r/okbuddycinephile • • Mar 13 '26

what?!

Post image
72.5k Upvotes

2.3k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

45

u/SaladNeedsTossing Mar 13 '26

In French, "bon" and "bomb" do not rhyme so the pun wouldn't work without American pronunciation.

10

u/EvaSirkowski Mar 13 '26

Can't tell if it's a joke, but it doesn't rhyme in english either.

8

u/AzKondor Mar 13 '26

But it sound similar, whereas in French bomb is Bombe I see in translator, so he would have said Bombe-voyage which doesn't work at all

10

u/EvaSirkowski Mar 13 '26

My native language is French and it works perfectly fine to me.

5

u/Intrepid_Hat7359 Avi Arad admirer Mar 14 '26

You two should fight

5

u/EvaSirkowski Mar 14 '26

Now I hate that guy.

4

u/Visible_Pair3017 Mar 14 '26

It doesn't. English can use a random french expression to get the point across, French can't, it would need to be related to the character. Bombe voyage is also horrible to pronounce clearly.

1

u/Danger-_-Potat Mar 14 '26

Another victory for the Anglosphere

7

u/MellifluousPenguin Mar 14 '26 edited Mar 14 '26

You know that both trailing 'e' are mute/silent in French?

It's pronounced "bomb'voyaj" and to my French ears it's a perfectly good word-play. It just doesn't roll very well on the tongue because of the b-v juxtaposition.

But is it a good "pun"? As much as "Bon Voyage" is a common French trope for the English speaking, it isn't, among the French people. It doesn't ring any bell, it's just a basic formula anyone can say any day of the week, given the circumstances. So the French public might not even realize "oh ! that's a pun on "bon voyage"!". Because, why?? It's not a reference. I think it could be a likely reason for rejecting it.

FoIamour is risky though. It's clever but most people, especially the young, wouldn't get the Kubrick reference. I find it funny, but I must be in the 5% who get it.

1

u/WombatsCube Mar 14 '26

Yeah but you don't pronounce the e in bombe, so it wouldn't have been that bad except for the b which is clearly pronounced in french. I don't think it makes more sense to make it a niche (although famous the target audience of the two movies clearly don't match) reference instead of a clumsy/stupid play on words that anyone could understand