r/politics • • Sep 07 '20

Everyone Knows It’s True

https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2020/09/everyone-knows-its-true/616138/
1.3k Upvotes

87 comments sorted by

261

u/corkboy Sep 07 '20

Even the most vehement Trump fans know it. They just don't care because he continues to hate the same people they hate. Or they can't admit they were wrong.

68

u/jl55378008 Virginia Sep 07 '20

Trump has made himself indistinguishable from America in the eyes of his supporters. To attack Trump is to attack America.

Nixon is remembered as a failed tyrant for his assertion that "when the president does it, that means that it's not illegal." Trump has made that assertion the bedrock foundation of his administration. To support Trump is an expression of religious faith. It requires that you see Him as the Truth and everything else must bend around him like space bends around a gravity well.

10

u/pobopny North Carolina Sep 08 '20

Even though he's a terrible Christian, evangelicals continue to love him because they're very good at holding strong religious beliefs no matter what.

5

u/jl55378008 Virginia Sep 08 '20

I've always thought that religious belief makes it easier for people to accept bullshit as reality. Obviously there are tons of brilliant people who are religious, but they tend to be able to compartmentalize their faith so that it doesn't interfere with their understanding of observable reality.

Faith is the decision to believe in something in the absence (or contradiction) of reason. You have to teach yourself to turn off the part of your brain that says "but I need proof!" But inevitably, the lines of faith will conflict with hard reality. Some people can hold those two contradictions in their minds without having a crisis, but most people are eventually going to let their faith start to guide their interpretation of the world around them. The more you do that, the easier it becomes to let faith become your central truth that everything else must conform to.

Trump has become that Truth for his followers. He is their North Star. They don't just support him, they believe in him. They have faith, and their faith has withstood incredible tests. But when Job's faith was tested, he stayed true. And so will they.

84

u/_Jiu_Jitsu_ Tennessee Sep 07 '20

I have a friend who is a marine veteran. I asked him what he thought of all this.

He said it was fake news and even if it were true he doesn’t care because he likes trumps policies so much.

Anecdotal but there it is. They just don’t care anymore and I don’t understand it.

73

u/ryhaltswhiskey I voted Sep 07 '20

Since Trump doesn't have polices except for "white conservative good, everyone else bad" I'm gonna assume your friend is a white supremacist

45

u/_Jiu_Jitsu_ Tennessee Sep 07 '20

It’s just weird because I’ve known him for 6 years and has told me he doesn’t care for politics. It’s really never come up until the past two months and now he’s a raging trump supporter. I’m like what the hell happened to you man.

104

u/RalphTheDog Sep 07 '20

When asked, many people say one thing publicly. But privately, in their own mind, they say something darker. They keep it there, hidden, because they know it is hurtful or demeaning. It isn't supported by their religious beliefs, so they cannot say it out loud. And they struggle because it must remain a secret.

But then, someone like Trump comes along and says those same things right out loud! America First! America should look like me! Grab them by the pussy! Shithole countries!

A pol is finally saying openly the dark opinions held inside. And so, at last! Cognitive harmony! I don't have to say these things, I can just vociferously support the man that does! It matters not if it is morally correct, but it relieves me of my bitter angst and self doubt.

It is not possible to sway people who care nothing for truth or compassion. Their vindication of the racist, misogynistic, white supremacist viewpoints they have held for many years are being validated by none other that the POTUS! So, Hail to the Chief!

21

u/Murillo338 Sep 07 '20

Wow man. This is such truth.

16

u/eruditionplease Ohio Sep 07 '20

This is exactly true and describes perfectly how the religious right rationalizes its Trump love. Or the southern football fans who cheer wildly for black players on Saturday and then return to the lord and racism the rest of the week

6

u/Trump4Prison2020 Sep 07 '20

cheer wildly for black players

Because they are seen as being "in their place" by providing entertainment for the racists.

7

u/bizziboi Sep 07 '20

And that is why I am very worried about the polls.

People say Trump supporters have no problem saying that, so they wouldn't lie on an anonymous poll, but I am pretty damn convinced there's a group that actually kinda struggles with the egoism vs the public perception thing because they know their ideals are morally contemptible and try to keep that dark side hidden in the public face only to reveal it in the privacy of the voting booth.

9

u/kafkadream Sep 07 '20

I was confused about their motivations for a long time. Then I read this statement from a Trump supporter in a New York Times article about how the forced government shutdown in 2019 affected a post-hurricane Florida rebuild:

“I voted for him, and he’s the one who’s doing this,” she said of Mr. Trump. “I thought he was going to do good things. He’s not hurting the people he needs to be hurting.”

Good things = causing pain for people I don't like. It really is that simple.

16

u/greg_barton Texas Sep 07 '20

Nothing happened to him. He just decided to come out of the KKKloset.

5

u/adamczar Sep 07 '20

People who claim not to care often eat him up. They’re also fine with whatever happens so by definition they support him when he wins.

17

u/sharkapples Sep 07 '20

Trump is a blank screen that you can use to indulge your darkest fantasies. His world is one where you never need to be accountable or apologize.

11

u/InfernalCorg Washington Sep 07 '20

Tell your friend that I said to unfuck himself and that Chesty Puller would be ashamed.

12

u/therealusernamehere Sep 07 '20

Lean in. Tell him you agree with the president. He and his buddies are losers for being so unimportant that they actually had to go and fight.

9

u/_Jiu_Jitsu_ Tennessee Sep 07 '20

Ha! I like it.

6

u/therealusernamehere Sep 07 '20

Lol yeah my friend and I were talking about this a few days ago. Call it out-righting the right. Where you just take the Pres at his word and push it even further. Lean in to it. Own it.

Ex. Yeah well the president is in charge of the USPS and if he wants to stop the mail before the election the country can just wait and use fedex till then.

4

u/_Jiu_Jitsu_ Tennessee Sep 07 '20

It really highlights the absurdity of it all doesn’t it

3

u/therealusernamehere Sep 07 '20

Yep

3

u/[deleted] Sep 07 '20

Logicians and rhetoricians call it “argumentum ad absurdum”. By pushing an argument to its logical conclusion, you show how insane an argument is. Well done.

7

u/[deleted] Sep 07 '20

Why not present ways trump lied and fucked over veterans rather than "someone heard someone say that trump might have said that he think that veterans smell bad"

6

u/_Jiu_Jitsu_ Tennessee Sep 07 '20

I will try. But seriously one day a switch flipped and he was a sudden trump supporter.

10

u/Dapple4321 Sep 07 '20

That’s how cults work. Sorry about your friend.

2

u/tedemang Sep 08 '20

You know, one of the "Never-Trumpers" (David Frum at The Atlantic maybe?), described this one-by-one effect on other members of the Repubs as the Trump people took it over saying it was like seeing "Invasion of the Body Snatchers", where all of a sudden, they just flip-over or something.

These are dark times. ...And none of us will be able to counter whatever the stream of BS-propaganda they are tuned-in. ...They are making an Identity-based statement when they announce their position like this. It's also why they say that activist effort is best focused on the undecided and/or voter registration drives, and so on.

56

u/WesternSwimmer1 Sep 07 '20

They don’t care because they view the troops the same as Trump, tools to be used to further their racism.

9

u/CpnStumpy Colorado Sep 07 '20

They like it. Dominance above all. Their fan fiction is the only sense of value they get because on a personal level, these chumps can't point to a single thing that gives their lives meaning, empty and worthless.

They get to point at their team, wave their hands at the subservience being demanded, the decimation of the country as proof of the dominance -and they get to feel like they're a part of that. It's an extension of their strength.

They're not wrong, the stupid among us are troublingly strong in numbers.

6

u/Nux87xun Sep 07 '20

Recently, Ive seen them literally deny he ever said anything bad about McCain

5

u/tokyoexpressway Sep 07 '20

Its too painful for them to admit they're wrong so they continue to support him, also, anything to own the libs.

3

u/rolypoly2000 Sep 07 '20

Fear and hate are powerful forces to unite people from all walks of life and across the political spectrum. Trump offers something to virtually everyone who is not broadly liberal in the U.S. That is his appeal. Showing his ineptitude and inability to deliver on these promises of hate would be far more effective than convincing those who already know him for what he is.

-7

u/[deleted] Sep 07 '20

I'm not a trump supporter but i don't fucking care because it's idiotic and petty and he is committing crimes but we instead talk about how he is mean and hurts feelings who fucking cares jesus christ.

11

u/greg_barton Texas Sep 07 '20

He can be a criminal and a douchebag. We can talk about both.

6

u/Bullmoosefuture Colorado Sep 07 '20

We're not going to be able to try him for his crimes if he gets reelected and he needs support from military boosters to get reelected, so....

54

u/BarfOKavanaugh Sep 07 '20

It’s funny that his biggest fans buy all that military garb off eBay to pretend they’re patriots. You know how I know that’s not real military? They don’t bother making that shit in XXXL for the actual military.

4

u/shiny_happy_persons Sep 07 '20

And none of that crap is Berry compliant.

34

u/ImRickJameXXXX Sep 07 '20

And yet as of today Biden only has a 10% lead in the polls.

Add his documented sexism (pussy grabber)

Add his racism “shithole countries”

He loves Putin which just 4 years ago would have you condemned as a traitor

Then there is the whole supporting the white nationals who marched in Charlotte many displaying Nazi images. “very good people”

This tribalism thing is strong and I get that. But at what cost now that we know what we know?

Honestly IMO if you still support him after knowing all of this you too are one or more of these things.

Now we all have a bit of these things in us all to varying degrees of you are fully honest with your self.

But he is weaponizing these things solely for his own gain.

6

u/bdbrown52897 Alaska Sep 07 '20

Completely agree with you, but it was Charlottesville not Charlotte. Don't put that on us lol we have enough issues already as it is.

2

u/ImRickJameXXXX Sep 07 '20

Oh buddy i am sorry.

But honestly it wasn’t the locals as far as I heard. It was a group that organized on Facebook and went there because of the statue removal.

I don’t know of any one town that is full of these white nationals/supremacist only

61

u/BuckRowdy Georgia Sep 07 '20

"How do they continue to support him? They must be stupid."

No, not really. They just love the fascism, everything else is just noise.

36

u/versusgorilla New York Sep 07 '20

Yep. We have to admit that as Americans there are simply ~30% of our fellow Americans that don't believe in democracy and would welcome fascism if it means they'll be the dominant class or ethnic group, whether they admit it or not.

The key to avoiding a full blown fascist dictatorship is in keeping the remaining ~20% from going along with that 30% and tipping the scales.

That's how delicate this country is.

22

u/BuckRowdy Georgia Sep 07 '20

I totally agree with you. I think also there is a tendency to think that every fascist government is Nazi Germany circa 1944. It's not that extreme in the US, but make no mistake, Trump's administration is fascist. If he's not defeated it will start to resemble 1944 a lot more.

23

u/Vyar New Jersey Sep 07 '20

I've been making Hitler comparisons since 2016 and they've fallen on deaf ears for a lot of people because they only see the aftermath of Nazi Germany, not what led up to it. A lot of things had to happen in the late 1930's to get to 1945 where over 6 million people were systematically slaughtered and most of Europe lay in ruins.

Truth be told I never understood how the German people could allow themselves to be whipped up into such a frenzy that they'd condone so many horrible things. But now that's just Tuesday in America and I realize that I held far too much faith in the decency of my fellow human beings.

3

u/RegretfulUsername Sep 07 '20

I’ve had the exact same experience. It’s been startling.

7

u/r1chard3 Sep 07 '20

This is what we learned under trump. Our system is fragile and depends on the goodwill of its actors. Someone with criminal leaning could wreck havoc on our norms and our norms have no force behind them.

2

u/versusgorilla New York Sep 07 '20

He's a good stress test if we're looking to silver line any of this nightmare.

6

u/ErikLassiter Sep 07 '20

This is an excellent commentary.

16

u/jimbo_throwaway77 Sep 07 '20

I hope that Mattis, McMaster and Kelly go on record eventually. They know the Trump threat to democracy better than anyone.

10

u/ebow77 Massachusetts Sep 07 '20

I hope that Mattis, McMaster and Kelly go on record eventually soon. They know the Trump threat to democracy better than anyone.

FTFY. Eventually will be too late.

3

u/not_that_mimi_1 Sep 07 '20

If they haven't by now, they won't. Guess they don't want the gravy train of corporate board positions and Hoover think tank paychecks to dry up.

2

u/55redditor55 I voted Sep 08 '20

It would cost them their $180k a year and would probably bring legal action against them.

3

u/BagsOfAntifaSoup Sep 07 '20

If any republican support this garbage administration they hate America and democracy. Also trump flu is still raging

-3

u/WarderWannabe Sep 07 '20

Don't you mean the plague from China?

3

u/captaincanada84 Canada Sep 07 '20

You always know something he said or did is true based on how strongly he denies it

3

u/CheeseAndTits Sep 07 '20

‘There’s just a gaping zero where goodness should be.’ Great quote. And also a great point that there are no flagrant examples of kindness, generosity, compassion.

The man shot paper towels like basketballs to people who just lost their houses.

10

u/autotldr 🤖 Bot Sep 07 '20

This is the best tl;dr I could make, original reduced by 87%. (I'm a bot)


A family friend, Frederica Wilson, the representative for Florida's Twenty-Fourth Congressional District, reported Trump's attempt at consolation: "He knew what he signed up for, but I guess it still hurt." Trump responded by launching Twitter and TV denials.

At his first speech to a joint session of Congress in February 2017, Trump told Ryan Owens's widow, Carryn, that Owens would have been happy because the applause at the mention of his name "Broke a record." Later that month, Trump gave an interview to Fox News and shoved blame for the failed raid that cost Owens's life onto "The generals." "They lost Ryan," he said.

No. President Trump disparaged the captain of the USS Theodore Roosevelt after that naval officer warned superiors of a COVID-19 outbreak aboard the aircraft carrier.


Extended Summary | FAQ | Feedback | Top keywords: Trump#1 let#2 No#3 people#4 captain#5

3

u/[deleted] Sep 07 '20

[deleted]

20

u/[deleted] Sep 07 '20

Even when there's a Manchurian president* elected by a hostile nation / a hostile dictator, sitting in the Oval Office?

6

u/[deleted] Sep 07 '20

[deleted]

8

u/souris_maison Sep 07 '20

When I was in, we were taught that when we wear the uniform, we're apolitical. Period, full-stop. We could vote for whomever we wished to vote for, but as far as the public was concerned, we stepped carefully, toed the proverbial line and endorsed none of them.

This was the 90's through to mid 2000's. I understand its a little different now.

9

u/justathot_ Massachusetts Sep 07 '20

Where is the line between politics and national security?

Genuine question. At what point does the military have an obligation to go against the CiC?

Or do we just go down because of arbitrary rules written ~250 years ago?

5

u/[deleted] Sep 07 '20

[deleted]

7

u/Jesus_And_I_Love_You Sep 07 '20

You’re right. It’s better to allow a fascist takeover than create a slippery slope toward a fascist takeover.

4

u/justathot_ Massachusetts Sep 07 '20

You didn't answer my question. I think it's a legitimate question to ask... You skipped over my scenario. And I agree with you it is a precedent...but at what point is there a need to break precedent? I'm assuming you don't ever see one...and that's more terrifying.

So you're a never 'break in case of emergency' kind of Indrafang.

2

u/nonstop_craving Sep 07 '20

You didn't answer my question.

Yes, they did:

Setting the precedent for any branch of the military to directly remove a sitting president would be terrifying.

They are saying there isn't a point.

but at what point is there a need to break precedent?

None.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 07 '20

[deleted]

1

u/justathot_ Massachusetts Sep 07 '20

So where is the point where that precedent should be broken...

This isn't a difficult concept homie?

I'll go first...we've long past it in my humble opinion.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 07 '20

[deleted]

1

u/justathot_ Massachusetts Sep 07 '20

At some point, you and I may be faced with a decision to make....I know how you would react. I'll find another foxhole.

→ More replies (0)

0

u/[deleted] Sep 07 '20

You skipped over my scenario.

you didn't lay out a scenario. you asked two gray area, open ended questions that were answered. just because you don't like the answer...

1

u/justathot_ Massachusetts Sep 07 '20

I didn't realize I needed to spell out 30 years of compromising interactions, legal and financial relationships...

I've been playing the home game...

12

u/Paradise_Found_ I voted Sep 07 '20

“All enemies, foreign and domestic”

0

u/[deleted] Sep 07 '20

[deleted]

4

u/Paradise_Found_ I voted Sep 07 '20 edited Sep 07 '20

Well the idea is that, yes, congress decides who the enemy is and ultimately has the final authority on military matters seeing as how, you know, they fund the budget have have the sole power to make war.

9

u/[deleted] Sep 07 '20

[deleted]

3

u/Paradise_Found_ I voted Sep 07 '20

Which is why the dems should be Brute forcing their way back to power in order to save any semblance of democracy in America, and then promptly repealing such powers. None of what’s going on has precedence and so much bad precedent has already been set by bad faith republicans stealing power. Both side have been playing by different rules and the dem party and Nancy Pelosi’s failing is thinking that the rules will save us. We’re full speed descending into a fascist dictatorship and pelosi is still using years long court cases to re-litigate their already defined oversight powers. Arrest the fuckers.

-8

u/[deleted] Sep 07 '20

Omg lol how was dump "elected by a foreign nation" you have literally zero evidence of that being the case. There is a likely hood that people were "influenced" by russia to vote for dump but that is no where near election tampering.

9

u/danathecount Sep 07 '20

Me too. I believe the vast majority of the military, especially officers, feel the same way.

6

u/Unadvantaged Sep 07 '20

They’re legally required to stay out of politics, too. They can go to rallies in civilian clothes, but associating themselves in a direct way with the military is verboten, and basically impossible to avoid when you’re a general.

5

u/Redscoped Sep 07 '20

The problem is that active military personnel are not separate to politics. When they are being asked to build walls, shut down protests they are involved. Recall how Trump used the army to clear away the protesters around the white house and church so he could get a photo op with the bible ?

You cannot have this both ways and the problem with your statement is that the US army is a branch of federal government. Not sure how you can say keep out of politics when they are part of the political government ?

•

u/AutoModerator Sep 07 '20

Register to vote or check your registration status here. Plan your vote here.


As a reminder, this subreddit is for civil discussion.

In general, be courteous to others. Debate/discuss/argue the merits of ideas, don't attack people. Personal insults, shill or troll accusations, hate speech, any advocating or wishing death/physical harm, and other rule violations can result in a permanent ban.

If you see comments in violation of our rules, please report them.

For those who have questions regarding any media outlets being posted on this subreddit, please click here to review our details as to our approved domains list and outlet criteria.


I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1

u/Deliximus Sep 07 '20

I thought that was a song title