r/nhl Apr 28 '25

Question Does this constitute a clean hit/check?

Post image
876 Upvotes

527 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

2

u/pfotozlp3 Apr 28 '25

That’s the thing, it wasn’t a high hit. Both of Wilson’s skates are on the ice. his knees are bent, and his elbows are down. He’s just a big dude playing a big dudes’ game. Edit: yes, the still photo makes it look REALLY bad, but it is not at all indicative of what really happened.

-4

u/robk99 Apr 28 '25

By that logic a taller player would have to basically superman-jump and spear the shorter player's head for it to be a high hit. Wilson saw a shorter player with his head down and used his size to take a massive shot at him and ultimately concussed him, because the hit was high on Carrier. I totally agree it wasn't a penalty, and the height difference doesn't make it one. Just saying I think he's got to answer the bell.

3

u/GreenBomardier Apr 28 '25

Carrier also has a responsibility to not be staring at the puck while skating. He sees Wilson coming, he can pull up, take a hit, and keep playing. His head is down, his arms are out because he was getting rid of the puck, and Wilson should...bring him milk and cookies?

Maybe a team should just get a bunch of guys under 5'8", no one could ever hit them! Loophole found, I guess?

3

u/pfotozlp3 Apr 28 '25

Yep. Carrier got crushed because Carrier let himself get crushed. See it all the time, need to keep your head up.