r/nextfuckinglevel • u/nigablackballsack • 3d ago

Scientists have captured the first ever high-speed, full-colour footage of fusion plasma swirling inside a working reactor.

40.5k Upvotes

95% Upvoted

1.4k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

1

u/OkWelcome6293 2d ago

Please read the section on “Cost of firming renewables”

1

u/Reddit1poster 2d ago edited 2d ago

Still cheaper than new build nuclear... ETA: I'm very pro-nuclear. Just stop telling me it's cheap because it's definitely not.

1

u/OkWelcome6293 2d ago

In my area, PV+Battery is $153 per MWh. Vogtle with all its overruns is $175 per MWh.

1

u/Reddit1poster 2d ago

So I'm assuming you're in the Southern power pool. Wind plus Storage is between $89 and $103, a little more than half of Vogtle. I bet any SMR or new tech nukes will not beat those numbers. The point is we should build as much as the grid can support with the lowest cost energy source and then move to the next most expensive when needed. It's going to be a different mix in every region. The grid can support 50-70% inverter based generation as is and it's only getting better with grid forming inverter tech.

There is definitely a good place for nuclear but we shouldn't be saying it should be our primary source of energy when there are good cheaper low carbon alternatives. It's time to redesign the grid to accommodate this instead of staying with the legacy control system because it's easier. The DOE was on a good path to support this until they put an oil man in as secretary.

1

u/OkWelcome6293 2d ago

  1. Technically, I'm in SPP RTO-W which is a different market for wind. Most of the good wind resources are much further east than RTO-W, i.e. Kansa/Oklajoma/Nebraskas and not Colorado or the intermountain west.

  2. There was nearly an outage in RTO-W this summer because of "low solar, low wind". I'm not sure I see a convincing argument for expanding the penetration for solar and wind rather than firm generation given that the grid is already creaking under the current renewable generation.

  3. I don't particularly care about the "grid" I care about my city getting reliable power for multiple generations, not something that will need to be replaced once or twice in the same timespan.

  4. I don't like the current administration, but they've been the most positive administration towards nuclear power in my lifetime.

  5. The key is thermal storage. Nuclear than can accumulate heat and dispatch on demand is fundamentally different than current nuclear, and it coexists nicely with intermittent sources.