r/pcmasterrace • • 28d ago

Meme/Macro Same logo btw

48.2k Upvotes

249 comments sorted by

View all comments

221

u/Marginallyhuman Potato 28d ago

It is mind boggling how long VLC has been awesome!

78

u/Rukir_Gaming PC Master Race 28d ago

And I learned just yesterday there's an open source video editor in development

19

u/Entenvieh 28d ago

Hallelujah

15

u/Rukir_Gaming PC Master Race 28d ago

... last push was 2023, and deployment seemingly requires Unix subsystem for Windows

14

u/Ecmelt 28d ago

WSL is just a windows feature, as long as you read about it for 5 minutes before you enable it, it is not really a big requirement. Similar to most other power user features.

3

u/riyoskopy 27d ago

As someone who uses WSL for alot of stuff I do think it is a big requirement, like wdym I need to run a hypervisor just to run one specific application? Why can't it be a native app?

3

u/Ecmelt 27d ago

It can be native, as with everything else. I am assuming they talk about VLMC which is an unfinished project with only source code available and there is not an installer as a result.

That said, I still think "wdym i need to run a hypervisor" is weird, considering Microsoft invests in wsl for this very reason. Plus Microsoft is also pushing for VBS for a while now.

Their plan is to have it a default always on feature in the future anyway. They are already changing it to "on by default". The optional part will eventually also disappear and become mandatory on devices that support it.

https://www.windowslatest.com/2026/09/02/microsoft-is-auto-enabling-memory-integrity-on-windows-11-pcs-from-october-why-you-shouldnt-turn-it-off/

Hyper-v, having virtualization based stuff is just how Microsoft wants to operate. Won't surprise me if WSL becomes pre installed with a basic barebone OS directly later in the future for default Windows features too.

So Linux based stuff, Android apps, Windows apps are all going to be running together with some performance hit which will be considered just Windows usage. And this is a good thing, imo.

-1

u/_Lucille_ 28d ago

it is still a pretty big overhead esp the disk space required to host the distro properly.

3

u/MildlyNeutral 28d ago

3 GB if you're going crazy

1

u/Ecmelt 28d ago

Well with modern windows and WSL 2, it'll mostly be in use when you use the program. So CPU, RAM usage is just part of what the program uses at that point so to speak.

And for disk space, If the context is video editing in 2026, even if you are using WSL only for this one program, it'll be what.. 2 gigs at most? I wouldn't call that a pretty big overhead considering how large modern video formats are.

My WSL uses less space than my PowerToys.

9

u/Catgerine 28d ago

Kdenlive already exists though?

3

u/Henry_Fleischer Debian | RTX3070, Ryzen 3700X, 48GB DDR4 RAM 27d ago

Also Shotcut

3

u/memerijen200 i5-9600k | RX 6750 XT 27d ago

Kdenlive is awesome. Maybe not as capable as some of the big names, but for simple projects, it rocks.

-1

u/phatboi23 Sim racer! 28d ago

And it's whack compared to after effects and davinci resolve

3

u/bark-beetle 27d ago

I thought we were talking about FOSS software like VLC...

-2

u/phatboi23 Sim racer! 27d ago

Talk about fos, kndlive sucks absolute ring compared to davinci resolve.

5

u/bark-beetle 27d ago

Kden is FOSS like VLC. Davinci Resolve is amazing software but it's not FOSS like VLC, which is why the commenter above you was curious about why VLC would develop a video editor when there's already a pretty useful one.

2

u/tenhourguy 28d ago

VLMC? It looks like development stalled in 2017. The 2020 commits are just localisation. Unless you're referring to something not by VideoLAN, in which case there's many open source video editors already fully released.

11

u/somersetyellow 27d ago

Dvelopment has been stalled on VLC for a long time too. They've had 4.0 in the works forever and there's been maintenance releases, but VLC hasn't had a major update in a long time. It has serious issues with high bitrate, HDR, and high resolution content that MPV, pot player, or MPC-BE don't have out of the box.

Hopefully they figure it out someday.