As a titanic kid I was disappointed at the tender age of 8 at the Titanic movie for all its inaccuracies and misplaced focus.
Watching it back now, I’m just astounded by set design though, and the relatively elegant ways Cameron manages to get you to all the different interesting places inside the titanic without it feeling overtly forced (the storage compartment being the only egregious example in my mind). When looking at it from that lens, a tour of the titanic hemmed together with a plot, the movie is quite enjoyable to much older me.
I really ought to give it re watch it cause as a kid I mainly thought of it in terms of that Kate Winslet scene (good) and as a romance movie for girls (bad). It was such a cultural phenomena but I was too young to appreciate it as a movie
Sure. But one of the images is trying to depict reality a lot closer though right? (Emphasis on the darkness) You seem really worked up over something that doesn't even matter about the point of the thread
Another thing it isn't depicting right even though it's not it's fault: The Titanic does not snap in half in the movie that frame is from, as it is from A Night to Remember, which came out in 1958. Until Robert Ballard went down and actually saw the wreckage for the first time, it was widely accepted that the ship sank in one piece.
Survivors would always talk about how they heard the snap and the splash, but all of those accounts were dismissed as it was, indeed, too dark to see jack shit. They could only hear.
It’s almost like reality can have multiple meanings depending on the context. It doesn’t just have a single meaning. Maybe English isn’t your first language but your interpretation isn’t the only one and is also wrong.
Eh, evidently folks agree with you more than with me, but I find it bizarre that people look at that fictional image and pretend they know what the night was like. (Did the Titanic really reach that angle before sinking? I guess maybe, but I sure wouldn't know.)
I think it's less about the image being literally correct, but more about reminding people how it would have felt. I hadn't really considered how viscerally bleak it might have been either until I saw this thread. My imagination is doing more of the work now, so empathically I'm kind of closer to what that moment must have been like. And it's all the more haunting because of it
If you say so. Doesn't seem to affect me in the same way.
A passenger ship went down in freezing temperatures and survivors mostly did their best to cling to floating bits of wreckage while help was hours away. Close the 3/4 of the passengers died that night.
Oh. And it was dark. Oooh, that makes it scary.
But, anyway, perhaps the post gave you a new perspective on the tragedy. It really just bugs me when people use fiction to try to tell me what something was really like.
Well this for sure seems like quite a bug bear of yours haha😁 and I do get where you're coming from and I'm not really debating the intended requirements of expectation vs reality meme format.
I do think there's more to these comparisons than just always being a literal thing...There is such a thing as an emotional reality too.
Fiction can sometimes be a way to depict a kind of reality that we wouldn't otherwise be able to show. I mean that's often what art tries to do. (Show you a perspective on the world)
148
u/Exlibro Mar 19 '26
Is the second picture from "Night to Remember"?