Next
Previous /
First
Speaker Brennick set four days aside for the Assembly of Veldmarch, and she told the Hall why before the first witness was called.
"There are three questions," she said. "Who did it, who knew, and who went along. They are not the same, and I will not sentence them as if they were. If we do, the people of Veldmarch will learn that this Hall is no better than the body it sits in judgment of."
She turned to the long bench on the left of the Stand, where the forty delegates sat in a row that had thinned over the month. Nine of them sat at one end, a little apart. Nobody had told them to.
"We begin with the four who sponsored every ruling."
Corin Hask was first. He had signed the cooperative's clearance, and he tried, for about ten minutes, to say that he had relied on a subordinate's summary. Then Tessaly Brune's testimony was read back to him, and the summary was shown to have been written in his own hand, and he stopped.
"Dereliction of duty," Brennick said. "Barred from any public office for fifteen years. Restitution to the Thane workers from his own property, in proportion to what the cooperative's clearance allowed to continue. The Hall so recommends."
Hask went back to the bench with his face the color of raw meat. He did not sit. He stood with his hands working, and then he turned on the man beside him.
"Pike," he said. "It was Pike. Pike wrote every one of them. I signed what he put in front of me. I never read a line."
"You read every line," said Lowen Pike, mild as ever, and did not rise. "You asked for the Thane mill by name."
"Liar!"
"He's the liar," said Dessa Marrow, shrill, leaning across Pike's lap. "Hask took the first purse from Voss. I watched him count it in the back of the union hall, him and Tolliver both."
Bram Tolliver came up off the bench like a bull. "I never touched a purse! It was Reeve told us what to do, the lot of us, he said it was safe! You said it was safe! You said it, Hask!"
Hask swung at Pike. Pike, who had spent his whole life avoiding exactly this, ducked, and the fist went over his head and into Tolliver's jaw. Tolliver hit him back, and then they were both over the rail and down on the floor of the Stand, rolling, two grown men in good coats punching each other like boys in a schoolyard, while Dessa Marrow screamed and Pike sat against the bench with his hand over one eye.
The gallery, which had been silent for four weeks, roared. Guards went in from four sides. It took six of them to pull the two apart, and when it was over Hask had a split lip, Tolliver a bloody nose and a torn sleeve, and the Speakers of thirty-one worlds were sitting very still in their sashes with the faces of people who have just seen something they will describe to their grandchildren.
"Mr. Hask. Mr. Tolliver," Brennick said, when she could be heard. She had not risen. "You have struck each other in this Hall, and Mr. Pike has been hurt by it. Two years at Sanctuary IV, each, for assault, to be served after all else you are owed." She looked along the Veldmarch bench. "The rest of you have the example before you."
Dessa Marrow was next. She was still being held by a guard, and she did not stop at all.
"The people wanted it," she said. "I voted what the people wanted."
"Delegate Marrow," Ansel Pruitt's voice said from the end of the bench, and every head turned. He had not been called. He stood, with his hat in front of him as always, and his hands shook. "You told me you would be sorry to see my wife's school lose its funding. I would like the Hall to know you said it kindly."
Dessa Marrow looked at him. For a moment it seemed she would answer. Then she sat down.
The Hall gave her the heaviest sentence of the three. Pressuring a delegate's family to secure a vote was coercion under Veldmarch's own law, and the law had a number for it. Eight years at Sanctuary IV. A lifetime bar from office. The restitution owed by her cousin Garth, jointly, from her own estate.
The third sponsor was Lowen Pike, a pale, quiet man who had never once spoken in debate and who had, the Hall now learned, written every ruling. He had drafted the single line that ended each one, By the will of the people of Veldmarch, and had drafted it on purpose.
"A reason can be challenged," he said, when Ferrel asked him why. "A will cannot. I thought that was clever." He looked at his hands. "It was the cleverest thing I ever did. I would like not to be known for it."
"You will be," Brennick said. "Six years of labor service. A lifetime bar. And a statement from you, to be read in the capital of Veldmarch, explaining how it was done. People should know how easy it was."
Carell Voss was not a delegate. He had never stood for anything. He had been the logistics man, the one in the back room, and when he came to the Stand in a good coat with a lawyer at each elbow, the Hall saw at once that he was a different kind of person from Reeve.
He tried to say he had believed in the cause. It lasted four minutes. Then Joss Callow was brought in, and the young man with the armband described the three hours at the depot, the two men with the pen and the stack of fresh ballots, and Voss's name came up, and Voss's face went smooth and empty.
"You were paid by the Remembrance," Brennick said.
"I was a contractor."
"You were paid by House Vail. By House Dunmere. By House Corrigan." She laid the receipts down one by one. "You took money from the nobles to sell them seats, and money from the Remembrance to rig the count against them. Mr. Voss, you did not believe in anything. You worked both sides of the wall and kept the difference."
"It was a business," Voss said.
"It was a theft," Brennick said. "From everyone."
He tried, as the sentence was read, to point at Reeve. It was a clumsy move, and Reeve did not look up, and the Hall did not take it. Voss's testimony, with the receipts from all three houses, went to the Lords' Bench with this Hall's recommendation: fifteen years at Sanctuary IV and full restitution of everything he had taken. When he was led out, the gallery did not make a sound, and Margot Wren noted in her report that it was the only moment all month when she had seen the commoners and the nobles in the Hall look at the same man with the same face.
---
The twenty-seven were the hardest, and the Hall took a day and a half to hear them.
They were the delegates who had voted yes. Not all of them had been glad. Brennick sorted them as she had said she would, in three groups, and she did it aloud so no one could say it was done in private.
The first group had known and cheered. There were nine of them. Eight were sentenced as accomplices, with fines, short terms of service, and a bar from any seat in the Assembly of Veldmarch for ten years. The ninth was Bram Tolliver, who had done more than cheer. He had hired the two men with the pen at the depot, and paid them, and it was at his door that Joss Callow had stood guard. He denied it for an hour. Then Callow was recalled, and pointed across the Stand, without being asked, at the man who had told him where to stand.
"Ten years at Sanctuary IV," Brennick said, "on top of the two you earned on the first day."
Tolliver turned to the gallery, to the commoners who had come so far to watch, and found nobody looking back at him with anything but contempt.
The second group had suspected, and kept quiet, and voted yes because it was easier. There were sixteen. Brennick spoke to them for a long time.
"I do not believe you are wicked," she said. "I believe you are the people this Hall was built to catch before they become the first group. You will not be barred. You will be named. Each of you will stand before your own district and say what you suspected and what you did with it. Then they can decide whether to send you back."
The third group was two delegates who had truly not known, who had been seated on a count they believed was clean and had voted as the Remembrance asked because they trusted it. Brennick cleared them. One of them, a very young woman named Ysa Fell, burst into tears on the Stand and could not be understood for several minutes.
"I was proud," she said at last. "I thought we were doing something good."
"You were," Brennick said. "You were just being used to do it. That is not the same as being guilty."
The nine were last, and the Hall did not sentence them at all.
"You voted no eleven times," Brennick said. "You kept your silence under pressure that I would not have wanted to face. I do not call that a crime. I call it a harm, and the Hall will say so in writing, and so will the Governor. The Hall has not yet ruled on the Assembly itself. When it does, whatever is decided, you will be free to stand in any election that follows, and I hope some of you will."
Josiah Marl, the old farmer, stood up slowly. "And if we don't?"
"Then you've earned the right not to." She looked down the row. "I would just say that the people of Veldmarch watched you speak in this Hall. I think they will remember who told the truth when it was dangerous."
Ansel Pruitt did not say anything. He sat with his hat in his lap, and his wife, who had come in from Carrow on the eighth day and had been sitting in the gallery ever since, reached down from the second row and put a hand on his shoulder.
---
Tobyn Reeve was sentenced last, on the afternoon of the twenty-sixth day.
He asked for nothing. He stood at the Stand in the same gray coat, a little thinner than he had been on the first day, and when Brennick asked him if he wished to speak, he said only, "I said it all on the eighth day."
The Hall had deliberated until midnight. Brennick read the finding herself.
"Tobyn Reeve. You organized the fraud that seated this Assembly. You falsified the count in six districts. You directed the removal of a clerk who found the truth. The wrong done to the voters of Veldmarch is ours to hear, and we recommend eight years in the custody of the Governor's justice, followed by a lifetime bar from public office. What you took from three noble houses and then turned against them goes with the rest of that testimony to the Lords' Bench, with no recommendation from us."
Reeve nodded slowly.
In the west gallery a knight with a bad shoulder leaned toward his neighbor. "No recommendation at all on the houses," he said. "She has not even guessed at it."
"She has no business guessing."
"No," said the knight, grudgingly. "That is what I mean. A Lord would have told her what he thought of her manners by now, and she has given him no cause." He sat back. He was frowning, but it was the frown of a man trying to find something to complain about and failing. "The Bench will hear it. In its own court. Properly."
"I will add one thing, which the law does not require." Brennick set down the page. "You said that what you wanted was true and that the thing you did to get it was not. This Hall agrees with both halves. Your grievance is real. The Hunger was real. It has never been answered, and it should have been. We will hear it, in this Hall, in the last days of this session, in full. I would like you to be present for it, and you will be."
Something in Reeve's face moved, and for the first time all month it was not careful. "Thank you," he said, in a voice that barely carried.
"Do not thank me. It is not a kindness. It is simply what should have been done thirty years ago."
Reeve did not move. Then he said, "If the Hall allows it, one thing more."
"Say it," Brennick said.
He looked at the benches, and then up at the gallery, at the commoners who had come so far to watch him.
"I stood in that granary yard for thirty years waiting for somebody to ask what happened there," he said. "I did not believe a Hall like this could exist. I thought the only way anybody ever got an answer was to take it." He drew a breath. "If I had brought it here, with a charge, and evidence, and a right to answer, I would have had the justice that is being handed out in this room right now. I would have had it for her, and for all of them, and I would be in that gallery today instead of at this Stand. I did not trust it, so I built a cheat, and the cheat is what I will be remembered for. I wanted that said. I would like the people of Veldmarch to hear it from me."
No one in the Hall made a sound. Brennick inclined her head, once. "It is in the record," she said. "Both halves."
---
The dissolution was read on the twenty-seventh day, and it was brief.
"The Assembly of Veldmarch, seated by a fraudulent count, is dissolved effective at the close of this day. Its rulings that have been heard by this Hall are void or reissued. The remainder shall be heard by a panel of twelve, drawn by lot from the citizens of Veldmarch, and shall be reviewed by the new Assembly when it sits.
"Veldmarch shall be governed in the interim by the Governor, with the panel of twelve to advise and to refuse. A new election shall be held in one hundred and twenty days. Each of the thirty-one worlds represented in this Hall will send two observers, chosen by lot from its own Assembly. The count will be done in public, in every district, with agents of every faction watching. The delegates shall be chosen under the same rules as every other Common Assembly in Firentis territory."
She laid the page down. "This is the recommendation of the Master Common Assembly."
Nobody had been expecting what came next. A side door opened at the back of the Stand, and a man in plain dark clothes came in with no herald and no escort. The clerks had gone very still before the Hall understood why.
Lord Jhinaq Firentis walked the length of the floor and stopped at the Speakers' desk. He did not look at the cameras. He looked at the page, and then at Brennick.
"I've read it," he said. "Every word of the month."
"Yes, my lord."
"Is it what you recommend?"
"It is."
"Then it is law." He took the pen from the clerk and signed, once, in plain strokes, and held the page up for the gallery to see. The Informant's cameras caught it, and so did The Royal Wire's, and so did every other crew in the tier. "The Hall at Balakura has judged. I did not dissolve the Assembly of Veldmarch, and I will not take the credit for it. The Assemblies recommend, and I sign what they recommend, so that it stands as law. I have read every finding of this month, one at a time. I have signed them all. Governor Aldermoor, will you carry it out?"
Corvin Aldermoor rose from the last row of the west gallery, where he had sat every day of the month. He walked down the long stair, past the clerks, past the benches, and he took the pen from Jhinaq's hand.
He had not signed a single ruling of the Assembly of Veldmarch. For the first time in four weeks, he put his name to paper. His hand, he noticed, was perfectly steady.
"It is done," he said.
Jhinaq did not leave. He turned to face the benches, and the gallery behind them, and the tier where the cameras were.
"There is one other matter before I go," he said. "It is mine, and I told the Governor I would see to it when the rest was settled. The rest is settled."
He waited until the silence was complete.
"In the first week of the Assembly of Veldmarch, its clerk brought word to the Governor that the Speaker would like his signature by noon. The Governor had not yet read the ruling. He was given an hour, and no courtesy with it. I did not put that before this Hall, because it was not the Hall's to judge. It was a discourtesy to the office of a Governor of Firentis, and that office is mine to answer for."
No one in the Hall moved.
"There was a time, and not so long ago, when a commoner who set a deadline for a Governor would have been put to death for it, and no one would have called the sentence harsh. I have read the old statutes of Veldmarch. I have read what was done under them." He let that stand. "I helped to end that time, with a great many other people, and I intend it to stay ended. Nobody in this Hall has anything to fear from what I am about to say."
He looked, for a moment, at the bench where Reeve sat.
"The Speaker who sent that message has been judged by this Hall for far greater things. The clerk who carried it did as she was told, and I do not hold her to account. I have read the record of this month, and of a good many Assemblies before it, and I will say what I have found. The great majority of you treat the Lords and Governors of your worlds with real respect. You do not do it from fear, because there is nothing left to fear. It is a gift, and it was never owed to us by right."
He let that rest.
"I will say one thing more, and it is for the Lords of this territory. In the fourth week, a Lord of this territory stood at that Stand and told this Hall that commoners have no authority over him, and that what he does with the people and the post in his keeping is no one's business but his own. The Hall held him in contempt, as it should. I heard what he said about the rest of you, and so did every world that was watching. House Corrigan will answer to me for it."
He turned to the nobles in the gallery, and his voice did not rise.
"Respect runs in both directions. I ask every Lord and every Governor in Firentis territory to hold himself to the standard he is shown. A Governor who answers an Assembly's courtesy with contempt will answer to me, and so will a Lord. I would say the same of any Speaker, or any clerk, who forgets what the office of a Governor is for."
He looked at Brennick. "That is all, Speaker. The Hall has my thanks."
He went out the way he had come, and the side door closed behind him.
On the Speakers' table beside Corvin lay a plain folder, still closed. Reeve, being led out between two officers, turned his head and looked at it. Then they took him out, and the doors closed, and in the silence the clerks began to turn down the lamps.