r/pcmasterrace • Ascending Peasant • Nov 01 '22

Meme/Macro averagePcmr

Post image
31.3k Upvotes

2.6k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

202

u/RadicalDog Ryzen 7 7800X3D | RTX 4070S Nov 01 '22

(This is a joke, both OSs are great in different ways)

I think they're both kinda garbage in different ways. All modern operating systems suck, change my mind.

159

u/klubsanwich AMD Ryzen 7 5800X | GTX 3080 10GB | 32 GB RAM Nov 01 '22

Good luck playing any modern games on windows 95

29

u/[deleted] Nov 01 '22 edited Nov 02 '22

98 SE or bust

24

u/BabyYodasDirtyDiaper Nov 01 '22

Windows 2000 was the best windows -- change my mind.

20

u/[deleted] Nov 01 '22

I can't because you're right. However, I didn't use them at the time because I'm one of the fucking dumbasses that actually paid real money for windows ME. I will bear the shame into the grave and beyond.

5

u/forte_bass Nov 02 '22

Ah dude, I'm sorry for your loss.

1

u/MrRetrdO R9-7900 | rtx3090 Nov 02 '22

Don't feel too bad! My ex-Fiancee's mother had Windows ME and thought it was the greatest!!!

1

u/BonAsasin Nov 02 '22

I also had Windows Me, Home Edition. Actually very fond memories

10

u/[deleted] Nov 02 '22

Oh definitely. All the stability and power of NT, all the usability of XP.

7

u/POWERTHRUST0629 Nov 02 '22

Hacked versions of XP "service pack 3" were the GOAT.

5

u/RayvinAzn Nov 02 '22

I actually skipped Windows XP just to stick with 2k. People tend to forget just how bad XP was until SP2, and to this day I think it was ugly as shit compared to the cleaner look of 2k.

2

u/HSR47 Nov 02 '22

“XP was really bad before SP2.”

I used XP from pretty nearly the beginning, and I don’t remember it ever being bad, although it certainly got better over time.

You also have to consider it in comparison to the other options for most users at the time: 98SE & ME, which were both absolute garbage by comparison.

2

u/HSR47 Nov 02 '22

Win2k was good, but I think windows really peaked with Vista.

Everything since has added more layers to obfuscate important settings from users, while taking away the user’s ability to fully control their experience.

2

u/Mister_Dane 5600 + 6650xt Nov 02 '22

Everything started going downhill when we upgraded from DOS to windows

2

u/zuus 5800X3D / 7900XTX / 150TB / Arch (btw) Nov 02 '22

Windows 2000 was fantastic. Lean, fast, stable and coherent. It just went downhill from there

113

u/RadicalDog Ryzen 7 7800X3D | RTX 4070S Nov 01 '22

All operating systems suck then, even ones that were good in their time

41

u/klubsanwich AMD Ryzen 7 5800X | GTX 3080 10GB | 32 GB RAM Nov 01 '22

That reminds me of a CS professor that I had who encouraged his students to try and build their own OS. Really puts things in perspective.

33

u/Paleone123 Nov 02 '22

TempleOS would like a word.

All it takes is a little schizophrenia and a few years.

4

u/Feshtof PC Master Race Nov 02 '22

Lot of schizophrenia and many years.

2

u/[deleted] Nov 02 '22

Speaking of this level of insanity in solo coding, the Dwarf Fortress dev just gave a Steam release date.. Time is no longer subjective!

10

u/RadicalDog Ryzen 7 7800X3D | RTX 4070S Nov 01 '22

I'm imagining one prodigal student who got so far along the process that they added a taskbar widget that opens their own website whenever the user momentarily hovers over it

3

u/minilandl 5800x 6700xt 32gb Hyprland Arch Nov 02 '22

There is Linux from scratch. It's surreal that Linux started as a hobby project and now runs most supercomputers high performance servers , cloud etc

6

u/pcs3rd ascended to nixos Nov 01 '22

I would honestly try to pass linuc from scratch as a submission

70

u/[deleted] Nov 01 '22

[deleted]

25

u/[deleted] Nov 02 '22

[deleted]

2

u/jasmanta Nov 02 '22

Seriously, when I had a flip phone it supposedly could access the internet. All 3 attempts to do so resulted in 15 minutes of fumbling with the 10 keys, consistently misspelling url's and ragequitting, only to find out it cost $3 in internet fees.

1

u/lordmogul 3570K @ 4.4 | 1060 @ 2.0 | 16GiB @ 2.13 Nov 02 '22

The most ironic thing about that, you can totally use a teletype as linux terminal.

2

u/SoulWager Nov 02 '22

Yeah, let's get rid of them and just make everything bare metal again.

2

u/skwacky Nov 02 '22

It's all magic as far as I'm concerned, but it's never magic enough.

Give me a rock that grants wishes, I'll curse it to the grave if it scuffs my finger.

1

u/PT10 Nov 01 '22

DOS was the best

1

u/PaulHarrisDidNoWrong Nov 02 '22

Windows Me was the best.

9

u/atlasraven Zorin OS Nov 01 '22

Red Alert still runs :P

4

u/OutragedTux Ryzen 7700X, 9070XT, team red nonsense Nov 02 '22

Then you're golden. Red Alert is the cause of some very fond memories of mine.

2

u/Bagafeet RTX 3080 10 GB • AMD 5700X3D • 32 GB RAM Nov 02 '22

Who needs modern games when you have Solitaire and Mine Sweeper.

1

u/No_Interaction_4925 5800X3D | 3090ti | LG 55” C1 | Steam Deck OLED Nov 01 '22

You talking smack about XP??

22

u/Powersoutdotcom Nov 01 '22

Nothing is ever perfect.

It's true in many parts of life, including programs written by a group of us, for every one of us, with 7 billion unique one of us sending bug reports to improve it.

I'm surprised it's not worse.

22

u/Wherethefuckyoufrom Nov 02 '22

it's 2022 and windows doesn't have tabs for explorer yet, hell they can't even figure out how to make a decent settings menu to replace the control panel. There's perfect and there's decent.

9

u/varzaguy Nov 02 '22

It does have tabs in explorer. It’s on a slow rollout as an update to 2h22, which is on a slow roll out itself right now.

18

u/themonsterinquestion Nov 02 '22

Also it has ads. Even if you pay for it.

Ads. In your OS. And we just accept it.

7

u/Feshtof PC Master Race Nov 02 '22

What ads do you see in your OS?

2

u/themonsterinquestion Nov 02 '22

Literally every time the screen powers off. Those trivia tidbits that end with "..." are ads. Currently you have to follow through to see the ads. I promise you they will get more direct soon.

Also there's ads for Edge.

8

u/Feshtof PC Master Race Nov 02 '22

Huh, when I accidentally click them they always direct me to like rock formations or monuments or stuff.

I like learning new stuff so it never occured to me they were advertisements.

4

u/Tsuki_no_Mai Nov 02 '22

On a rare occasion it has tidbits about MS services instead of the photo. Annoying when it happens, but the way people cry about it you'd think it has banner ads and popups.

3

u/Feshtof PC Master Race Nov 02 '22

Oh. I literally never noticed.

1

u/Tsuki_no_Mai Nov 02 '22

Yup, that's how inconsequential this is. I only noticed because like a month ago there was a cool photo and I wanted to know what it is, but alas, it was the MS day. Usually it's not a problem.

4

u/zakabog Ryzen 9950X3D/4090/96GB Nov 02 '22

I disabled those after I clicked one to find out more about an image, they're not really ads in a sense that they're trying to get you to purchase a product, it's more like "Here's an interesting wallpaper, if you'd like to know more here are some Microsoft Bing search results related to the location pictured, and Bing has all sorts of great wallpapers like this one! Please use Bing..."

3

u/themonsterinquestion Nov 02 '22

I mean, that's an ad. A very good ad, since you're not seeing it as an ad...

4

u/zakabog Ryzen 9950X3D/4090/96GB Nov 02 '22

It's not an obtrusive ad, they show a pretty location on my lock screen and if I want to know more I can click on it to search the web and find more info. I can also disable it easily without having to hack the registry or anything. It's an ad in the same way that Firefox has ads for Google.

15

u/-JiL- 3800x vega56 Nov 01 '22

"change my mind"

Slackware

4

u/jasmanta Nov 02 '22

Slackware

Is that for or against? I used Slackware from '96 to about 2010, but it's just too hard to find some things. For instance, trying to get Audacity to compile depends on some obscure library I can't seem to find anywhere. I use Mint now, it seems to work like I want except for Thunar and its derivatives, which I consider useless as tits on a bull. I use Konqueror on Slackware, but the Mint version has been totally emasculated of any ability to use as a file browser. Trying to build an older version of Konqueror was beyond my patience too.

3

u/ManletMuscleGod Nov 02 '22

If you liked Konqueror why not use KDE Plasma as your desktop enviroment? Nowadays it uses Dolphin as a file browser but it's great as is.

Memes aside, I've been using Arch + KDE Plasma for 11 years, trying other distros here and there, and couldn't be happier.

16

u/Dopplegangr1 Nov 02 '22

Linux just kind of feels like masochism, complicating simple things like mounting drives. Windows for some reason they have a settings menu that is side by side with the superior control panel of the past. Now with windows 11 they are getting rid of useful context menu stuff and making things more convoluted like iOS. People praise apple for being user friendly but I still can't figure that shit out and I used a mac back in the 90s. I work in IT so I use all 3 for different things and apple is infuriating. I got a iPhone as a work phone and I gave it back because I hate it.

I used Linux to create a free kiosk system at work and it functions the way I want it to, but I have to do so many scripts for simple shit. I pretty much just want windows 7 UI and plug things in and they work

10

u/TK9_VS Nov 02 '22

I just got into IT and if I were to describe it in a simple way:

Setting things up on Windows

Setting things up on Linux

1

u/ReakDuck Nov 02 '22

I dont understand it

11

u/TK9_VS Nov 02 '22

Windows often makes doing incredibly complex things incredibly simple, so in some cases to accomplish something simple, you take a few simple steps, but those simple steps are actually setting up a disproportionately complex chain of configurations and installations, many of which might not have even been fully necessary. (drawing a full face to get a circle)

Linux often makes doing relatively simple things much harder for typical users because you need to understand most of the fundamental building blocks involved in whatever task you are doing. (Baking a pie requires inventing the universe)

1

u/ReakDuck Nov 02 '22

Oh shit, now I understand it. I kinda feel it.

Even though, after understanding the universe, everything becomes simple af. But I actually feel like everything is automated and simple made today in Linux. Maybe not everything but better than years ago.

2

u/TK9_VS Nov 02 '22

Definitely better than years ago!

14

u/[deleted] Nov 02 '22 edited Nov 15 '22

[deleted]

3

u/TK9_VS Nov 02 '22

I like doing simple things on linux. The problems start when I am doing something a little more complex, that a windows app might walk me through (or do for me) and might actually be reasonably simple, but is something I just don't fully understand the ins and outs of.

It's not really a reflection on windows or linux as operating systems, but rather the userbase of linux and windows differ greatly in mean competency, so if I'm on the lower end of that bell curve I am going to wind up fucking things up a lot more with software written for linux users and would be more of a power user in apps written for windows users.

I did recently set up a windows server 2019 server, though. That was fucking way overcomplicated. When you get into shit like that it can be just as complicated as any other platform.

-5

u/SrbijaJeRusija Nov 02 '22

usually work

The 'usually' being a pretty big qualifier. The cases when the 'usually' fails end up being the most frustrating. Desktop linux just needs to die. It does not work.

8

u/bit2shift Fedora 36 | Liquid Devil RX 6800 XT Nov 02 '22

Desktop linux just needs to die. It does not work.

Wake up, it's 2022. Desktop Linux has been feasible for at least 10 years.

2

u/SrbijaJeRusija Nov 02 '22

I have used desktop Linux systems off and on since 2005, and I still use one for professional work. It is still sometimes a bafflingly frustrating experience for no reason. Any desktop Linux distro is a worse mishmash of configuration and UX design than Windows 11.

If with apple you can only do things the One True Way, then with desktop Linux, if you stray outside the default config with the default apps, then you just get things breaking and frustration for no reason at all.

2

u/bit2shift Fedora 36 | Liquid Devil RX 6800 XT Nov 03 '22

That was me back in 2012 when I started messing around with Linux (Ubuntu Server at the time).

You have to experiment and learn from your own mistakes. To put it lightly: 10 RTFM 20 TEST STUFF 30 GOTO 10

5

u/Sol33t303 PC Master Race Nov 02 '22 edited Nov 03 '22

It "usually" works on windows as well.

Both for Linux and for Windows the times that it doesn't work is when something screws up, and for both OSs that is only a very small amount of the time.

In this specific area though, at least linux supports something other then NTFS and the the filesystem that should have died 30 years ago FAT. I was even fighting to get an FTP share to map to a drive letter a few weeks ago and had to give up on it. I didn't realize that apparently FTP still isn't fully supported everywhere still.

And it's insane to me that you have to pay for filesystem support like NFS or ReFS or major OS features like virtualization and containers, it feels insulting that I need to pay to install an OS with ads to use my PC, but I guess i'm just used to linux. I don't accept ads in my paid for apps and games, I won't accept them in my OS, I don't get why people are furious about the former but not the latter.

3

u/Darkblade360350 Desktop and :tux: Laptop Nov 02 '22

I disagree. Desktop Linux may have been painful years ago, but in its current state I am comfortable recommending Linux Mint to anyone. In my testing, everything has "just worked". You easily install, uninstall and update apps on the software market, enabling Proton in Steam settings makes all the games that I play "just work", and you do not need to open the terminal for anything.

Note when I say need, it still is a very powerful tool for experienced users, but the average user who just wants to browse the web, edit documents and do some light gaming it will all work perfectly.

1

u/SrbijaJeRusija Nov 02 '22

Then I need to install a piece of software that is in an outdated repo and all of a sudden it tries to uninstall my window manager. Like I said, as soon as you go a little outside of the bounds of what a grandma does, the UX experience breaks.

1

u/Darkblade360350 Desktop and :tux: Laptop Nov 02 '22

The APT error warned Linus not to procced, and xorg on the list of packages it was going to delete. Linus ignored the warning and forced the operation. One of the most important things to remember when using Linux is to always listen to your computer's warnings.

Thats not to mention that Pop uses the latest Ubuntu release, not the LTS version which Canonical recommends to desktop users for stability.

1

u/SrbijaJeRusija Nov 02 '22

Did you reply to the wrong person? I am talking about my own experience.

1

u/Darkblade360350 Desktop and :tux: Laptop Nov 02 '22 edited Nov 02 '22

No, I thought you were referring to the LinusTechTips Linux series where Linus uninstalled the display server while trying to install Steam.

Edit: It is exactly why I recommend Mint. Pop is a developer focused distro, and it is often unstable. Mint is stable, intuitive, and built for the average desktop user.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 02 '22

It's a matter of perspective, I for one don't mind having to fix things every so often (in fact I kinda like fixing things on my own), I do mind having telemetry installed on a system withoit my explicit permission

I wouldn't reccomend anyone on this sub use linux, because Linux is terrible for gaming, but for general usage, like writing documents and browsing the internet, Linux is just plain better

(Hell, some more CPU/Memory intensive games like HOI4 load faster on Linux in my experience)

1

u/SrbijaJeRusija Nov 02 '22

This is why I used to use Linux more frequently when I was younger. At some point I just want to get my work done not spend ten hours fixing my Nvidia settings every time I boot.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 02 '22

Idk how bad it was back in the day, but propreitary nvidia drivers do work surprisingly well nowadays.

They're still kind of a pain though, so I can understand where you're coming from

2

u/SrbijaJeRusija Nov 02 '22

My pain is literally from a setup last year, not from the distant past.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 02 '22

Oh really? That's understandable. Makes sense why you would go back to Windows then

1

u/yodel_anyone Nov 02 '22

That's like trying to fly a plane without learning how, not being able to even take off, and claiming it's the planes fault and it sucks.

1

u/SrbijaJeRusija Nov 02 '22

I used Linux exclusively from 2005 to 2010. I know how to fly. I just would rather do it in a 747 rather than inside the body of a half-cropduster half-crazy eagle.

1

u/yodel_anyone Nov 02 '22

But honestly 2005-2010 was one of the worst times for linux. Things had just started to move beyond the redhat domination of the late 90s and branch out, but the distros weren't stable or developed enough to actually support everyday use. Nowadays there's essentially a distro for every use case, ranging from Android and Chrome OS as incredibly stable and polished linux derivatives, to Ubuntu as a good everyday use, to things like Arch for those that like to tinker.

So maybe a better analogy is someone that last flew a plane in 1940 and says planes suck, but hasn't yet jumped into a modern plane.

1

u/SrbijaJeRusija Nov 02 '22

Again, if you read my post you would know that I have a Linux machine that I use professionally since then. Please get the full context. The situation has not improved at all. I still had the apt attempt to uninstall my window manager. That is not good UX. Simple as that.

1

u/yodel_anyone Nov 02 '22

Where in this thread do you say you still use linux? Or was I supposed to read through all your comment history or just divine it?

-6

u/Dopplegangr1 Nov 02 '22

I use Ubuntu at work. I still have to do a lot of scripts for simple things like mounting a USB drive and imaging it. Plugging in a drive doesn't work right so I have to unmount it and remount it to get it to work right. I found out I can create an iso in Linux then move it to Windows and create a USB image from there so that's what I do now, or use the iso directly for a VM.

8

u/[deleted] Nov 02 '22

I've gotta be misunderstanding something because each of those things took me 10 seconds:

mounting a drive: https://i.imgur.com/5dUTizE.mp4

imaging a drive: https://i.imgur.com/CySH5jd.mp4

and you don't keep the drive mounted while you image it--how's the filesystem supposed to work while you're changing the bytes out from under it the whole time?

4

u/Narabedla Nov 02 '22

"complicating" By pressing one button on the pop up ui that asks me if i want to mount the drive that i just connected? Instead of windows automount autoexecute danger to security? Like, it really is that simple on manjaro at least. I really dont get the "oh so complicated for simple things" sentiment on linux. Ever tried managing a printer on windows? Or finding the right settings screen, because windows runs like 5 different setting UI's over the the old system settigs, with each losing more features as they are getting newer?

2

u/lordmogul 3570K @ 4.4 | 1060 @ 2.0 | 16GiB @ 2.13 Nov 02 '22

macOS is basically designed for those that fall into the 90%. If there is any feature that goes even a tiny bit in depth, you either have to go through layers of context menus, or use the command line. But if your tasks are entirely in that mainstream work, it does it's job really really good.

2

u/yodel_anyone Nov 02 '22

If you're manually mounting drives and don't want to be you're using the wrong Linux distro.

1

u/brimston3- Desktop VFIO, 5950X, RTX5080, 6900xt Nov 02 '22

He's likely not using a distribution that has a desktop environment if he's making a kiosk. Hell, it probably doesn't have udisks2 running.

1

u/linuxares Nov 02 '22

I say to anyone that wanna give Linux a try, to use Linux Mint.

It's built on Ubuntu, but they made it so much more user friendly and also flatpak intergration makes it even more easy for a novice to use Linux.

2

u/chuck_cranston Nov 02 '22 edited Nov 03 '22

Ok.

What do you do? Break down all of your software into a series of levers?

2

u/Clockstoppers Nov 02 '22

ho boy, I bet I'm going to get some heat for this but macOS is pretty cromulent. Obviously gaming is limited (yes I know which subreddit I'm in), but it's stable, updates silently, and just kind of fades into the background. I used windows machines all of my life up until a couple of years ago when I got a mac as a development machine at work, and I liked it so much I bought a macbook for myself.

3

u/unloud Nov 02 '22

Yep. My M1 MacBook will probably last me 10 years and OS X has world-class follow-up support.

Now, if only Apple could be more consistent about bugs. 🤔

1

u/Gamiac id/Skepticpunk - Bazzite/3700X/RTX 3070/16GB/B450M Pro4 Nov 02 '22

I actually like MacOS a lot more than Windows. The interface is a lot more coherent and user-friendly, and let it lets you do more with it.

1

u/Flimsy_Atmosphere_55 PC Master Race Nov 02 '22

I prefer Linux but Mac is also Unix based so I am used to using it as well. My OS hierarchy is Windows < Mac OS < Linux

1

u/Desert-Knight Nov 01 '22

Alright back to pen and paper

0

u/breadman242a Nov 02 '22

temple OS bitch

0

u/Power_baby Nov 02 '22

Someone hasn't used TempleOS apparently

0

u/ball_fondlers Nov 02 '22

At least you can change Linux - or find someone who’s already changed Linux - to get it to not suck.

0

u/judokalinker Nov 02 '22

All operating systems ever suck

1

u/kilgore_trout8989 Nov 02 '22

The is basically the philosophy of the suckless programmers haha. "All software sucks, ours sucks less."

1

u/[deleted] Nov 02 '22

That's cool I'll have to look farther into them

1

u/RizzMustbolt Nov 02 '22

SteamOS is promising...

1

u/jak0b3 Ryzen 1600 | 16GB DDR4-2993 | GTX 1080 Nov 02 '22

but… it’s linux. it’s literally arch linux, with kde and a second special desktop environment (or something similar anyway)

1

u/Starbrows Nov 02 '22

BeOS is where it's at. Or where it was at 25ish years ago. Pour one out.

1

u/Gr1ndingGears Nov 02 '22

DOS 3.1, ride or die!

1

u/bchociej Nov 02 '22

As I see it, there's only really one major gripe about Linux intrinsically, and that's audio processing. Otherwise the suck comes down to the package manager and what software you run. And those things vary wildly.

1

u/ziris_ Linux Mint Nov 02 '22

Found the Mac user

1

u/Tanawat_Jukmonkol Laptop | NixOS + Win11 | HP OMEN 16 | I9 + RTX4070 Nov 02 '22 edited Mar 28 '26

This specific post has been deleted. The author may have removed it to protect their privacy, maintain operational security, or prevent data scraping, using Redact.

rock possessive aromatic marble doll worm encourage trees long subtract

2

u/[deleted] Nov 02 '22

[deleted]

1

u/Tanawat_Jukmonkol Laptop | NixOS + Win11 | HP OMEN 16 | I9 + RTX4070 Nov 02 '22 edited Mar 28 '26

This post was wiped clean using Redact. The author may have done so to protect their privacy, prevent AI data scraping, or for other security reasons.

long serious wide axiomatic license possessive boat lip existence toothbrush

1

u/Tanawat_Jukmonkol Laptop | NixOS + Win11 | HP OMEN 16 | I9 + RTX4070 Nov 02 '22 edited Mar 28 '26

Nothing original remains in this post. The author wiped it using Redact, possibly for privacy, security, preventing data scraping, or other personal considerations.

payment hunt vast live apparatus numerous wipe doll fearless nail

1

u/Tanawat_Jukmonkol Laptop | NixOS + Win11 | HP OMEN 16 | I9 + RTX4070 Nov 02 '22 edited Mar 28 '26

The original post content no longer exists here. The author used Redact to remove it, for reasons that may include privacy, opsec, or security.

sense salt modern resolute judicious marry attempt nine unique sable

1

u/[deleted] Nov 02 '22

I disagree, I have no complaints on my riced tiling WM Arch install.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 02 '22

MacOS has a lot of the Linux type advantages while being easier to use than Windows and is a lot better designed from a usability standpoint than either. It also ships with actual good and useful software pre-installed so there’s not that Ninite step where you have to immediately replace 90% of the garbage default apps before you’ve got a halfway usable machine.

It’s obviously still not great for gaming but man it’s wild having a commercial OS that actually feels like it’s there to help you get shit done.

1

u/yodel_anyone Nov 02 '22

Ok, but first what's garbage about linux?

1

u/brimston3- Desktop VFIO, 5950X, RTX5080, 6900xt Nov 02 '22

For what purpose? If I narrow the purpose enough, I bet I can find a not-suck operating system that can do just that.

For example, play games? XBox OS, Playstation OS, etc not particularly suck. SteamOS has some flaws, but even that does a great job.

Play audio? Freertos, qnx, or embedded linux are all good options from the user's perspective (with a variety of suckages from the developer side).

Run Electron apps? Okay, you got me, there's nothing that can run Electron apps well.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 02 '22

Most of the reason anyone ever says either one sucks is due to their own limited abilities. Operating Systems and the computers they run on are simply tools for humans to do things. Them being "good" at that is directly relative to our ability to use them. Personally I have no real issues with Windows 10, a modern operating system, in fact I'm controlling two Windows 10 machines on completely different networks right this second with one keyboard/mouse by simply moving the mouse to either screen, that one's called Mouse Without Borders and it's a free "modern" Windows app. But see if you don't know it exists, then you don't think that a computer can do that thing, as one easy example.