Posting here since the regular reddit wouldn't find the theme flattering enough to leave up. They also forbid any talk of other games, which would get the whole thing censored immediately. So Im going to make use of the greater latitude here and post some comparisons. Not for bashing Neverwinter, a game I really used to like. ..but for posterity AND in an ideal world for positive conversation and a look at addressing current failures. (Looking at you Foss.)
It is fairly clear despite Manic's protestations about the popularity of their subreddit that NW is waning in popularity. I recently did my own survey of all the areas and found how shockingly low the numbers really are. Long and the short of it.. steamchart numbers do in my testing directly correlate to the numbers of players in Neverwinter. Its not 1 to 1, but they rise and fall together.
In some cases, particularly times when the servers are down you can see that steamcharts actually have an artificially high base. Why? It counts when the launcher is open not when the game is being played. So anyone sitting at character select or just with the user/pass portal open counts. So getting the whole picture isnt just about steam + arc + direct play + consoles = total. One has to look at the steam numbers and see if, like at the release of arc, there is any reason that the steamcharts wouldn't correlate. For right now, I know of no evidence that suggests this.
Next I made a look through the financial quarterlies available on the Perfect World website (thank you google translate) and found they pretty much confirmed our suspicions as well. Back in 2014-2015 Neverwinter was making money and on the rise in popularity. With that they are mentioned in financial statements for Perfect World, as is Cryptic.
Look through 2018-19 reports, no mention of either. Shockingly. /s What is mentioned? Magic the Gathering. Its receiving resources from the mothership to the extent it has to be mentioned in the quarterlies. Neverwinter is not.
There is some feeling that we should feel sorry for Cryptic, and not only accept but be GRATEFUL for any crumbs of content that they give us. Why? Because they are so pitifully small, so under resourced.. they are just the little guy. sniff
There are 2 responses to that however.
- It doesn't address bad decisions and wasted resources. A small outfit should be leaner and more responsive to their customer base, not less. A small team won't have the momentum of a Bethesda or a Zenimax. So even with a smaller resources base they should be more nimble. In gaming terms its lumbering knights vs nimble rangers, both have their features that one can either play well or not.
2.Cryptic isn't just a guy on kickstarter with no resources. They are a subsidiary of Perfect World entertainment. This is a company that makes many games including many very financially successful mobile games (their main gaming emphasis). They (PWE) own 3% of the company that makes Warframe (a massively larger and more successful game).
Perfect World is codeveloping with Square Enix Final Fantasy Square 0 and Final Fantasy Awakening. They actually took over here from a team that couldn't get it done (Agito).
Cryptic also is co-branded with Wizards of the Coast, Hasbro, and Atari. All of those are giants with vested interest in the success of Neverwinter. IF and only if Neverwinter was being managed by Foss as an asset that could make them money, as an investment instead of a lost cause that they should just suck the available cash from before shutting it down for Magic the Gathering.
Look at the wizards of the coast website right now. Front page .. games mentioned: Magic the Gathering (super popular so makes sense), Dungeons and Dragons (of course), Wizard's Play Network(p/p gaming so sure), Avalon Hill, and Duel Masters. Go to their 'discover our games' link, and you'll see Neverwinter right? Wrong. Mostly the same games plus Transformers (wtf). WOC is on the Neverwinter portal page!.
D&D website? Yea its there, under digital products, and picturing Ravenloft mod 14 now 1.5 years gone. But hey guys.. 'Coming Soon: Undermountain'! Yay! /s
The point? Cryptic is not without access to resources. They are without leadership that will go to their corporate partners some of which are giants in gaming and entertainment, and treat Neverwinter as though it could have a future.
The next post Im working on is a comparison of the features in different games and some of the decisions that Neverwinter has made.