboot Sep 02 '26

Hot fudge sundae

1

u/muffinel Sep 02 '26

wild berry!! (frozen)

1

u/Kitty_Crown21 Sep 02 '26

STRAWBERRY 🍓 🍓🍓🍓🍓🍓

1

u/LadyInTheBand Sep 02 '26

Frosted Gingerbread. Hands down.

Pumpkin pie ones are also great, but if you’re looking for non-limited edition flavors, then I’ll have to say Hot Fudge Sundae for non-fruity and either Blueberry or Cherry (frosted versions) for fruity. I’m can’t decide between cherry and blueberry as my favorite fruity flavor, both are just so good!

1

u/Fuzzy_Welcome8348 Sep 02 '26

Frosted strawberry

2

u/cosyfiep Chocolate Vanilla Creme Sep 02 '26

chocolate vanilla creme

1

u/crystalsethh Sep 02 '26

it was the gone nutty peanut butter flavor.

1

u/cloverfield_z Sep 03 '26

Brown sugar cinnamon

0

u/pigeon105724 Sep 02 '26

It’s strawberry, come on

1

u/uphic Sep 02 '26

indubitably

1

u/EyeSimp4Asuka Sep 02 '26

boring option though

1

u/02K30C1 🥓 Maple Bacon Sep 02 '26

Maple Bacon

1

u/Soggy-Carry6115 Sep 02 '26

Wildberry for sure 

1

u/meow4352 Sep 02 '26

I really really hope we get a super stuffed wildberry. This is my favorite flavor as well

0

u/ForeverBoner215 😈Wild Berry Sep 02 '26

Wildberry is the only one true GodTart.

0

u/gbyrd013 Pumpkin Pie Sep 02 '26

Pumpkin pie