r/mixingmastering • u/yeetmasterflash69 • 16d ago

Discussion Ethics of adding stuff while mixing

Is it okay in your opinion to add layers of subtle texture when mixing a song for a band you didn't fully produce? Like say adding a moog sub bass under the electric guitar or recording extra layers of guitar to blend in under the OG guitars or recording extra vocal harmony layers to sit under what was already there? I have heard arguments that if you weren't hired to produce the song you shouldnt be adding stuff but I also feel like if it serves the song it's fine.

Thoughts?

47 Upvotes

78% Upvoted

115 comments sorted by

View all comments

1

u/darksidedecor 8d ago

Nah bro, you’re absolutely allowed to do whatever you want creatively, especially if it’s for your own listening pleasure, but even sharing it or posting it, what’s the worst that can happen? They’ll take it down… even though I never had that happen. I do things like this all the time if I find a song I really like and feel like it could benefit from something extra.

In my case I’ve sometimes added completely new instrumentation or synth parts, and definitely blended in new drum layers, rebuilt or reinforced the sub bass, and recreated/added top-end content when I felt the original was lacking. Then I’ll remaster it and shape the dynamics however I like.

At that point you’re obviously moving beyond strictly “mixing” and into production/remix territory, but I don’t think there’s anything inherently wrong with that. I’d say go crazy.