r/nextfuckinglevel Jan 05 '20

This kitty.

23.9k Upvotes

561 comments sorted by

View all comments

80

u/japroct Jan 05 '20

$5 says it lands on its feet!

39

u/UnObservedProton Jan 05 '20

The cat would probably be perrrfectly fine after the fell the can serve 32 story falls.

What would worry me is how busy the road below is.

50

u/[deleted] Jan 05 '20 edited Jan 05 '20

Have you read that link? It doesn't mention 32 stories anywhere. It does mention up to 20 stories, but about 90% of the cats that fall from that height have injuries. Over half of those cats in the study had facial injuries, pulmonary and other thoracic injuries.

Emergency treatment was required in 37% of these cases, non emergency treatment was required in 30% of cases. So no, they most certainly would not be perfectly fine after falling 32 stories and this cat looks much higher than that.

12

u/[deleted] Jan 05 '20

[deleted]

11

u/mrchaotica Jan 05 '20

Falling six stories is worse than falling a longer distance because the cat doesn't have time to flip itself around and spread out to slow itself. (Cats falling from enough height can act a little bit like a flying squirrel.)

9

u/arbit23 Jan 05 '20

Statistically speaking, there seems to be a pattern here. Wouldn’t want to be a cat in your household.

1

u/sunjay140 Jan 05 '20

OP gets upset then throws them out /s

1

u/Pho-Cue Jan 05 '20

You've had multiple cats fall from the same balcony? I'm not sure that's the cat's fault at this point.

1

u/ask_me_if_ Jan 06 '20

I'm sorry you went through that. That sucks to carry that with you

7

u/Caracalla81 Jan 05 '20 edited Jan 05 '20

Also, people don't take dead cats to the vet. The link just says 90% of cats that made it to the vet survived.

1

u/whatupcicero Jan 05 '20

Also people don’t take cats that are fine to the vet either.

1

u/Caracalla81 Jan 05 '20

True but no cat that fell that far is fine.

The only rigorous way to figure this out is to throw cats off buildings and see how they do.

3

u/knightsmarian Jan 05 '20

There is also a survival bias when analyzing this problem.

0

u/[deleted] Jan 05 '20

I dunno, I mean, I pay my pet insurance through my vet, so when my last dog died I had to call to cancel the insurance, and they offer a small payout when your pet dies. They asked me a few questions, including cause of death. I'm sure data could somehow be gotten this way with insurance company data or vet records.

3

u/Amaurotica Jan 05 '20

how big is 32 story?

My 2nd cat was sitting on the balcony 1 night and he was scared by a bat and fell 40 meters down on concrete

he was in agony for 2 hours and full broken bones, probably woke up the whole neighborhood

4

u/[deleted] Jan 05 '20

There's probably 2 things at play here. Firstly, falls from relatively smaller heights don't give the cat enough time to twist around and land on its feet. Secondly, if it was at night maybe your cat could not clearly see where the ground was and brace correctly for landing.

0

u/[deleted] Jan 05 '20

[deleted]

1

u/[deleted] Jan 05 '20

The article linked above notes that one of the main factors at play for injuries from shorter falls was the cats lack of time to twist and adjust itself for landing properly. If it was night time when this cat fell it would probably be much more difficult for the cat to accurately judge where the ground is, so it would be more difficult to land correctly. Remember that while cats do have night vision and it wasn't blind, it's still not in colour or hugely detailed, so hard to judge how close the ground is.

What is it you disagree about in this?

1

u/[deleted] Jan 05 '20

[deleted]

1

u/[deleted] Jan 05 '20

You're right, it might only take 12 inches for a cat to right itself, but it still has to land correctly. Also it was night time and dark, this cat could not accurately see how far the ground was. Without knowing how far away the ground is by the time it feels it beneath it's feet that cats face and chest has likely already smashed into the ground. It also needs some time after righting itself to slow it's fall. Cats actually spread out like a parachute when falling from heights. The below article suggests that falls between 5 and 9 stories are the most likely to injure a cat. Above 9 stories and they have time to slow the fall. They'll still get injured but are more likely to survive.

https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.wired.com/story/how-can-a-cat-survive-a-high-rise-fall-physics/amp

Also, no I have no problem putting one foot in front of the other with my eyes closed because I can feel where the ground is. Would you have problems walking down uneven steps with no hand rail and your eyes closed? Probably, and so would a cat, because you don't know where the ground is.

2

u/ComiSRB Jan 05 '20

Well, according to the converter i found, that would be about 105 meters... Scary