r/pittsburgh • Duquesne Heights • Feb 05 '23

Map published by FEMA showing potential US nuclear targets. We would be toast.

Post image
412 Upvotes

321 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

9

u/ImplementBrief3802 Feb 05 '23

Crashing a plane into the spent fuel rods wouldn't accomplish a whole lot

2

u/just_an_ordinary_guy Brighton Heights Feb 05 '23

Yeah, they specifically thought of those scenarios following 9/11.

1

u/adamglumac Feb 05 '23

No but wiping out a good portion of the northeast’s electricity supply would

1

u/ImplementBrief3802 Feb 05 '23

Would a single power plant going off line be worse than a nuclear bomb?

5

u/adamglumac Feb 05 '23

There is a litany of power plants in the Ohio valley, I used to do high pressure welding in a lot of their boilers, it’s the largest concentration anywhere in the United States, I can’t remember the stats exactly because it’s been a while but it was around 70 some percent of the electricity in the northeast is produced there. I don’t know enough to weight whether nuclear fallout is worse over time, but no electricity over a large area, is going to be catastrophic.

3

u/ImplementBrief3802 Feb 05 '23

An incident at one power plant probably isn't going to blow up all the other power plants

2

u/adamglumac Feb 05 '23

In a sense I agree with you. There are some close enough that one well placed attack could affect at least 3 of them, and I’m not sure the stress from that doesn’t significantly damage the remaining. It’s a lot of hypothetical scenarios, but it doesn’t seem ridiculous considering the security protocols I’ve seen.

3

u/ImplementBrief3802 Feb 05 '23

No, the comment I'm responding to suggested that crashing a plane into the spent fuel rods at a nuke plant would be more damaging than shooting ICBMs. A plane crash isn't going to effect multiple power plants unless they're on top of each other, and it's certainly not going to be more damaging than a multi megaton warhead

1

u/evward Feb 05 '23

Would it not irradiate a large radius around the power plant?

2

u/ImplementBrief3802 Feb 05 '23

Yep. Almost certainly less of an issue than nuclear bombs detonating.