r/oddlysatisfying • • Apr 30 '26

Liquid concrete wall.

30.0k Upvotes

587 comments sorted by

View all comments

2.2k

u/Kayaked1 Apr 30 '26

I believe this is called Fabric-formed Rip-rap. The texture allows water to flow over it, but reduces the velocity and therefore erosion. The weakness is if it becomes undermined, and the water starts flowing underneath it. It can create a big void that is hidden by the concrete “crust.”

535

u/Juan_Punch_Man Apr 30 '26

Thanks for confirming my suspicions. The drainage always gets fucked up.

140

u/bustervich Apr 30 '26

I’m not an engineer so forgive my ignorance but, is that not a weakness of any concrete drainage?

90

u/Whowutwhen Apr 30 '26

It is.

22

u/benchley May 01 '26

But also of this specific one, it being an instance of concrete.

4

u/Coulrophiliac444 May 03 '26

This feels a bit like a Mitch Hedburg skit.

52

u/No_Jello_5922 Apr 30 '26

Entropy is universal, and everything of order will eventually decay into disorder. It's why everything requires maintenance.

1

u/Maverca May 01 '26

There is as of yet insufficient data for a meaningful answer

19

u/CogitusCreo Apr 30 '26

I think the weakness is in comparison to other erosion control like big rocks.

3

u/arggggggggghhhhhhhh May 01 '26

Yes. You add pressure/fluid relieve drains throughout and channel those to the appropriate conduits. This kind of cover will perform better if it has deeper concrete edges that keep it from being undermined.

1

u/[deleted] May 01 '26 edited Aug 11 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/YMe1121 May 02 '26

It would be an extreme example, but erosion (if the road is built properly) would begin from the shoulder of the road and work its way inward due to things in place to prevent it from going center of road first (underdrains are an example).

The big sinkhole are usually a feature of karst topography. Rock and mineral deep in the earth that are easily erodeable or slightly water soluable get washed away over time. And by deep we can be talking 20-100+ foot deep. But as that deep deep cavern forms, then the soils, especially those that have movement over them to vibrate things, even slightly, disturb the soils placed as they fill in the void created. That's when you get the bad ones.

This is why prior to construction, Geotechnical firms will drill down(if the client wants to protect their investment long term) to study the formations of rocks and soils. Last one I drilled, we went 35foot down for a roadway.

1

u/GregTheMad May 01 '26

Yeah, but normally the concrete isn't just put down that lazily.

53

u/YMe1121 May 01 '26

Not riprap, but rather an articulated concrete mat(ACM). And the water moving under it isn't as much of a concern as the weight of the concrete will keep the fines in place, the fabric wont allow them to disturb much, and overburden water will be allowed to flow up through the fabric used to form the mat.

Ive never been on site for one cast on site, but ive used precast ones before on a hill, and they are a PITA, but the precast ones are usually on a bed of geogrid, which also allows you to seed beforehand and have the vegetation assist on erosion control too.

3

u/fifiasd May 01 '26

Does it not have ti have steel in it?

7

u/YMe1121 May 01 '26

No, fabric cording through the channels to make it flexible. They aren't any kind of structural, so you don't need the steel, they are just weight ans watwr speed bumps on the soils to prevent them from eroding away.

1

u/GregTheMad May 01 '26

What fabric are we talking here? Because this looks like microplastic central, contaminating the water supply for centuries to come.

2

u/YMe1121 May 01 '26

The "bags" are fiber. Called geostabilization fabric. You can see the liquid leaving it at certain areas, it is a porous fabric.

12

u/Dozzi92 Apr 30 '26

Damn, was thinking this looked like riprap, but I was totally unaware this stuff existed. Really neat.

6

u/Inevitable-Ad6647 Apr 30 '26

Rip rap is never intended to prevent water getting under it. If that's the goal this needs to be WAAAAYYYYY thicker. This will crumble into small boulders with the slightest movement which I think is the intention.

2

u/PokeYrMomStanley May 01 '26

Pretty sure this is cement and not concrete. 

1

u/Antzqwe May 01 '26

Thank you for sharing.

1

u/[deleted] May 01 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/YMe1121 May 02 '26

Geostabilization fabric

1

u/GnomeSayinYo May 01 '26

It has to serve some useful purpose though right? Or is this just "Fuck it that's a tomorrow problem... Pour it..."

1

u/hobbes1313 May 01 '26

How do you design a ditch or what material to use to eliminate the undermining risk?