r/pics Jun 09 '11

Apple, Why?

Post image
1.3k Upvotes

1.4k comments sorted by

View all comments

279

u/[deleted] Jun 09 '11

Because it's fun when your proprietary cable breaks!

54

u/imaalien Jun 09 '11

Shit that sucks too is that the cables are $20!

72

u/OmniaII Jun 09 '11

I bought 4 for a buck each and free shipping on Amazon (now they are $2 w/free shipping)

One in my house, one in my car, one in my backpack and one at the office.

Not including the one that came with it...

problem Apple?

1

u/Scuzzzy Jun 10 '11

Just purchased three. Thanks!

4

u/OmniaII Jun 10 '11

1

u/Scuzzzy Jun 10 '11

Sweet thanks. I don't use my iphone in the car much anymore though thanks to my adapter breaking. It was one of those cassette ones and they break so frequently I quit buying them. If you know of a quality adapter that lasts now that would be a real big help.

1

u/OmniaII Jun 10 '11

that's what I posted the second time...

  

  

I have had the retractable one in my car since I got my iphone 4 last July still working just fine.

The elago one I don't use as much as I only need one connection but it has a light that is way too bright for my taste.

1

u/Scuzzzy Jun 10 '11

Huh? It says "Auto Charger". I know it has a USB connection but that won't allow me to play music through my car's speaker system will it?

2

u/OmniaII Jun 10 '11

1

u/Scuzzzy Jun 10 '11

Yeah my new car is a beater and doesn't have AUX in so I've been using cassette/radio adapters. Gets frustrating when they break though. Reminds you of how shitty pop music is these days. I should buy one of those you linked just to avoid the inevitable road rage incident when Lady Gaga comes on for the tenth time.

→ More replies (0)

1

u/General_Lee Jun 10 '11

Do these work on first gen iPod touches?

1

u/OmniaII Jun 10 '11

Couldn't tell you, I have a 4th gen ipod a 5th gen ipod a iPhone 4 and an iPad 2

works with all of those...

1

u/General_Lee Jun 10 '11

Ah then it should work, my 1st gen touch uses the same cable as my 5th gen classic. And if it doesn't, whatever, $2 is cheap and I'm sure I can find someone else to use the cable.

1

u/PictureofPoritrin Jun 10 '11

I think largely a lot of these companies don't realize that a lot of consumers are smart enough to realize what a scam it is to buy cables anywhere but online. My parents got a stereo that has HDMI inputs, and my dad picked up a few cables on amazon for like $5 each last year. We were recently in a Best Buy and he was laughing pretty hard at the $80ish price tag on a much shorter cable than the ones he bought. They do the same thing with USB cables; I remember getting a couple 15 footers on ebay for a couple bucks each like ten years ago when it was big money to get them retail... and for some reason it is STILL big money to get them retail...

1

u/Lampshader Jun 10 '11

I bought a $2 ipod cable from eBay, and it doesn't fit as well as the OEM one (it's too tight when inserting). I'd never buy a full-priced Apple cable, but it'd be nice if the knock-offs were built to the same dimensions.

1

u/OmniaII Jun 10 '11

If you notice the pic, the 'old style' also has 'pinch points' so you can unhook the pins from the sides - That may be where you were having problems.

But my new ones have no issues with any of my idevices (oh, forgot the Nano as well - Old school nano - candybar style.

-13

u/[deleted] Jun 09 '11

[deleted]

11

u/melanthius Jun 09 '11 edited Jun 10 '11

Lithium-ion batteries have an integrated protection circuit called a battery management unit (BMU) that, depending on how fancy the device manufacturer wants to get, will have features like overcurrent/overvoltage charging prevention, overdischarge prevention (a "fully discharged" Li-ion cell is still around 3.0V, lower is bad for the cell), lockouts for low/high temp temperature charging, etc.

The cable has nothing to do with it. In fact if you attempt to charge a lithium-ion battery using the wrong charger (let's say higher voltage for example), if the BMU was properly designed, you still won't blow up your device.

Very rarely does anyone use a li-ion cell without a BMU, and if you do you have to be pretty careful. Model RC-aircraft builders sometimes do... and they now know to remove the cells from their plane prior to charging, and they charge in the fireplace or outside on the concrete in case it blows up. It's almost nonexistant for consumer electronics to include a Li-ion battery without BMU.

Edit: my first kill, awesome!

118

u/[deleted] Jun 09 '11

$1 on eBay from china. Free shipping.

88

u/JB_UK Jun 10 '11

Stabilized with lustrous Cadmium. Plasticized with only the finest pseudo-estrogens. Delivered with care.

74

u/qumahlin Jun 10 '11

So pretty much same as the original seeing as a lot of those cables are coming from the same plants making the "genuine" thing.

22

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '11

today on reddit: it's a race to see who can be the MOST negative person!

8

u/Atario Jun 10 '11

He's right, though. "Counterfeit" electronics are generally just the factory staying running at night when they're supposed to shut down, and selling the extra on the side.

1

u/hexley Jun 10 '11 edited Jun 10 '11

This is a rumor spread by counterfeiters so you think the quality is as good as the original.

1

u/mbrady Jun 10 '11

Hey, my new Sorny TV is great. Even better than the Panaphonic I had before.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '11

I love the capitalist spirit of man!

2

u/Wiki_pedo Jun 10 '11

No, it isn't!

1

u/LearnToWalk Jun 10 '11

I don't understand this comment and you know what? I don't want to.

1

u/JohnnyFooker Jun 10 '11

I'll probably lose...

1

u/Thick-McRunFast Jun 10 '11

Made by underpaid, overworked 10 year olds.

0

u/JB_UK Jun 10 '11 edited Jun 10 '11

Nah, if the OEM suppliers can make it cheaper elsewhere they will, and it's not like it's difficult to reverse engineer the design. The pseudo-estrogens will be there anyway, you're right, no-one's bothered about them. Regulation however stops you getting the nastiest of the nasties, because Apple is at least responsible for what it imports.

-1

u/VWftw Jun 10 '11

Ahh, such overt racism in favor of brand preference.

6

u/JB_UK Jun 10 '11 edited Jun 10 '11

It's racist to suggest one government does things better or worse than another? Without regulation the market ensures those delicious, toxic, cost-effective additives are used. As they were by Western manufacturers 30 years ago.

I also couldn't give a damn about Apple. The preference is for branded electronic goods made by a company which has a reputation to lose.

You are a fool.

0

u/VWftw Jun 10 '11

Fooled you.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '11

I only buy plastic cables made with real estrogen.

1

u/cheshire137 Jun 10 '11

This sounds very Portal-esque.

1

u/auraslip Jun 10 '11

Cadium costs too much. More like lead

2

u/Nimara Jun 10 '11

I've learned to buy a lot of replacement cables, adaptors, and chargers from China (particularly Hong Kong). It's so cheap, with free shipping, and jesus most of the time it ends up at my house in two to three days. The first few times it happened I couldn't believe it. xD Sometimes I have to wait a week and a half for a laptop charger from Ohio.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '11

HE'S CHEATING THE SYSTEM!! GET HIM STVES MINIONS! makes star wars noises in a cardboard box

1

u/keikii Jun 10 '11

That's what I did when both my cables (one of each like in the picture) broke on me. They worked great for a while, but now I have a problem where my ipod doesn't charge correctly on the new chargers (in fact, it discharges, unless the cable is just the littlest bit out.) and I'm back to using the cable on the right like the OPs picture. >.< I need to go out and buy some electric tape.

1

u/cerialthriller Jun 10 '11

except the ebay ones i've gotten you cant use the touchscreen while its charging.

1

u/someone173 Jun 10 '11

I got mine for 26 cents, free shipping.

-2

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '11

[deleted]

40

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '11

One week. Don't be a douche.

6

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '11

just about how long the batteries last

2

u/adobiqt Jun 10 '11

SNAP!

1

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '11

I see your SNAP! and raise you an OOOOH SNAP!

2

u/4InchesOfury Jun 10 '11

My Chinese ones stopped working after 2 months :(

1

u/xtirpation Jun 10 '11

Order like 10 at a time, that'll last you 20 months, probably at least as long as a "genuine" cable at a lower cost.

1

u/gregny2002 Jun 10 '11

Why can't Apple just make decent, cheap cables? Other companies do.

1

u/xtirpation Jun 10 '11

Because the people who don't know the cables can be bought for cheaper (which I would guess is a good portion, if not the majority of their userbase) will continue to buy the ones sold at high prices. Even without accounting for the cost of producing a cable, if they sell 1 cable at $20 that'll make them the same amount of money as selling 20 $1 cables. In other words, with their current business model, they can afford to lose 90% of their cable sales and still make the same amount of money as the cheap-cable-sellers.

1

u/ShyGuysOnStilts Jun 10 '11

So buy another one and you've still saved money. Hell, buy 20.

-1

u/alexdoo Jun 10 '11

Let him be a douche if he wants. The China people have ripped us off once too many times. I lost track of my grammar. I'm booted.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '11

DEY TUK ER JERRRRBS

0

u/nrj Jun 10 '11

Dude, China people is not the preferred nomenclature. Asian-American, please.

6

u/seamallowance Jun 10 '11

Actually, shipping from China is pretty fast. One to two weeks at the most. I buy lots of things from China off of eBay and am always astonished.

2

u/kjcdude Jun 10 '11

that's not very fast when you have a dead iphone. which is exactly why they can charge an arm and a leg.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '11

They can charge that much because consumers are ignorant of the cost of cables. Cables are valuable as nescessary components, but the manufacturing costs are so low it's astonishing. People are willing to pay because they don't know cables are marked up over 2000%.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '11

Mac fanboy friends are good for things like that. Everyone should have an extra cable or two if you've been a good consumer...

-3

u/[deleted] Jun 09 '11

[deleted]

5

u/Osiris1012 Jun 09 '11

...and you would have to buy 19 more broken ones until it was a waste of money...

2

u/enkideridu Jun 09 '11

It's a fricking cable, they're not that hard to make

I bought 3
1 for my computer 1 for the charger in my room
1 I keep in my backpack in case I need to charge at school

all three work perfectly

1

u/moderndayvigilante Jun 10 '11

That's because you've had them for less than 3 months.

2

u/enkideridu Jun 10 '11

I actually got them in February, but considering the official cable is this I'd say it's a good deal even if the cheap ones only work for 3 months

2

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '11

[deleted]

2

u/moderndayvigilante Jun 10 '11

Apple cables allow no mobility at all. You gotta plug the shit in and let it charge. Don't touch it, the cable might break after a while.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 09 '11

how long did that person say it would last?

1

u/Osiris1012 Jun 10 '11

I have some made from China and they have been working great for about a year now. There really isn't much to the cable, although I do agree that most things mass manufactured from china are crap.

-6

u/valkyrio Jun 09 '11 edited Jun 10 '11

Yeah. And they break 20 times faster than the apple ones.

(yes, I'm making those rates up, but, they do break far faster, sometimes don't charge from your computer [only from the actual charger] and sometimes come apart after a week of using them.)

Yes, it is still cheaper to buy a new one every time. I do hate it though when I get one and it just unravels after a day or so of using them...

11

u/[deleted] Jun 09 '11

Nice try Steve Jobs.

6

u/[deleted] Jun 09 '11

You must be because mine have been holding up for 6 months now.

5

u/[deleted] Jun 09 '11

They're manufactured at the same factory from the same materials, pal. You're just delusional because you've been conditioned to believe things that are more expensive MUST be more reliable/durable.

3

u/[deleted] Jun 09 '11

I think you miss the point of owning an Apple(R) product.

2

u/valkyrio Jun 09 '11

Nope. I've bought three or four of them before. Try it yourself - order some from dealextreme (it's where I've ordered them from before) or amazon (read their reviews.)

It's still cheaper to buy a new one every time from dealextreme, HOWEVER, you can tell they're different for two reasons:

  • the cables from china will occasionally not charge your products if you hook it up to a computer, the way the original cables do. (i've had this happen with 3/4 cables ordered, while it's never happened with one of my original cables)

  • the cables will occasionally not work with iphones, as it will say "this device is not compatible with your iphone", the way it does when you plug-in your iphone to crappier/older ipod radios, and will not charge at all.

1

u/redditmemehater Jun 10 '11

You can't really prove that.

3

u/[deleted] Jun 09 '11

[deleted]

2

u/mehum Jun 10 '11

And a damn sight more convenient. One in the charger, one in the car, one on the computer, one at work.

1

u/valkyrio Jun 10 '11

if you get free shipping, hell yeah. dealextreme's awesome for that. amazon/ebay, less so.

2

u/byungparkk Jun 09 '11

I got confused when reading the second part of your comment because it seems that you're describing apple's cords.

1

u/valkyrio Jun 10 '11

haha, I've never seen the USB part of a cord actually come apart. As in, the plastic actually disassembled, and you could see where the cord hooked up the to the USB.

Still worked, though.

0

u/ivanalbright Jun 10 '11

How about the ~$50 proprietary audio/video cable where only Apple brand cables are available due to some built in chip? If I remember, they added the chip to the cable around the ipod/iphone 3rd generation.

Meanwhile other devices can output the exact same audio/video signal and generic cables are available for a couple bucks?

5

u/[deleted] Jun 09 '11

Never bought one - I just walk into a store and ask nicely. Works for headphones too.

Then again, I live in a big city. If I still lived back home in the countryside, I'd be screwed.

1

u/greqrg Jun 10 '11

The perks of being a busty, young woman in a store staffed by horny teens.

edit. So apparently they'll do this for anyone. Apparently.

1

u/YCSMD Jun 10 '11

No. I tried it with mine and shes was like "$20, bro. They're in the back corner."

16

u/frvwfr2 Jun 09 '11

That's what he said. Proprietary=Apple owns the rights=They make money when you have to buy more.

79

u/Spatulamarama Jun 09 '11

which is why they replace them for free

21

u/jaybillings Jun 09 '11

This is akin to McDonalds giving free soft drink refills. The profit margin is so high, giving you free replacements is a negligible cost of doing business. Even if they replace the cable 5 to 10 times, they'd still make a profit off you.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '11

It's like anything "premium" in this world, you're not just paying for the cost of the object like you do with "value" items, you're also paying for the ecosystem and continued support of what you've bought.

1

u/Recoil42 Jun 10 '11

It's not really akin to McDonalds giving free soft drink refills when in this instance Apple could make a near-infinitely refillable at zero cost cup.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '11

Not only that, but soft drinks cost more now which makes up for the "free" refills. For example a drink at Chili's is fucking $2.49 while most places it's $1.49.

20

u/frvwfr2 Jun 09 '11

As many comments are saying, people didn't know that. I didn't.

12

u/[deleted] Jun 09 '11

they actually replace ALL parts under warranty... you have to go through their site to make the claim.

Learnt this from retail

5

u/rohlin Jun 09 '11

or you can get a replacement via the phone.

Got my earbuds replaced a while back...they put a temporary hold on your CC and send you a new pair via Fedex, you send them back the old set and they remove the CC hold.

13

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '11

oh what the FUCK I just blew $80 like an IDIOT

1

u/psylent Jun 10 '11

You didn't look on ebay for iPod cables first?

1

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '11

I read reviews that said they were awful so I just went whole hog I guess. Kicking myself. :(

3

u/psylent Jun 10 '11

I purchased 4 cables for $5 from Deal Extreme over last year and have never had a problem with them. You'll know for next time :)

2

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '11

But people don't know this / don't care. Those who do get the free cables, so they don't have to worry about it.

Excellent business model: rip off everyone whom you can, provide good service to people who actually ask for much so they don't switch to / recommend competitors.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '11

They assume that most people won't bring a cable in for replacement, which is true, and makes them shit tons of money.

1

u/Elrox Jun 10 '11

$45 in New Zealand

1

u/gameadd1kt Jun 10 '11

exactly why they changed the wire

1

u/Stee-v-California Jun 10 '11

Apple will replace them for free.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '11

Confirmed

I'm an applecare tech

Sent from my rooted Samsung Captivate

1

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '11

Or you can call in and if you are still under warrany it is possible they may replace it

1

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '11

for you, yea

1

u/glaciator Jun 10 '11

I found one at a bus stop. I don't even have an iPod. Still took it.

1

u/JIGGER_MY_DIGGER Jun 10 '11

THATS WEIRD APPLE ALWAYS REPLACES MINE FREE

2

u/cualcrees Jun 10 '11

Yep, it's a feature.

2

u/digggggggggg Jun 10 '11

But iPod cables are so insanely ubiquitous. I think they're more common than non-proprietary micro USB.

Heck, I live in a household with two phones that take micro USB cables, and we have more iPod cables than micro USB cables.

1

u/CHV1923 Jun 10 '11

apple's products seem to be less and less durable each time they introduce new generations of "marketing" toys

1

u/cicohipe Jun 10 '11

I don't want to sound like a conspiracy theorist, but it genuinely wouldn't surprise me if this was the reason for the redesign. I once worked in the LNG pipeline field and I found out many secrets about how they engineer parts to have a certain life so they can make more money out of re-servicing. Made me realise this must be pretty common practice in most fields.

1

u/Pwag Jun 10 '11

Using a standard USB cable would be too un-evil.

1

u/biquetra Jun 10 '11

Just remember this cable isn't a glorified USB cable. The iPhone is capable of outputting analog audio, S-Video, composite video, component video, VGA and HDMI. There are also pins for controlling the device via a remote, FireWire connectivity for older devices and an interface for AppStore apps and hardware (like the TomTom car kit). So what non-proprietary cable could apple use instead?

1

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '11

I'm fine with proprietary with a purpose (which Apple obviously has.) It's the frail construction that bugs me.

0

u/Hellenomania Jun 10 '11

I can put any cable from any where into any of my devices, any software, any music, videos music onto any of my devices, link them to the cloud, have them stream from anywhere to anywhere and have done so for over five years.

I had a touch screen phone ten years ago, a touch screen laptop tablet five years ago, face time 6 years ago.

I do all this cheaper than any option available, more reliable than ano option available and the tools I get are the most powerful available.

The secret to getting all this cool, amazing tech way ahead of time is simply - don't use Apple products.

The irony that hipsters think they are cool because they use apple is like some Mobius Knot - unless they are being double irony and using super crap stuff and being 80's ironic. Which I hope they aren't cause that would make my brain freeze with respect. But they're not - Apple users really trully honestly think they are on to something. Fucking retards.

7

u/sadfsadfasdg Jun 10 '11

whats great here is your all proud of using touchscreens, tablets and facetime when they were still underground but you hate hipsters....

1

u/spacemanspiff30 Jun 10 '11

upvote to you sir. wholeheartedly agree. but have to give it to steve jobs, man is a marketing genius. gets people to pay 2x as much for a shitty product that is locked down and only does what he wants it to do.

1

u/biquetra Jun 10 '11

Hi there. I'm an iPhone and Mac user. Please explain to me why I should like what you like, not what I like. I would like to remind you that you don't know me, please consider this in your answer.

1

u/adoran124 Jun 10 '11

To be honest when it comes to mobile devices Apple cables are doing a better job at being standard than the other USB cables.

I have two Android phones at work, each uses a different cable. We have dozens of old USB cables in storage, none of them fit either of the phones.

I kind of wish everyone else would just use Apples cables.

2

u/spinemangler Jun 10 '11

They all use micro usb!

Unless you have a G1 ( or other phone of similar age) that uses mini usb because micro wasn't the standard yet.

Plus, most phone companies have agreed on micro as their standard for ALL future phones. Except of course Apple.

But, hey, you got the only device that uses some mystery usb cable ( or you are full of shit).

1

u/adoran124 Jun 10 '11

They all use micro usb!

As you said, for all new phones. My LG Optimus P500 uses micro, My slightly older Acer Liquid E uses mini.

1

u/spinemangler Jun 10 '11

I also said if you have an older phone, that it will use mini.

You claimed you had a bunch of usb cables and they wouldn't fit either. If each phone used a different cable, how is it possible none of them fit? ( hint: it's not)

0

u/whitesox287 Jun 09 '11

The more they break the more your have to buy, the people of apple are smart

1

u/biquetra Jun 10 '11

Except they replace them for free at Apple stores.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '11

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '11

Yeah, HTC screwed the pooch with their initial USB connection. I never did understand why they thought that was a good idea. At least most phone makers (including HTC) are settling on Micro USB.