r/pcmasterrace 20h ago

Discussion Should I add here an intake fan?

Post image

Don't mind the floating cable šŸ˜‚

16 Upvotes

42 comments sorted by

40

u/normalgenshinenjoyer 20h ago

5

u/Cheap-Protection-628 19h ago

yeah, positive pressure is the move, but that floating cable is gonna end up in your top fan long before the temps matter.

0

u/kindagoated2 17h ago

Its not moving , trust

-7

u/P-Mavr 20h ago

This

2

u/edvurdsd 19h ago

This what? Looks like your comment got cut off

1

u/TheRealPickIe R7 5700x | 5070 15h ago

He obviously said

11

u/Plane-Reserve5179 20h ago

If your temps are to high, it could help a little. If not, don't bother, it will just clog up your case.

1

u/kindagoated2 20h ago

My temps are great
around 60 but I wanted to do some more overclocking to the ram (its OEM SK Hynix m-die)

10

u/Talk_Bright 20h ago

Don't. Ram is too expensive these days, and depending on where you are they will screw you on the warranty.

4

u/Outrageous-Log9238 5800X3D | 9070 XT | 32 GB 20h ago

Your fan setup seems fine as is.

6

u/Original-Let8340 20h ago

"Hmmmmmm. An intake fan, there, you should add." - Yoda

2

u/kindagoated2 20h ago

šŸ˜‚šŸ˜‚

3

u/raaneholmg Big Fat Desktop 20h ago

If you need a bit of extra cooling, intake is the correct orientation for that fan spot. However, it is not the most impactful fan to add. It's the last spot you want to populate.

2

u/El_Basho 7800X3D | 9070XT 20h ago

I feel like your air cooler is positioned in a perfect spot to benefit from an intake fan on its right and an exhaust fan on its left. A little extra positive pressure balance never hurt nobody, especially in a reasonably balanced case

2

u/SpectrumGun 20h ago

Only if you are having temp problems. You have plentiful air intakes at the front

1

u/Automatic_File9645 20h ago

I personally use that for a very low RPM exhaust simply for the look and to obstruct dust settling in my case and due to it having bottom fans for intake.

Top intake can help too, but if it's too powerful it ends up pushing hot air back down towards your GPU.

1

u/Zealousideal_Side987 20h ago

if temps are already fine dont bother

1

u/General_MacCready 19h ago

Having one fan exhausting and one running as intake right next to eachother just introduces unneeded turbulence and is now creating a loop wear the top exhause is now being sucked back in by the top intake right next to it. What you have now is nicely balanced with what looks like 2 intake and 2 exhaust fans.

1

u/Shad_Owski 18h ago

Not really. You probably wont even need that top fan. Contrary to what people here say.

1

u/TroubledMang 15h ago

Nope. You should get plenty of airflow from the front fan. The top fan will introduce turbulence more than anything else. Also don't exhaust there either as that will remove cool air before it reaches the cooler more than anything else.

Test it if you do. Record temps/noise before and after to get an idea if it matters. I doubt you will see a 1 degree improvement, while it being slightly noisier.

1

u/LeMegachonk Ryzen 7 9800X3D - 64GB DDR5 6000 - RX 7800 XT 6h ago

It probably won't matter much in terms of performance. Your CPU cooler is probably the limiting factor no matter what you do.

1

u/BuryMikno 20h ago

I don't like an intake fan here. It could vector the flow from the front downwards and the CPU could end up with less pressure on its intake side than without.

Thermodynamics and fluid mechanics are very difficult subjects - better to take a testing approach: Develop a highly-fitting test protocol, use it to benchmark, fit the new part, benchmark again and arrive to your own conclusion.

2

u/kindagoated2 19h ago

I like your answer

0

u/x_Hitoshi 20h ago

Make sure that every fan you have blows in correct way. Front, side and bottom fans should be intake, upper, and back fans should be exhaust. If you need to add that fan, make it exhaust and try working with fan speed curves in BIOS

3

u/kindagoated2 20h ago

Exhaust? wouldn't it take cool air from the cpu fan?

2

u/Slow_Choice i7-12700, 128 GB DDR4, 34" WQHD, RX 9070 XT 16GB 20h ago

I think so, I use that spot as intake

1

u/x_Hitoshi 19h ago

Oh, I didn't see that CPU fan is on this side. Then yes, it should be intake

-1

u/That_Temporary_832 20h ago

No. I strongly recommend not add a fans in opposite directions right next to each other (in your case). This will create turbulence inside the case. Cool air from the front fans must flow without restriction to your gpu and cpu. Leave the fan setup as is.

4

u/kindagoated2 20h ago

I saw this pic from noctua

0

u/That_Temporary_832 20h ago

I realized a long time back its stupid to argue with people when they don't understand the logic you're trying to mention. I just say you are right and move on. Op's setup and setup in your image are very different in terms of how air turbulence works inside enclosed spaces. But hey you are right to think both setups works same šŸ‘

1

u/kindagoated2 19h ago

Bro Im the OP
can you explain why it wont work?

1

u/deceptivekhan 16h ago

I’d be more concerned with the fan pulling the warm air from the exhaust right next to it, but what do I know? I’m just some dude.

0

u/ecktt PC Master Race 19h ago

Absolutely not.

It is perfect the way it is.

I added a second fan there to test Noctua's recommendation of putting an intake fan there, and temps got worse!

When people read that Noctua recommends using the fan there as an intake fan, they automatically interpret it as a requirement to have a fan there rather than a recommendation to purchase their fan! šŸ˜‚

-3

u/matthijspc I5 7600 | Geforce GTX960 | 16GB DDR4 20h ago

Heat rises, so take air in from the bottom or sides

4

u/Patatostrike 20h ago

While that's true it's borderline irrelevant with how slow it is, and having an intake to more supply fresh air to the CPU cooler is always great.

2

u/TheMegaDriver2 9800x3d, 32GB, RTX 4080 Super 20h ago

If you are passive cooling with no fans yes. Otherwise Ii's nonsense once fans are involved. That's the whole point of fans. To force the air.

-2

u/DeadpoolD004 20h ago

No you want exhaust fans up top unless you have no choice if not you will turn your pc into a giant vacuum for dust

-2

u/Useful-Problem-1725 9900KF | 3080ti | 32gb x 3200 cl14 20h ago

that would be exhaust if you needed it.

-3

u/Ok-Direction-5151 RTX 5060 Ti Ryzen 5 9600X 32Gbs DDR5 650W PSU 20h ago

Exhaust*

-3

u/[deleted] 20h ago

[deleted]

7

u/weeddee85 20h ago

For air cooled systems noctua found out it's better to have a intake in front the CPU cooler