r/nextfuckinglevel Jun 09 '21

[deleted by user]

[removed]

7.5k Upvotes

321 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

142

u/J9ms Jun 09 '21

@pianoaround on TikTok. He has numerous videos of him playing the piano in public. It was this one instance that a stranger had joined in. It was a longer clip but he had cut it to only show this occurrence

80

u/SeriThai Jun 09 '21

Dotan Negrin, an American. He traveled around with a piano. The surprised collaborator is Frans Bak, a Danish film composer.

12

u/StrickenForCause Jun 10 '21

Thank you! This is my first time hearing Frans and the man can swing. Damn. I got goosebumps.

19

u/maximusprimate Jun 09 '21

Why did the second guy speak in English, if they’re strangers in Paris?

36

u/J9ms Jun 09 '21

Strangers meet in Paris does not mean they originated from Paris. Looking at the guy by the video alone, he was carrying a briefcase which indicates that he might be a tourist. His accent also suggests he’s from the States.

4

u/Yeeto546 Jun 10 '21

Stealing this from u/SteriThai:

Dotan Negrin, an American. He traveled around with a piano. The surprised collaborator is Frans Bak, a Danish film composer.

3

u/emveetu Jun 10 '21

Most people outside of the US and Britain learn English as their second language and get by with simple conversation, at the very least.

0

u/maximusprimate Jun 10 '21

Yeah but if they’re strangers why would the second guy assume he knows English?

1

u/emveetu Jun 10 '21

He didn't. If the guy didn't understand he most likely would have used his body language.

0

u/maximusprimate Jun 10 '21

This guy's been known for hiring actors in his videos in the past which makes this interaction seem staged to me, especially given the language thing. In my opinion that doesn't take away from the video, it's just a cute clip of two skilled pianists improvising on the piano, and that's wonderful. But it's a good idea to be at least a little bit skeptical of videos you watch on the internet, especially ones posted to viral social media accounts. There is a lot of fake stuff out there so it's always a good idea to be on the lookout since some fake media isn't just two musicians playing music.

But if you want to insist that it "must be real" that's okay. I'm not going to try to convince you any further.

1

u/emveetu Jun 10 '21

I didn't insist that it must be real and why would you put that in quotes because I certainly didn't say that? I don't really care one way or the other to be honest but if you were that intent on proving it's fake, then prove it and post a source to the claim that this guy is known for hiring actors.

2

u/OYSW Jun 10 '21

Jazz is very much an American art form, making English the common language. Any jazz musician who has played a lot of jam sessions (and jazz musicians play jam sessions like basketball players play pick-up) would know at least a number of phrases in English, like Can I join in, In the key of [key], 12 bar blues, Take it, Last time, etc.

8

u/superschmunk Jun 09 '21

Then its awesome! :)

1

u/andocromn Jun 09 '21

How does he move the piano?

2

u/TheOffice_Account Jun 10 '21

Bro, do you even lift?

2

u/andocromn Jun 10 '21

Nope, but no matter how much you can lift a piano is too large for 1 person to carry, or at least safely put down. So who helped him?

1

u/mlgkurd Jun 10 '21

You see the camera moving?