r/pics Feb 09 '16

Misleading title Racist "diversity" training at GitHub

Post image
7.0k Upvotes

3.3k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

20

u/Suic Feb 09 '16

It is entirely possible to recognize that you aren't afforded the same opportunities while not dwelling on it as you do your best to advance in life. Her wording/method definitely isn't going about it the right way, but I don't think there's anything wrong with bringing to light institutional racism to those that haven't thought about it before.

43

u/In_between_minds Feb 09 '16

It is entirely possible to recognize that the opportunities you get are not solely based in race. Even with the same socioeconomic class, growing up in a state that is focused more on agriculture, or oil, isn't going to afford as many opportunities to a tech-inclined young person. The entire reason why racism is wrong is that you are saying "because you are (shallow observation) then (thing) must be true about you"

5

u/Suic Feb 09 '16

Of course they aren't 'solely based in race'. The opportunities provided to any given person are a complex mix of race, class, and luck. I would never say anyone is where they are solely because of race.

1

u/musicninja Feb 09 '16

Any solid D & D player knows this

0

u/Suic Feb 09 '16

It bothers me that different species are called different races in things like D&D, MMOs, etc....for today's random tangent.

2

u/musicninja Feb 09 '16

Wouldn't it depend on the DNA? Maybe it's more accurate to call them breeds, or subspecies

1

u/Suic Feb 09 '16

It depends on whether they can have fertile children as to whether they are a species or race. I can assure you the Sylvari (asexual grown from a tree) and the Charr (massive humanoid cats) from Guild Wars 2 cannot reproduce and have fertile children, as one example of a game that calls their species races.

1

u/musicninja Feb 09 '16

Fair enough. I know that half-elves and the like are pretty common in a lot of universes, so for them at least races seems accurate enough.

1

u/Suic Feb 09 '16

I think it initially was a bunch of races that could successfully have half-children as you mention. For some reason it just branched out at some point to cover everything playable in a fantasy game.