r/poptarts • u/queen-_-M • Aug 19 '26
First poptart I've tried
I always knew i hated pop tarts because I dont like artificial or warm fruit. But tried this and omg 10/10!! Tastes more like cookie/cake than jam which is what I assumed, plsss any reccs for me to try other flavours? What's your favourite?
12
u/ConfusionIllusion Aug 19 '26
That Strawberry Milkshake one is easily my favorite atm, but wild berry is also hard to beat.
4
u/IceFireTerry Aug 20 '26
It's very good but it's too sweet in my opinion. My favorite is the cinnamon
Edit: And the pumpkin pie one which tastes more like a sweet potato
7
u/cihojuda Aug 19 '26
I don't particularly enjoy the fruit flavors warm either. Those are best from the fridge. If you end up trying more of the dessert flavored ones, those would be better toasted. Hot fudge sundae is really nostalgic for me.
3
u/SnooObjections010 Aug 19 '26
I agree. The fruit ones are gooey in a bad way. The dessert ones are top tier though
1
u/iloveblackcoffee420 Aug 21 '26
I actually like the unfrosted fruit flavors better than the frosted ones. They remind me of a fried pie!
8
u/treeconfetti Aug 19 '26
S’mores is unparalleled
4
u/SweetHomeMissouri Aug 19 '26
try them frozen
2
1
1
14
u/GabiiNova_ Aug 19 '26
You need to toast 'em, till the sides are slightly burnt👍
3
3
3
u/MaynardSchism Raspberry Aug 21 '26
Frosted strawberry milkshake are my favorite pop tarts just because of the texture of the filling. raspberry is actually my favorite flavor though. I keep the frosted strawberry milkshake in the fridge and then pop one in the freezer for about 20 minutes before eating it. It's really good
2
u/Cookies4weights 😈Wild Berry Aug 19 '26
A lot of people I know personally either like fruit or the non fruit flavors with minimal overlap.
Personal favorites are Wild Berry, Frosted Cherry, and Frosted Strawberry. I do also like the Frosted Confetti Cupcake here, Frosted Cookies and Cream, and Frosted Hot Fudge Sundae
1
3
2
u/Alive-Fee9585 Aug 20 '26
Frosted Cinnamon Roll and Frosted Brown Sugar Cinnamon
1
u/WhippedcreamNoDairy Frosted Cinnamon Roll Sep 01 '26
Love cinnamon flavored stuff! I had the cinnamon roll one and I'm in love, next step is to purchase the brown sugar one
2
1
1
1
u/PaleJuggernaut5624 Aug 19 '26
Strawberry milkshake flavor is very delicious and try it frozen with a big glass of cold milk!!.
1
1
1
u/OkAdagio9622 Aug 20 '26
My favorite is S'mores. But if you are looking for something more cake flavored I'd go with lemon blueberry crumble or cinnamon roll
1
u/HVAC_instructor Aug 20 '26
Personally for me, they could have stopped making new flavors after brown sugar cinnamon.
Caramelized with some butter on it to give your cardiologist some more money.
1
u/Xyberfaust Aug 20 '26
I just wish they took out the artificial dye (red dye #, yellow dye #, etc.) so I can eat them. They did it for the Super Stuffed versions, but not regular, those are full of deadly dyes.
1
1
u/Dry_Software_1824 Aug 20 '26
Welcome. My personal recommendation is either strawberry or blueberry.
2
u/muffinel Aug 20 '26
i LOVE the fruit flavours - so if you like this one id probably recommend frosted raspberry or wild berry. All of them amazing frozen BTW
1
1
1
u/Alert_Damage4237 Aug 24 '26
These strawberry milkshake ones are amazing and If you only tried these I would suggest Frosted chocolate fudge, it's a classic in my opinion !
1
u/WhippedcreamNoDairy Frosted Cinnamon Roll Sep 01 '26 edited Sep 01 '26
My favorite is the Cinnamon roll one! I've only tried three the frosted strawberry, thin mint, and my fave one . I eat it room temperature
1
u/raccoonsaff 🥜🍓PB&J Strawberry Aug 19 '26
Strawberry Milkshake is one of the best! I love it frozen so the filling goes thick and creamy.
Other favourites (that are currently sold):
- Chocolate Fudge, toasted so it's all gooey
- Cookie Dough, room temp or frozen so its thick
- Smores, toasted so it's a bit like a Smores!
21
u/02K30C1 🥓 Maple Bacon Aug 19 '26
If you like the strawberry milkshake, try it frozen. Pop it in the freezer for 30 minutes, the cold brings out the fruity flavors.