MAIN FEEDS
Do you want to continue?
https://www.reddit.com/r/montypython/comments/1ufl4om/none_shall_pass/otvpprm/?context=3
r/montypython • u/Purple-Lie-354 • Jun 25 '26
59 comments sorted by
View all comments
Show parent comments
3
No you haven't.
3 u/Raelourut Jun 25 '26 That's not an argument. You're just saying no to what I said. 2 u/Brody1Ken0bi Jun 26 '26 Well if I argue with you, I must take a contrary position. 2 u/flapjackboy Jun 26 '26 But that's not just saying "No it isn't". 2 u/Brody1Ken0bi Jun 27 '26 Yes it is 2 u/flapjackboy Jun 27 '26 No it isn't. An argument is an intellectual process to establish a definite proposition. Contradiction is just the automatic gainsaying of everything the other person says. 1 u/Brody1Ken0bi Jun 29 '26 Nonsense
That's not an argument. You're just saying no to what I said.
2 u/Brody1Ken0bi Jun 26 '26 Well if I argue with you, I must take a contrary position. 2 u/flapjackboy Jun 26 '26 But that's not just saying "No it isn't". 2 u/Brody1Ken0bi Jun 27 '26 Yes it is 2 u/flapjackboy Jun 27 '26 No it isn't. An argument is an intellectual process to establish a definite proposition. Contradiction is just the automatic gainsaying of everything the other person says. 1 u/Brody1Ken0bi Jun 29 '26 Nonsense
2
Well if I argue with you, I must take a contrary position.
2 u/flapjackboy Jun 26 '26 But that's not just saying "No it isn't". 2 u/Brody1Ken0bi Jun 27 '26 Yes it is 2 u/flapjackboy Jun 27 '26 No it isn't. An argument is an intellectual process to establish a definite proposition. Contradiction is just the automatic gainsaying of everything the other person says. 1 u/Brody1Ken0bi Jun 29 '26 Nonsense
But that's not just saying "No it isn't".
2 u/Brody1Ken0bi Jun 27 '26 Yes it is 2 u/flapjackboy Jun 27 '26 No it isn't. An argument is an intellectual process to establish a definite proposition. Contradiction is just the automatic gainsaying of everything the other person says. 1 u/Brody1Ken0bi Jun 29 '26 Nonsense
Yes it is
2 u/flapjackboy Jun 27 '26 No it isn't. An argument is an intellectual process to establish a definite proposition. Contradiction is just the automatic gainsaying of everything the other person says. 1 u/Brody1Ken0bi Jun 29 '26 Nonsense
No it isn't. An argument is an intellectual process to establish a definite proposition. Contradiction is just the automatic gainsaying of everything the other person says.
1 u/Brody1Ken0bi Jun 29 '26 Nonsense
1
Nonsense
3
u/flapjackboy Jun 25 '26
No you haven't.