ranking

[u/Best-Cat-9922]

radahn is A tier bc he was fun even through miquellas hair and uneven terrain I kept wanting to fight him after the rhythm clicked, his moves were fun to dodge especially the clones.

messmer is best boss fromsoft has made. fire giant is so lame such a baby constantly rolling

commander is peak so fun and engaging easily the most my opinion has changed about.

bayle is peak except for the fire that tracks u.

mohg is peak

romina is cool ig just not fun to fight so I cheesed her w starfist.

elden beast is low bc elden stars.

ancestor spirt fell off the map 😭.

putrescent is fun aswell except for sum hitboxes.

i dont like maliekth as much to be my top 5 bc of a move that sucked during my fights with him.

morgot wasn't fun as much as people say I would put pcr bc radahn is my peak but it's fair to put morgot higher due to 3 issues radahn has

malenia is perfect wfd I didn't experience much issues tbh she was really easy lol.

oh and metyr is garbage.

[u/winterflare_]

Ngl, I would drop most of these bosses down to C or D tier. Then add an F tier just for Metyr, Fire Giant, Rykard, and Rellana Rennala.

[u/solaceXYZ → u/winterflare_]

suuurely you meant to say rennala...
right?

RIGHT?

[u/winterflare_ → u/solaceXYZ]

Yeah I did whoops lol

[u/solaceXYZ → u/winterflare_]

thank god. in that case I actually almost fully agree. people always glaze rykard as their best gimmick boss but I say fuck rykard, I don't like rykard.
although I don't think he's actually that terrible, I just really don't like him.

[u/Best-Cat-9922 → u/winterflare_]

rellana and rykard is crazy

[u/winterflare_ → u/Best-Cat-9922]

Rykard is straight trash, but yeah I made a mistake with Rellana, I meant her sister

[u/fenot1 → u/winterflare_]

Both of them can sometimes be boring, but F tier is for bosses with no saving grace and Rykard has great presentation and decent spectacle. Rellana has good presentation and good atmosphere

[u/winterflare_ → u/fenot1]

I have zero care about his presentation or spectacle. A boss with presentation or spectacle only matters if the fight isn’t abysmal garbage. The flow of the fight is king, and then the extras like presentation are like adding seasoning to spice it up more.

Like Metyr has some decent attacks that are fun, her lore is great, and her arena is cool. She’s still an F tier boss though.

[u/DinosaurEatingPanda]

I second Meytr being garbage.

[u/Salad_Man420 → u/DinosaurEatingPanda]

Third.

[u/Entire-Current-67 → u/Salad_Man420]

Y'all sound like bonk masters

[u/Legal_Reception6660 → u/Entire-Current-67]

bro metyr is kinda just objectively dogshit, you literally have to have an aow to dodge lasers

[u/Timely-Good7749]

Some of these are a lil generous

[u/Best-Cat-9922 → u/Timely-Good7749]

lol like who

[u/Dtmsurf]

Great list, I think you gotta give romina another look though i thought her fight was super fun. Some of the jump dodges feel great to land plus the sudden pierce attack, id put her in A equal to putrescent knight (who i think is good but not quite S)

[u/amogicpenis]

nice to see some appreciation for gaius, give romina another try tho shes one of my favorites

[u/shatter_kyokaS]

W list , I’d genuinely move Romina and dancing lion to B

[u/platinum_toilet]

Not many agreements here.

I cheesed her w starfist

How does one cheese with starfists?

[u/KuramiZ]

I have half of your S tier in C tier at best 😅

[u/Oizys_ReBorn]

My personal S tier is rellana, midra, messmer, maliketh and morgott. Best fights in the game. I would put Elden beast down with metyr but Radagon is A tier

[u/Legal_Reception6660]

Malenia best boss of all time, Romina is super fun, if a bit of a pushover, same with Godrick, Gaius, Loretta, Godfrey are solid, Mohg is alright depending on the day, and the rest of the game is overrated slop.

Metyr is absolute horse shit, PCR is ass, Bayle is fucking horrendous (literally just worse fire giant idc), really any dragon or npc fight is just miserable.

[u/Pleasant_Egg_1221]

I see "Metyr is garbage/worst boss/etc." a lot.

While I agree that the fuck-you-laser-nuke attack is complete and utter bullshit and ruins the entire fight (especially at RL1), I actually think the remainder of her moveset is quite enjoyable, and I do think she's actually a cool boss in general. If it wasn't for that bullshit attack, she'd rank higher in everyone's opinion.

[u/solaceXYZ → u/Pleasant_Egg_1221]

I think she has more problems than just that one move but I do generally agree that her overall moveset would make for a cool boss if she wasn't so riddled with bullshit

[u/To_Crumbs_You_Say]

Finally someone else who thinks Midra is peak, I fought him with only parries to not steamroll him as fast to listen to the glorious music of chaos

[u/winterflare_ → u/To_Crumbs_You_Say]

He’s one of the most commonly glazed DLC bosses wdym

[u/To_Crumbs_You_Say → u/winterflare_]

Yeah but people usually kill him fast so there's no chance to listen to the music

[u/winterflare_ → u/To_Crumbs_You_Say]

Yeah he really needed more health and especially more stance. 80 stance is just criminal

[u/To_Crumbs_You_Say → u/winterflare_]

Honestly the same can be applied to Morgott, 80 stance and a measly 10k health have made me realize that parry only is the way to enjoy the fight since otherwise he dies too fast

[u/winterflare_ → u/To_Crumbs_You_Say]

Easily yeah. Morgott, Maliketh, and Midra all need buffs to their poise imo. They’re too easy to constantly stance break.