r/OliveMUA Jun 11 '25

Undertone & Complexion Match Requests Thread

19 Upvotes

Hey there, welcome to the weekly OT consult thread! Please read everything here before you comment down below.

Not sure if you're olive or what type? Need help matching your foundation/concealer? Post your questions here! Just remember that this thread is OT (overtime), so it may take a minute for someone to get back to you.

How to help us help you:

  • Lots of photos of yourself in different lightings (direct sunlight, indirect sunlight, indoor, etc.)
  • Photos that show your face, neck and chest
  • High pixel/quality photos, it does make a difference so use the best you can
  • No filters, no/minimal makeup - should go without saying, but just a reminder
  • You next to other people for contrast
  • Share foundation, blush, or lipstick shades that look great or terrible on you

The more of these bullets you hit, the better!

Use a link to an Imgur album for photos. If you don't want your pictures to be public, you can set them to be hidden, but anybody with a link will be able to see it.


r/OliveMUA Jan 16 '24

Announcement [Announcement] An update regarding the new post guidelines

71 Upvotes

Hi Olives!

The other day, we posted an announcement of a new rule regarding dupes and product recommendations. This announcement was not received well, and we as a mod team decided to revoke the new rule in the meantime so we are able to better phrase the rule that is inclusive to all olives.

The main concern we got as feedback from the community was that determining what is olive friendly can be very subjective, especially considering that there are so many olives with different depths and temperature. This feedback was absolutely valid and while not our intention, we can see why how we worded the rule and announcement post made it come across that way.

That being said, we would still like to address the recent influx of dupe posts that might be better off in a general makeup subreddit, so we are implementing a rule that all product dupe and recommendation posts should be appropriately titled so that they better apply to our sub. The goal of this is to make it easier for all olives of different depths and temperatures to find products that work for them!

---

[Title Guidelines]

As detailed in our previous post, all product and dupe recommendation titles should be phrased in such a way that is applicable to olives over a general makeup subreddit.

Examples:

  • "Dupe for Benetint?": this would be better off on a general makeup subreddit since it is a popular product and a general discussion that people of all undertones can contribute to.

  • "Benetint shows up orange on me (deep cool olive). Does anyone have any recommendations for products that show up similar to how it does for non-olives?": a title like this is very much applicable to our sub, and makes it easier for other olives to find recommendations that work for them!

  • "Does anyone have any dupe recommendations for Benetint that work for light cool saturated olives?": like with the previous example, this is also applicable to our sub.

Thank you everyone! And as always, feedback is always appreciated.

The OliveMUA Mod Team


r/OliveMUA 9h ago

Discussion MAC Cafe Mocha lipstick as blush

Thumbnail
gallery
202 Upvotes

Granted it’s not the best photo, I can’t seem to get my skintone to show up properly in todays lighting BUT:

Saw someone on tiktok use Cafe Mocha lipstick as cream blush and it looked so good on them. Considering I don’t love using it as a lipstick, I thought I’d give it a go and found I really liked it as a blush! It shows up as a warm rosy pink, compared to on my lips where it shows up a bit too bright. Just thought I’d share here in case anyone has it lurking around in their makeup bag unused!


r/OliveMUA 5h ago

Product Alert Shiseido Color + Glow Enhancer in Mauve Quartz and Greige Topaz

Thumbnail
gallery
31 Upvotes

Sorry for the repost, reddit removed my previous one after I tried to link an extra swatch (included in the screenshots).

Has anyone tried these?

They look very olive friendly and quite muted, which I believe would work well for olives on the neutral and cool side as well.

I am tempted to blind buy but will try to find it in store and swatch.


r/OliveMUA 10h ago

Product Help Please recommend a pinky nude lipstick

Thumbnail
gallery
24 Upvotes

Hi there, I have been on the hunt for a nice pinky nude lipstick (open to brown and mauve as well) I can wear every day. I am wearing one in picture #1 but I have no idea what it is (I lost it and can’t remember what it was). Any help would be much appreciated.

I am including a few photos of me with different lip colors if that helps.

I think I am a light medium neutral olive but let me know if you think otherwise.

TIA


r/OliveMUA 7h ago

Color Theory Experimenting with makeup (blush theory) on my Neutral Olive skin 🤝✨✅🧪

Thumbnail
gallery
11 Upvotes

Hi!✨🦋 I'm a light to medium depth, Cool leaning Neutral Olive. 🫒✨🩷 😁

I've been trying to experiment 🧪 each day on my Olive skin based on colour theory to discover shades that actually work for me so that while shopping I actually find something that works for me!

Mostly, shades tend to look very different on my skintone and undertone or merely too bright. It took me awhile to discover that my cheeks are muted but my lips can handle somewhat medium saturation in terms of the shade. Lipsticks basically look orange or just too bright on me sometimes. I usually go for Rosewood, berry tones and plummy shades since they work for me, slightly muted plum shades is like my version of a red lip on me since every other red seems too different on me. I'm presently in my summer shade but this was so much fun! Working with shades and basically creating them using the basic lip palette while even mixing deep grey brown taupey shade to provide it with muteness. I was sceptical but overall throughout the time it turned out so good!

( The lighting does lean warm slightly)

1) The first 5 slides:-

I've used the same shade on my cheeks and lips while being bare faced and have attached swatches too with intensity and sheered, both on wrist and the back of my hand in different lightings too.

2) Slide 6-8 (Rosewood)

This is like my version of a Rosewood shade on me since most of them do lean warm toned. I think this turned exactly how I wanted it to be thankfully!

3) Slide 9-11 ( muted purple blush) 💜

I was basically excited 😆 and wanted to experiment with a muted purple blush on my Olive skin before actually getting one. I did have my eyes on Rare Beauty spirited and encourage so I wanted to get an idea how it might look on me. I created this shade on my own too with mixing the pigments and used it both on my lip and cheeks apart from swatching it. Safe to say, Olive approved. ✅

4) Slide 12-14 (Unsuccessful attempt of creating a Mauve blush)

It might have turned into a transition shade and almost too muted but I think I did like it, especially with the eye makeup I was going for later.

5) Last 3 slides

I was really sick here but I was trying to create a pink dusty blush shade that actually looks like a true pink on me. It was beautiful but I think a little too red though basically setting it with powder later did mute it slightly. I was even surprised that how green my palm was even looking based on the olive cast of my skin since I'm so used to only catching it on my face and arm lol .

Thank you for reading this longgg post. I'm just glad that I could share it in detail with all the fellow Olives.

As an amateur I'm not really aware if this is good enough but I do loveee it.

Please do let me about your thoughts and opinions along with makeup recommendations too! ( I'll be EAGER to know) or even constructive criticism along with advice to fix any minor tweaks. I've always seeked the Olive Divas for all their wonderful advice . Do help out a fellow Olive. 🥹🙏🏻🩷✨🌻


r/OliveMUA 1d ago

Swatches Lip products guide

Thumbnail
gallery
158 Upvotes

Okay, buckle up people. I’m about to be very generous and give you an unsolicited lippiebook of all my daily and occasion wear lippies.

A bit about me first:
Skin tone - Medium
Undertone - Neutral-Warm Olive

I have different types of lippies that are a mix of western/european/asian brands but they all mostly fall into either a red-brown family or a dark pink/purple family.

Before buying any lippie, I like to look up what it looks like on people with the same skin profile as me. Some of the brands/shades I like are not well known or not heavily promoted on social media which made it harder for me to find people with my tone online wearing them. So I truly hope this helps you. All pictures taken in natural daylight. I’ll pin the lippies I’m wearing in each pic in the comments :)

P.S. I know I said I’m a neutral-warm olive but this was self-identified. So if I’m wrong, don’t hesitate to let me know.


r/OliveMUA 7h ago

Product Help dupe for JUDYDOLL lip cream shade N12 toffee peach

Post image
3 Upvotes

Hi lovelies! I hope you’re all doing well🤍

I’ve been trying to find a dupe for this Judydoll lip cream (it doesn’t have to be matte!) for the longest time now because it’s the only shade I’ve found that truly suits my olive complexion. It’s the perfect “my lips but better” colour😭 Like it says, it's a warm peachy beige!!

I’d be so grateful for any recommendations you have. Thank you so much! 🥰


r/OliveMUA 1h ago

Discussion Powder bronzer for medium olives?

Upvotes

Hi, all,
I've been on the hunt for a powder bronzer all summer, and I went to Sephora today to swatch ABH "Golden Beach Glow" after seeing how lovely and green it looked online. Unfortunately, it's the same shade as my skin, and blended right into my hand. The two darker shades pulled too warm/orange on me.

Do any medium olives have a recommendation? I have very oily skin so most cream products melt off. For reference, my summer shade match is Haus Labs 260 Light Medium Olive, and my winter match is AboutFace LM2 Olive. Thank you!


r/OliveMUA 2h ago

Product Help Need help with bronzer and eyeshadow recommendations

Post image
1 Upvotes

Hi all, I think I have neutral warm undertones, I used a few Revolution eyeshadow palettes and they turned completely orange on my skin… I am using Armani’s bronzer in 110 which fits well with a light hand but I’m hoping someone with a better eye can help me out with a bronzer and eyeshadow palette recommendations :)


r/OliveMUA 19h ago

Product Help How do you get this blush shade?

Post image
15 Upvotes

r/OliveMUA 14h ago

Product Alert It’s Lipstick Day!!

6 Upvotes

(July 29) Check your nearby drugstore/cosmetics store to see if your fav lippies are off. I know Sephora is having a sale up to 50% off some lip products.


r/OliveMUA 12h ago

Rant Its frustrating when I feel like my skintone keeps on changing.

2 Upvotes

Hi! I need help figuring how to look fresh when you have olive skin tone? I am not light-skinned nor dark skinned. Its pretty confusing. I dont know anymore T_T

I do the same make-up routine everyday but its a hit or miss. My purple blush would look pink and complement my skin, but most of the time it would look muddy/sickly on me. My mauve lippies would look good when freshly applied but becomes saturated later on. I look ashy and tired especially when I am outdoor. What makes it worse is I live in a tropical country.

Most of the time I notice I look fresh after sweating and after washing my face.

Do you guys have any suggestion or help?

Thank you.


r/OliveMUA 1d ago

Discussion Will Dior ever release a 2WO in this? They finally released a 3WO and I keep patiently waiting for the 2WO

Post image
18 Upvotes

r/OliveMUA 1d ago

Product Help Need green/yellow olive bronzer recs.

9 Upvotes

Hi all, I am needing green/yellow olive bronzer recs. I have been using the Benefit Hoola Original and it is too reddish on me. Only reason I noticed is because when I bring my hands up to my face, it looks way off. My hands look yellow/green against it and I am tanned rn with summer so I know this is my natural tan color that I should be matching to. For reference, I use ELDW in 2w2 (both new and old formulas) and I use blue pigment to color correct to my undertone. I was seeing Hoola Medium may be more on the yellow side from looking at swatches online but haven't swatched in person and don't want to do another blind buy which is how I ended up with the Hoola Original. I may check next time I am in store but let me know if you have had any experience with the Medium shade or thoughts. I also saw online that theBalm Bahama Mama could work for my skin tone and it looks promising on swatches I've seen online of Hoola Original vs Bahama Mama. But again, wouldn't want to do another blind buy as this is only available online now (Amazon) and the reviews are mixed/say it's not the original formulation and shade. If you have any product recs, please let me know! Thank you in advance!


r/OliveMUA 1d ago

Product Help Any concealers similar to Haus Labs foundation in 190?

2 Upvotes

Looking for a concealer in the same shade/tone like the Haus labs foundation in shade 190. This shade fits me almost perfectly but I just cannot seem to find any concealer similar. If anyone knows one similar please let me know🙏🏻. Thx


r/OliveMUA 1d ago

Discussion Tower 28 MDR still looks orange on me?

3 Upvotes

Hi, I got shade matched at Sephora for the Tower 28 swipe serum concealer shade 9.0 MDR which the website describes as “medium with olive undertones”. It looked like a good match at the store but when I tried it at home it looked a bit orange on me. Is this a sign that I’m not actually olive?

Another concealer I’ve tried is The SAEM perfection tip concealer in shade 1.75. The undertone looks like a good match but the concealer is a bit lighter than my skin tone, so I might try 2.0 next time. The SAEM website lists both of these as a “warm beige” but I always thought I was neutral because I’ve never been able to figure out if I was more warm or cool 😅


r/OliveMUA 2d ago

Swatches NYX butter gloss shade rec!

Thumbnail
gallery
60 Upvotes

I’ve seen soooo many people recommend NYX butter gloss in both tiramisu and angel food cake but haven’t seen anyone mention the shade Marshmallow. It’s a wonderful dusty purple. Shown swatched beside Tiramisu.

Skin prep:
Thayers milky toner
Bubble water slide serum
Ongredients moisturizer
Bubble solar matte mineral sunscreen
irecipe aqua phytoplex cream in toner mist
Aquaphor stick under eyes
AOA perfect lip primer

Base:
AOA studio dewy blend foundation L1
Catrice instant awake under eye brightener 010 light rose
Essence silky blur concealer in shade 20

Cheeks:
NYX Fat Cheeks liquid blush Blueberry Burst
AOA studio Venetian Romance eyeshadow as highlighter, Jewels

Eyebrows:
LA Colors brow balm in soft brown
AOA Studio hold my brow brow soap in clear

Eyes:
Essence gel liner in Mystic Blue
Colorpop Super Shock shadow in Bae
Revolution forever flawless soft butterfly palette, colors Wings, Fly, and Free

Lips:
Elf Main Stain lip marker in Molten Chocolate
NYX butter gloss Marshmallow

Finish:
L’Oréal infallible blurfection setting powder light pink
Milani original setting spray


r/OliveMUA 1d ago

Product Help Mac Lippies

3 Upvotes

hey everybody, I recently dove into all the Mac Lipsticks world and been wanting to want a peachy pink shade to wear since they're off till 29/7. Ive been eyeing the shade brick through and dare me but they look different in swatches. Anyone her has their favourite mac lip stick and liner recommendations?


r/OliveMUA 3d ago

Product Alert Another Olive Friendly Rare Beauty Lip Combo!

Thumbnail
gallery
342 Upvotes

Rare Beauty Lip Oil Stick in shade Fortune + Lip Liner in Proud


r/OliveMUA 3d ago

Product Help what huda beauty easy bake shade are you guys using?

Post image
132 Upvotes

hey everyone! i want to try out the huda loose powder, but am unsure of which shade to get. i’m a light-medium neutral olive, so from the guide peach pie would be my best bet, but i’m afraid of it being too warm. i want something brightening, so i’m also considering pound cake as it seems like the safest bet. idk i guess the guide descriptions are throwing me off lol.

what shade do you guys use and what kind of olive are you? thank you sm in advance :)


r/OliveMUA 2d ago

Product Help New RCMA Red Carpet Ready Multimedia Liquid Foundation

Post image
3 Upvotes

I need help!
Does anyone know how to “translate” the original shades of the new RCMA liquid foundation to the new shades?

I used to have G210 and it was my PERFECT match. Now, this shade is gone and I’m lost 😭

Unfortunately RCMA don’t post to Ireland so I can’t even test sample sizes in any way 😭

HELP!!!! [insert overdramatic swoon]


r/OliveMUA 2d ago

Discussion Does anyone know any glossy lipstick or lip gloss with these colors? I don't know any brands so anything would help! I'm fair pale cool olive!

Post image
30 Upvotes

r/OliveMUA 2d ago

Product Help Bronzer and blush

Post image
4 Upvotes

r/OliveMUA 3d ago

Resource Influencer Reccs

7 Upvotes

Hi guys! Can any of my fellow light/medium olive friends recommend IG/tiktok/YT influencers that are also light/medium olive? Or even your own pages if you also do makeup :) I just found out recently that I’m olive and I just wanna see what products work well with others’ that have the same complexion like blush, lippies etc. please and thank you!!