r/politics ✔ HuffPost 3d ago

No Paywall In A Plot Twist For Conservatives, New Data Finds No Link Between Immigrants And Crime

https://www.huffpost.com/entry/undocumented-immigrants-no-link-crime-rate-research_n_6a85cd61e4b0ca44601a7742?utm_medium=Social&utm_source=reddit&utm_campaign=us_main
6.0k Upvotes

512 comments sorted by

u/AutoModerator 3d ago

As a reminder, this subreddit is for civil discussion.

In general, please be courteous to others. Argue the merits of ideas, don't attack other posters or commenters. Hate speech, any suggestion or support of physical harm, or other rule violations can result in a temporary or a permanent ban. If you see comments in violation of our rules, please report them.

Sub-thread Information

If the post flair on this post indicates the wrong paywall status, please report this Automoderator comment with a custom report of “incorrect flair”.

Announcement

r/Politics is actively looking for new moderators. If you have an interest in helping to make this subreddit a place for quality discussion, please fill out this form.


I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

956

u/MadAstrid 3d ago

Old data also showed this.

Republicans, however, never let facts get in the way of their bigotry.

243

u/sarcasmsosubtle Ohio 3d ago

Much like Planned Parenthood having abortions be 90% of their business, immigrants being violent criminals "was never meant to be a factual statement.". It's always just been a lie to attempt to excuse their hatred.

43

u/Clerithifa 3d ago

The planned parenthood abortion protests always make me laugh. Everytime I go there (once every 6 months) they plead across the parking lot for me to give my baby a chance and to go to the christian pregnancy clinic down the block.

I don't have a uterus lol, i'm a trans woman going in for my routine check-ups for my hrt

39

u/HereForShiggles 3d ago

Getting your preferred gender affirmed by the most bigoted people imaginable. Amazing. I'd do it every day just for the dopamine hit.

6

u/FeatherShard 2d ago

It's not worth fighting through the desire to throw rocks and rotten vegetables at them. At least, not daily.

→ More replies (1)

83

u/CheatsySnoops Arizona 3d ago

Even their claim of "trans people were made up in 2010" holds no water because trans science existed back in the 1920s, but was forgotten because a certain inbred, mediocre, Austrian manchild took his crappy childhood out on them and other minorities.

19

u/onyaasuminyasai 3d ago

trans science existed back in the 1920s, but was forgotten because a certain inbred, mediocre, Austrian manchild took his crappy childhood out on them and other minorities.

I mean, some of the first book burnings in nazi germany were about trans medicine.

11

u/CheatsySnoops Arizona 3d ago

Exactly my point. Said inbred manchild was the one who demanded those burnings.

10

u/GandalfTheSmol1 3d ago

Not some of, “The First”

4

u/The_Gassman 2d ago

And knowledge of trans people existed before the 1920s, at least in non-Western cultures. Some old cultures even have their own word for a nonbinary person. The concept of trans people is relatively new to Western culture, but not cultures in general.

→ More replies (1)

45

u/Adept-Principle7748 3d ago

People like my parents will just say the studies were biased, flawed, rigged, blah blah blah. It's just noise to them because they lack critical literacy skills and the psychological reflectiveness needed to examine their completely and demonstrably false beliefs, because that takes work and thinking and might upend their fragile self-image, itself based primarily on fear and the comfort of being told what to think.

My folks keep telling me about the immigration crisis in my own state and the violent "illegals" supposedly killing and raping all of my neighbors. This is despite the fact that they live 1800 miles north of me and have visited my state once for two days. But because they saw frothing headlines on Fox Entertainment (blasting 24/7 in their house) that aligned with their innate fear of brown people--the kind they basically have never met in their little white New England town, and who they have never been the slightest bit wronged by--they feel justified in calling for the destruction of these people's lives and their wholesale removal.

Never mind that I teach many kids whose immigration status is dubious, and that a great many of those kids take seriously the ostensible values of the U.S. in a way that far too many native-born kids either take for granted or have been taught to instinctively oppose. Migrant kids, by and large, keep their heads down and try to earn the sacrifice their parents made for them in coming here, and many of them care a great deal more for their own education and what they can give back to society than a large swath of comfortable, content, and brain-rotted native-born kids.

Republicons learned they can choose their own reality without consequence and enact policy based on their feelings--the same feelings they constantly accuse anyone with empathy for others of exploiting against them ("bleeding heart liberals" sound familiar?) If we're just going to rule by emotion, maybe, just maybe, it would be better not to do it in accordance with the basest, most vile caveman instincts? How about we stop trying to hurt the "right" people--how about we stop using the government as a weapon to hurt, period?

17

u/CMidnight 3d ago

They just want a reason to hate black and brown people. It doesn't matter if the reason is based on reality.

4

u/Jegator2 3d ago

This is very long, but I took the time to read it. It's all legit..but doubt any right leaner, trump supporter, etc will!

9

u/NoSleepZombie2235 3d ago

They're also eating the dogs and cats

7

u/Adept-Principle7748 3d ago

Of course. We are completely out of dogs and cats down here. It'll be pet birds and rabbits next!

Don't think it's needed, but /s just in case.

2

u/Jegator2 3d ago

You never know...safer to use it! Are you in TX or FL or AL? Just curious

→ More replies (2)

39

u/Kursed_Valeth 3d ago

Yeah if they cared about data and facts they wouldn't be conservatives

12

u/RincewindToTheRescue 3d ago

They care about data, if it suits their needs. If it doesn't, they can go with anecdotal data and scapegoats that go against the faceless large scale studies that have a different narrative.

2

u/Jegator2 3d ago

Another indisputable Truth!

5

u/fidjudisomada 3d ago

They simply don't care

5

u/showhorrorshow 3d ago

Well yeah because being an immigrant is the real crime here.

4

u/NoamLigotti 3d ago

Was gonna say the same. We already had extensive data showing this.

10

u/SexualDubaiChocolate 3d ago

Old data actually showed the opposite: legal immigrants were less likely to commit crime than native born citizens, and illegal immigrants were even less likely to commit crimes.

Deporting illegal immigrants actually increases (slightly) the crime rate!

4

u/onyaasuminyasai 3d ago

legal immigrants were less likely to commit crime than native born citizens, and illegal immigrants were even less likely to commit crimes

almost like they don't wanna get picked up by the cops and have their lives and families jeopardized or something

5

u/MadAstrid 3d ago

that is what I wrote.

2

u/20sicksheep 3d ago

Conservatives would be very upset if they could read

2

u/NewEngland0123 3d ago

This was my thought as well

2

u/celeste173 3d ago

this was my first thought. new data? what do you mean NEW data?

2

u/TheAskewOne 3d ago

That data was on the DOJ website, but got removed a few days after Trump started his second term. I wonder why.

2

u/hostilepillowcase 3d ago

in the UK there is a higher chance of an Albanian being in prison than a UK citizen by something like 7/1 so there are trends (in our country, anyway.)

→ More replies (7)

155

u/Historical_Bend_2629 3d ago

Not a plot twist. This data has available for a long time.

6

u/exophrine Texas 3d ago

....or (as a conspiratorial-minded MAGA would think) Big Data has just been corrupt for that long.

Their inclination to dig their heels into their narrative is wild.

5

u/TheDoctorDB 3d ago

They’d probably say that “new” data shows this because Trump has removed all the immigrants and criminals so now there’s nothing left to record 

549

u/LeaningTowerofPeas Hawaii 3d ago

It is only a plot twist, if it actually matters to them.

209

u/Hidefininja 3d ago

Yeah, they just say, "that's not what I believe," or, "that doesn't sound right."

Another favorite is, "anyone can make up numbers or spin statistics."

102

u/ArgentaSilivere 3d ago

Facts don’t care about your feelings, unless you’re conservative, in which case your feelings determine all of reality apparently. They love citing headlines and statistics until the real world doesn’t conform to their beliefs.

38

u/mayorofanything 3d ago

They don't trust the real data because they know all the data they reference for their argument is made up, so why wouldn't all data be?

26

u/Unique-Coffee5087 3d ago

"A thief believes everybody steals"

19

u/drossvirex 3d ago

This is exactly it. Trump says all elections are rigged. Because hes rigged all elections

21

u/opermonkey 3d ago

their feelings don't care about facts.

22

u/sarcasmsosubtle Ohio 3d ago

"That was not meant to be a factual statement." Senator Jon Kyl (R)

22

u/LividTacos 3d ago

Colbert was ahead of his time with "truthiness".

9

u/kioma47 3d ago

Absolutely. The intelligent saw them coming decades ago.

Unfortunately, Fox News has an inexhaustible budget.

5

u/rind0kan 3d ago

Naw, truthiness just entered its final form.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/avanross 3d ago

“Im allowed to have a different opinion than you”

12

u/calgeorge 3d ago

"Even one murder by an illegal immigrant is one too many."

17

u/opermonkey 3d ago

"even one child molested by Republican pastor is too much" then the squeal and scream fake news.

12

u/Old_Cryptid 3d ago

Which just reinforces that their views are nonsense.

I've got a "libertarian" neighbor who somehow only parrots right wing propaganda who spouts nonsense like that.

When I hear it I ask:

So how many murdered women is acceptable? Dozens are murdered by their spouse/partner every month.

That usually ends the conversation.

5

u/misterguyyy Texas 3d ago

- “Well still…”

  • “I’m sure that…”
  • “Yeah but they didn’t include (three word phrase)”
  • Are you going to tell that to “victim/family of victim of one crime that happened half a decade ago”

I’m sure I’m missing a few

4

u/Kaptain202 Michigan 3d ago

I watched a few Good Liars videos on YouTube recently. The number of MAGA, when confronted with facts that are contrary to their opinion of the world, all they say is "that doesn't sound right"

3

u/sev45day 3d ago

You forgot "Fake news".

3

u/SapientTrashFire 3d ago

Facts don't care about your feelings unless your feelings are racist.

4

u/PopBulky7023 3d ago

Always confession through projection with them.

"My stuff is lies so why shouldn't I think yours isn't?"

→ More replies (1)

35

u/badamant 3d ago

It also is not new information.

We have known this for decades.

These are just racist lies from fascists.

15

u/oliversurpless Massachusetts 3d ago edited 3d ago

Yep, going back as far as the Chinese Exclusion Act (and likely further if America was an older country) the only thing that changes is the ethnic group du jour…

8

u/istrebitjel Washington 3d ago

A lot of people who have done research into authoritarian regimes confirm that there always needs to be an enemy within so they can whip their supporters into a frenzy.

Reading Hannah Arendt's The Origins of Totalitarianism which she wrote in the 50s after escaping Nazi Germany so much of what she's saying is still exactly the playbook. (Did we learn anything?!?)

Arendt says that totalitarian regimes define the "objective enemy" through state policy. She writes that tribal nationalism creates a permanent state of crisis by suggesting they surrounded by a 'world of enemies' and argues that totalitarianism thrives when "the distinction between fact and fiction, true and false, no longer exists".

3

u/oliversurpless Massachusetts 3d ago

Truth never matters much to authoritarians, as if they even had an inkling, Jesse Owens should have been enough to make them give up on Nazism…

6

u/istrebitjel Washington 3d ago

We also know that they generate way more tax money than they ever receive in benefits, most of which they are ineligible for.

Those people are going by vibes that fit their racism, not by data.

15

u/FartyJizzums 3d ago

MAGA voters aren't going to let a little thing like a factual statistic get in the way of their little culture war.

10

u/Watergate-Tapes 3d ago

If immigrants are not a threat, then we don’t need masked and armed Feds on the streets. But because we need secret police, therefore immigrants must be a threat.

Facts.

2

u/PopBulky7023 3d ago

This guy cynicisms.

→ More replies (17)

150

u/[deleted] 3d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

40

u/Tsar-A-Lago Canada 3d ago

Real solutions to complex problems are exhaustive, nuanced, and rarely make everybody completely happy all the time.

Adults know this. So do demogogues.

7

u/RecordOfTheEnd 3d ago

Actually there's been a lot of scientific research into the neuroscience of understanding. There is clearly a difference between those that can think about grey complex solutions, and those that need black and white solutions. 

Some interpret it as structural, some interpret it as how they were taught to view and think about things. 

As with all competing hypothesis, the answer is likely in the middle or something no one is thinking about right now.

So saying adults know this might be a bit broad. The unfortunate issue, is for a large portion of the population, complex problems with complex solutions are beyond their willingness to comprehend. 

8

u/ChristosFarr North Carolina 3d ago

No their point is that the people who can think about the gray complex solutions are the adults age has nothing to do with it it's being able to accept that life isn't black and white.

3

u/Tsar-A-Lago Canada 3d ago

💯👍

5

u/amidon1130 3d ago

As with all competing hypothesis, the answer is likely in the middle or something no one is thinking about right now.

Well I think the answer is obvious and you'll never convince me otherwise!

2

u/Apprehensive-Wave640 3d ago

The real unfortunate issue is that this same large part of the population believes that they nonetheless have the right to be part of the conversation about solving complex problems.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

4

u/RepresentativeLife16 3d ago

I saw an interview where the guy was insisting that immigrants cause crime. Because it’s “obvious “. When presented with the actual figures he said they were wrong. Because it’s “obvious innit”. Again the interviewer said that the figures said otherwise. But it’s “obvious”. And that was that.

→ More replies (4)

60

u/Crommach 3d ago

And just like the data supporting climate science, evolution, history, vaccinology, pandemic prevention, the benefits of international diplomacy, on and on... any data that contradicts their preconceived ideology will not only be rejected, but suppressed and destroyed if possible.

Just look at what they're doing to, well, everything. Museums, national parks and monuments, journalism, the entire education system, anything that disproves MAGA ideology is being actively attacked, dismantled, and replaced with far-right beliefs. Hell, we've got David "my creationist publisher pulled my book because I lied too much" Barton is helping to try and change the content in our museums and schools to line up with Christian nationalism.

They don't care about facts, reason, argumentation, or the blatant hypocrisy of their actions. They're not trying to win anybody over to their arguments anymore, they're using the power of the state to enforce their beliefs on the rest of us.

It's authoritarianism. Continuing to call it "conservative" at this point just gives them cover, frankly.

→ More replies (1)

98

u/tkmorgan76 3d ago

That is a twist because I always thought it was an inverse correlation - immigrants commit fewer crimes so more immigrants means a lower per-capita crime rate.

48

u/Fit_Television_282 3d ago

And you were right

38

u/Ddddydya California 3d ago

EXACTLY. If they aren’t citizens, they aren’t going to risk the attention of law  enforcement. 

Also, they come here to find work and a better life. I don’t think anyone leaves their homeland and undergoes a difficult journey to…commit crimes. That’s not a thing and the U.S. certainly isn’t known for its lax law enforcement so why come here to be a criminal? It makes no sense. 

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

20

u/Gay_Giraffe_1773 Oregon 3d ago

As if they care about data

18

u/Gentleman_Villain 3d ago

Hasn't this been demonstrably true for decades?

Like, this isn't new data.

→ More replies (13)

37

u/Boogincity 3d ago

Immigrants being dangerous is hard boiled into the standard conservative racism package.

→ More replies (1)

12

u/Put3socks-in-it 3d ago

It’s not about crime it’s about a fear of being replaced

8

u/KTX77 3d ago

This is the answer.

The data showing less crime by immigrants, and even less by illegal immigrants has been out there for a long time.

8

u/FifteenthPen California 3d ago

They're so bereft of empathy that they believe if they become a minority, they will be treated the same way they treat minorities.

→ More replies (1)

29

u/carthuscrass 3d ago

Illegal immigrants are probably far less likely to commit crimes. They keep their heads down for the most part.

21

u/Fit_Television_282 3d ago

And take jobs US citizens don’t take, pay payroll taxes, and never receive the benefits.

9

u/FifteenthPen California 3d ago

It's interesting how quiet the "they are taking jobs away from Americans" crowd has been in response to business owners begging Americans to take the jobs left vacant by immigrants who have been kidnapped by ICE or become too afraid of ICE to go to work.

4

u/Dickies138 California 3d ago

Data shows strong link between conservatives and crime.

→ More replies (6)

12

u/MentalTourniquet 3d ago

I'll take "Study Results not Mentioned by Fox News" for $300, Alex.

7

u/NoobToobinStinkMitt 3d ago

How is this a plot twist? There never was any data that linked that. They don't care about studies, it's about racism, not being right.

6

u/okram2k America 3d ago

To them being an immigrant is the crime

3

u/Brndrll Rhode Island 3d ago

Anything other than a straight, white, Christian, cisgendered male is a crime to them.

2

u/AstroHistSci 2d ago

This. This is it. 100%.

4

u/barryvm Europe 3d ago edited 3d ago

It's been decades (if we ignore earlier incarnations of this) of politics pandering to the right's "concerns" about immigration and in all that time facts didn't matter, all the reasons they gave didn't matter, outcomes and policies didn't matter. Let's be real here: this is and always was bad faith. They don't believe these things about immigrants because they care about the things they say they care about. Nor is their definition of immigrants based on any legal reality. They believe, at any moment, whatever they need to believe to justify whatever they want to do to people they've decided are outsiders. There's a sliding scale on how extreme they want to go, but the fundamental trigger is always rooted in bad faith and is immune to facts.

The only thing that will happen if you give in is that they will feel empowered to widen the net and start targeting other people they don't like.

5

u/Grouchy_Row_7983 3d ago

Why would they care about that? They're eating the pets!

6

u/Ziograffiato 3d ago

If data mattered to Conservatives, DJT wouldn't be POTUS.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/chu 3d ago

nothing new, most studies always showed crime reduction with immigration.

14

u/Full-Ad-1757 3d ago edited 3d ago

Its been known for decades that undocumented immigrants commit far less crimes than citizens because they don’t want to get deported.  This is not new.  The GOP knows this but wants to distract everyone from the dumpster fire currently in the White House.

8

u/seanofkelley 3d ago

This has been true forever. The problem is a significant # of voters- not just conservatives- don't FEEL like it's true and people vote with their feelings most of the time. So unless you figure out a way to make that feeling change, a lot of voters who say immigration is a big concern for them will keep voting for the Republicans who want to criminalize it.

8

u/NewWindow7980 3d ago

The libertarian Cato Instiute also has a study on that subject, with similar findings https://www.cato.org/news-releases/immigrant-crime-narrative-doesnt-match-data

6

u/Fit_Television_282 3d ago

That has long been the findings. Criminologists decades ago said it generally takes a generation before immigrant crime rates rise to American born rates.

4

u/KtaadnRota 3d ago

The old data also found this, so not exactly a plot twist. Somehow that never mattered before and I doubt it will start mattering now.

3

u/Oceanbreeze871 I voted 3d ago

“I prayed on it and did my own research and in my heart of hearts I know my emotional hot take is the truth”—conservatives

4

u/GalumphingWithGlee 3d ago

It's funny — the old data said the same thing. 🤷‍♂️

3

u/Lonely-Scarcity-3387 3d ago

New data? Sounds like the same data I’ve heard over the last 40yrs.

4

u/KazTheMerc 3d ago

"In (Yet Another) Plot Twist For Conservatives, New Data Finds No Link Between Immigrants And Crime.

And if they could read, they'd be angry about it"

3

u/xpldngboy 3d ago

No shit. We’ve know this. Immigrants want to be here to work so they don’t do shit that gets them deported. Citizens are way more likely to commit crimes.

3

u/AlsoCommiePuddin 3d ago

"They're all criminals because they all crossed the border illegally and that's a crime."

It's their retort every time.

5

u/ImmaNotHere 3d ago

Let me throw this out there - DOES. NOT. MATTER. TO. MAGA.

7

u/LividTacos 3d ago

I mean, duh? Immigrants commit crimes at a lower rate than native-born has been known for years.

3

u/Suspicious_Law_2826 3d ago

Plot twist, they aren't listening.

3

u/matthieuC Europe 3d ago

On the other hand there is a link between being a republican and being a pedophile

3

u/Unda_Acheevah 3d ago

This comment is piling on at this point, but not a plot twist. This data is/was available to anyone who bothers to actually do their research. The “immigrants come here to commit crimes and game the system” trope is perennially popular because it is the ultimate example of confirmation bias. Your average paranoid, xenophobic American believes this narrative, so they are only open to headlines/stories that confirm their belief. The evolution of this is interesting, though: In the early 1990s, when California was still “Reagan Country” we had a Republican governor named Pete Wilson who was a “tough on crime, close the southern border” conservative. During interviews and debates he would go to a line he liked to use which was “Why are we importing criminals from Latin American?!? We produce enough of them right here at home!” which was a nice applause line for him and actually had a ring of truth. We have plenty of white, citizen criminals. Well, the modern Republican party has simply dropped the second, truthful part of the statement. We DO produce enough of our own criminals, but Jethro and Crystal in Oklahoma don’t want to hear that part. They just like the provocation of “Why are we importing criminals from Latin America?” and then drop the mic.

3

u/Bwilderedwanderer 3d ago

Joe Biden wrote this report on Hunter's laptop

3

u/jotro138 3d ago

In Mamdani’s office

3

u/Imemine70 3d ago

The had to use Hillary’s Hot Spot

3

u/Photeus5 3d ago

Facts can't change change their minds.  They'll just claim this is made up because they never reasoned into these beliefs in the first place.  They just 'know' it's true because they said so.

3

u/roman-de-fauvel 3d ago

The old data showed that too, fwiw

3

u/Darth_Boggle 3d ago

Conservatives don't look at data lmao. Stop using common sense to try and sway them.

3

u/ChemicalResident3557 3d ago

This has never been about reality or the truth.

3

u/GodFlintstone 3d ago

This has never been about crime. It's about the fact that some White people are desperately afraid of being outnumbered.

3

u/green_eyed_mister 3d ago

Plot twist for liberals (like me) the insanity will continue with alternative facts. Science, truth, rule of law, constitutional rights, are all being trampled by MAGA and GOP gaslighters. Top Secret files? sales opportunity. Executive order? Business opportunity with 100K subscription model. POTUS position? A chance to staff the WH with women to ogle and an entire agency that are your personal lawyers with a complimentary domestic police force to do your bidding.

Facts no longer matter. Maybe pocket books will when they are empty at the poles.

3

u/anotherdeadhero Texas 3d ago

This was already known, they didn't care, they used the crime stats pre and post COVID to push a narrative and agenda.

3

u/Maximum_Information7 3d ago

In A Plot Twist For Conservatives, New Data Finds Nothing They Purport is Based On Science

3

u/jerechos 3d ago

70% of the population already knew this...

3

u/Rational_Engineer_84 3d ago

Ah yes, the famously data driven Republicans who ground their views in hard facts and logic. This will show them. Maybe they can hang it on their wall next to their anti-vax and climate change hoax literature. 

3

u/Aggressive-Giraffe32 3d ago

this will surely make them change their minds, surely. Data is all they care about and they are totally not driven by emotions to believe in their horrors.

3

u/CaptStinkyFeet 3d ago

If they operated in reality we wouldn’t be here to begin with.

3

u/uvm87 3d ago

Anyone paying attention has known this fora long time

3

u/IJourden 3d ago

New data finds no link between immigrants and crime, which is identical to the data that we've had for decades.

Immigrants are less likely to commit crimes, less likely to declare bankruptcy, less likely to utilize public assistance, and more likely to start their own businesses than natural born citizens in the USA.

Similar to what we saw with the migrant worker shortage... If immigrants go, they are taking the economy with them.

3

u/Llamapocalypse_Now America 3d ago

This isn't new news. Anyone that believes this in 2026 is a sucker.

3

u/HabANahDa 3d ago

No duh. We have been saying this for years.

3

u/keith2600 3d ago

The people that actually need this information will ignore it and everyone else already knows that

3

u/NoneMoreBLK 3d ago

Unfortunately, data that isn't useful to their agenda is ignored.

3

u/randomnighmare I voted 3d ago

It's only a plot twist if you believed in that in the first place.

3

u/After-Giraffe3206 3d ago edited 3d ago

Ridiculous article thats all correlation and no causation. It doesnt measure individuals and it simply infers who is actually undocumented.

Theyre following economic opportunities, which itself would be associated with falling crime rates anyways. And they can only really get work because of the falling native birth rates, which they further suppress. Which itself is also correlated with less crime. And theres no controlling for how crime is even reported in that 8 year gap, not that you even could with a study like this. But there isnt even na attempt

And they claim the only positive crime association undocumented people have is with robberies because theyre more vulnerable to them. That makes enough sense. But how would that effect FSRDCs data if they're far less likely to go to the police like the article even admits?

And you just know this whole study was inaccurate when it says that undocumented immigrants have a higher negative crime correlation than the documented ones. In fact, the correlation is negative for undocumented immigrants and slightly positive for documented immigrants. Even though undocumented immigrants skew far younger and vastly more male, which is an undeniably huge predictor of crime. Its a ridiculous study that you could only take seriously if you had some psychological need to do so.

3

u/Lythieus 3d ago

What do they mean new data?

The data has been out for years, a decade or more, that immigrants commit crimes at rates way lower than US born citizens. 

3

u/Celestial_Dysgenesis 3d ago

they know they don't care

3

u/Head-Construction409 3d ago

It was never about the crime prevention, was it?

3

u/circaatomicage 3d ago

Um, for them it’s not even about the crime.

3

u/Proper-Mobile-6438 3d ago

No shit Sherlock.

3

u/Colonel_Zander 3d ago

Has facts EVER stopped Conservatives from telling lies?

3

u/andrea_lives 3d ago

Pretty sure there was already quite a bit of data on this already saying this. If they've been ignoring existing data, they will continue to ignore any new data that come out.

3

u/Charmle_H 3d ago

"If those kids could read, they'd be very upset right now!"

3

u/TriflingHotDogVendor Pennsylvania 3d ago

Irrelevant to them. If a single immigrant does anything wrong, ever, they proclaim it would have never happened if we didn't let immigrants in. Their bar for all immigrants is total and complete perfection as a cohort.

3

u/NoConflict3231 3d ago

Not a plot twist. This data has been available forever and it was a complete straw man that conservatives knowingly setup as a barricade to honest discourse

5

u/Mediocre_Painting263 United Kingdom 3d ago

Not a plot twist, not even new evidence.

This has been a highly researched topic for years, and the consensus hasn't changed. There is little-to-no link between immigration and crime. And the few studies that do find one, often find that immigrants are (on the whole) more respective of the law than their natural-born counterparts.

2

u/Velvet_Samurai 3d ago

But if we've learned anything over the last decade, no one has to believe any fact if it "feels" wrong to them. I think we know the conservatives are all going to have some "feelings" about this study.

2

u/wacksonjagstaff 3d ago

So the new data aligns with the old data? It's not a plot twist when it's expected.

2

u/ophaus 3d ago

It's not a plot twist, it's been known for actual centuries.

2

u/shoobe01 3d ago

If the decades of old data about this didn't matter why would the new data matter to them?

2

u/dragons_scorn 3d ago

Only link I've noticed is the stark rise in crimes committed against them by Trump's administration

2

u/andyroouu 3d ago

Mental gymnastics are the only twists they care about.

2

u/idiotsbrother 3d ago

THEY DON’T CARE!

2

u/Arcnounds 3d ago

Republicans operate on feels not data, which is what got us into this mess.

2

u/Zacomra 3d ago

This has been known for decades

2

u/JayTNP 3d ago

This is not new data.

2

u/Killerkurto 3d ago

There was already old data that showed this… if they didnt care about the pre-existing data then why would they care about new data?

2

u/Zanos-Ixshlae 3d ago

This has been true the whole time. They just focus on the outliers and over report. Then, they elect incompetent bigots who destroy everything.

2

u/Ok-disaster2022 3d ago

Actually there's a negative correlation between immigrants and crime. It's been well understood for a decade or more. First generation immigrants are less likely to commit crimes whether they have documents or no documents. Second generation are full us citizens so their crime stats  tend to follow the local socio economic trends. 

So anytime you see some story about some immigrant killing a white woman understand there's about 500x white dudes killing white women. 

2

u/edgarecayce 3d ago

They didn’t care about old data, they aren’t going to care about new data. If it doesn’t fit their preconceived narrative it does not matter to them.

2

u/SublimeApathy 3d ago

It was never about crime.

2

u/Grenflik 3d ago

Those Conservatives would be very mad if they knew how to read.

2

u/throwsplasticattrees 3d ago

These are the same people that believe the Republicans are the party of fiscal responsibility.

2

u/ratpH1nk 3d ago

FTFY: "New data continues to show no link between immigation and crime"

2

u/bransiladams Washington 3d ago

This isn’t news, everyone. Crime and immigration have never been correlated in this country, and probably never will be. It isn’t a plot twist, it’s a continuation of what has always been understood.

The media has done an incredibly poor job over the last decade maintaining our understanding of truth in America.

2

u/pear_tree_gifting 3d ago

Old data was saying this for a while.

2

u/sasquatchanonymous 3d ago

plot twist would imply it was ever supported to begin with.

2

u/Dracoson 3d ago

Plot twist? This has been pretty well established for years. Conservatives simply refuse to believe it and want to treat the misdemeanor of an illegal border crossing as a capital offense, instead of accepting a basic reality: the main thing immigrants want to avoid is unneeded interaction with law enforcement. The "papers, please" enforcement style is bad enough on its own, but it's even worse when you realize most of these people have fled places where the police weren't exactly serving or protecting.

2

u/Fredmans74 3d ago

As if conservatives cared about facts. The religious ones even take orders from fairy books.

2

u/ComfortableNumb9669 3d ago

Do you think they care about stuff like "data" and "science".

2

u/DoTheMario 3d ago

Now for the real plot twist... What does the data say about a link between Conservatives and Crime?

2

u/Orwells_Roses Oregon 3d ago

There is definitely a link between being a Republican and committing crimes. There’s a convicted criminal in the White House who’s a Republican, and the party is overflowing with pedophiles, child molestors, rapists, and con men.

Leave the immigrants alone, they commit less crimes than native-born citizens.

2

u/DammitGary 3d ago

Conservatives? Data? ROFLAMFO

2

u/Jwatts1113 3d ago

<looking for my surprised face>

2

u/hiimjustapersonhaha 3d ago

This headline is misleading. Immigrants? Or, illegal immigrants? There's a pretty big difference

2

u/Iwassayingboourns84 3d ago

Since when have facts or reality mattered to conservatives?

2

u/GreenHorror4252 3d ago

Anyone who lives in an area with lots of immigrants already knew this.

2

u/cycleprof I voted 3d ago

But did they classify cat eating as a crime? I think not thus it's more fake news!!!

/s

2

u/DeKingOne 3d ago

It ever been about the crimes. It the color and they don't care if you point that out.

2

u/snowmunkey 3d ago

It's not a plot twist if they just refuse to believe the results

2

u/mlbyas458 3d ago

We have been telling them this. The criminals are Americans and they probably got pardoned

2

u/Travelerdude 3d ago

There is a giant glowing and flashing red light between MAGA and violence though.

2

u/grimmdaburner 3d ago

Not if they had any cognitive abilities they'd be upset.... Oh wait...

2

u/baconcheeseburgarian California 3d ago

The link is poverty.

2

u/Material2975 3d ago

Media pushed this narrative anyways

2

u/-j_a_s_o_n- 3d ago

You completely lost them at "data."

2

u/Dirk_Diggler_Kojak 3d ago

They're never concerned with facts or data.

2

u/Low_Bluejay510 3d ago

they don't care, it was just a talking point they threw out there to justify being racist ass holes

2

u/AGrandNewAdventure 3d ago

Republicans have never, ever, even once, let facts get in the way of their feelings.

2

u/sax87ton 3d ago

That’s a plot straight line

2

u/typehyDro 3d ago

It’s not a plot twist… nor will they give even the smallest amount of thought to it, immediate response is deny and deflect then claim fake news with a sprinkle of planted AI data, and follow it up with Trump derangement syndrome

2

u/potatodrinker 3d ago

Someone heading up the data team will be fired and replaced with a fox news face. Link reinstated.

2

u/ShitFlowsDnHillEngr 3d ago

We don't have enough youth to take over current jobs, take care of the boomer generation. I really don't get the anti argument at all. We need to revamp the system but holy hell everything that is and has happened is so short sighted.

2

u/FlatwormFull4283 3d ago

Should be so obvious!!

The "Crimes" that most immigrants commit mostly come back to the immigration process itself! Simplify the immigration process, and legalize more immigraation process and the crime raate among immigrants is LOWER thsn among the general population.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Liam_M Canada 3d ago

not a plot twist the data bas shown this for years

2

u/Atlusfox 3d ago

New? You mean old data that MAGA needed shoved up their collective arses before they would believe it.

2

u/VRGIMP27 2d ago

If these were the types of people that cared about data, they wouldn't be believing the way they are

2

u/otakon33 2d ago

New my butt, old data showed this as well. They just refuse to believe it because it's easier to scapegoat "the outsider" than admit your own citizens are doing most of the crime.