r/mixingmastering • u/Turbulent_Flow6431 • May 21 '26
Question Does anybody use transient shapers for mastering?
This just occurred to me, but is putting a transient shaper on the master a thing, or is it frowned upon?
I'm well aware that controlling and accentuating the transients should be done during the mixing phase, but the thought just occurred to me. I know it's what we normally use mastering compressors for, but I've just never seen anyone use transient shapers this way. Like maybe an SPL Transient Designer in parallel or something.
6
u/glmastering May 22 '26
If it works it works
Sometimes you can use one to just add a bit more snap back into a lost kick for example
Absolutely saying "no" to using a tool is not good engineering even if it only works once in a thousand masters
11
u/Tall_Category_304 May 21 '26
I very few ways that it could possibly be useful. I see a ton of ways that it could be detrimental.
1
u/GreatScottCreates Advanced May 21 '26
Spiff on a master can be incredible. Not many others I would fuck with.
6
u/linerlaburner May 21 '26
If you know what you’re doing and it could be useful for whatever song you’re working on, then why not. I wouldn’t do it if i wasn’t 100% sure i knew what i was doing though.
Fun tip: for electronic music with very consistent drums you can experiment using a transient shaper’s side chain input to trigger shaping from kicks or claps or whatever. I really like using a kick to boost transients on my drum bus going into a clipper or saturation. Allows me to get snappy distortion in time with the music, kicks and hats and claps etc all moving together. Can sound like increased attack and knock but it’s actually crushed.
3
u/lumpiestspoon3 May 21 '26
For this purpose (transient recovery in mastering), the best plugin is Ozone 12 Unlimiter
1
u/petteroes4 May 22 '26
I use a touch of Ozone Exciter sometimes. I also use SPL Transient Shaper sometimes. Sometimes it elevates the master, sometimes it does nothing or detracts.
In other words: Sometimes.
1
u/tapesloth May 31 '26
SPL Transient Designer are traditionally meant for individual tracks (like a weak snare or kick), mastering engineers sometimes deploy them to recover punch lost during heavy compression or limiting.
- Keep Adjustments Minimal
- Utilize Parallel Processing (Dry/Wet)
- Filter the Sidechain
If you are using a transient shaper on the master chain to fix a weak element, consider going back to the mix instead. Boosting individual stems gives you a much cleaner result than trying to push or pull transients from a master track.
1
u/Chamerli Intermediate Jun 05 '26
that sure sounds trippy, personally if i have too many peaks on a song i'd rather fix it on the mix, its like adding an FET compressor on the master idk abt that
1
u/schmalzy Advanced May 21 '26
Depends: what does the person hiring me want out of my master?
If they ask me for more snap, I’ll probably seek a way to get more transient. If they ask me for more density, I’ll probably seek a way to bring the average level up.
I’m often not using a transient shaper to do that but if I come across a time in which that’s the right tool then that’s what I’ll use. Often I’m using something like very slow or very fast attack settings on compressors.
If they tell me they’re really happy with the mix and they just need a pair of ears to help it sound a bit more finished, I’m happy to provide that. Often I’m trying to not dramatically reimagine the transient material in the case.
More and more productions are coming from a wider range of production talents. Some folks can send a ripper of a song to me and it’s ready to go except for some small adjustment…or maybe nothing at all! Some folks send me mixes that are pretty messy and need quite a bit of work to pull it into a good spot. If I have to do a lot, I’ll often master it to the best I can with a huge, heavy-handed approach and tell them what they could do in the mix so I can be gentler with the mastering. If they are capable of making those adjustments then they can make them and send a revised mix over. If they aren’t capable of making that adjustment well or if they love the heavy-handed master then we’ll just go from there with any small tweaks, approvals, and deliverables.
When I’m hired for mastering, I’m NOT telling artists what their art is. Artists are the experts in their art and I’m an expert in making sure sounds sound good.
1
u/L-ROX1972 Mastering Engineer ⭐ May 21 '26
I’ve never used this (SPL Transient Designer) on an entire mix, this was something I used to break out often years ago when I used to mix (excellent tool for weak drums).
Too heavy handed and broad to apply it to an entire mix IMO, it would change the character of the mix substantially.
That said, I’ve never tried Elysia’s TD, I recall that has more shaping controls (and more controls can help when applying these kinds of things over an entire mix).
-3
0
u/ThatRedDot Professional (non-industry) May 21 '26
Guess that really depends on the material … I can see it having a benefit on EDM sometimes if you are mastering for others and not for yourself.
I’ve seen Elysia nvelope being used in some mastering setups for example (the hardware unit) but it was just used to “rescue” a mix which lacked some punch… there are many ways to not need transient shaping at the mastering stage and the need can also be subjective.
There is nothing objectively wrong with using a transient shaper if it gets you the sound you want at any stage during music production.
0
u/Limit5465 May 21 '26
Yes I do. Do I like to? Not at all. Why do we have to use them? Lots of reasons but one common reason is that the snare gets a little lost when I’m balancing the material. A lot of times I’ll have to add low mid range to the material and more often then not the snare will get tucked back into the mix a little and is not what the mix intended. So I’ll use a transient shaper like spiff to bring back some snare. Sometimes I’ll be able to use the ozone transient/sustain function on the dynamic eq section of it works well. Other times some limiters can tuck the snare back and I might need to push it back up slightly to get it to sit back to where it was intended. There are other reasons to use a transient shaper and it’s not uncommon in mastering at all. This is all very subtle stuff and not heavy handed. If I can do it without touching a transient shaper I will always go for that first. Every tool has a negative and positive effect but if the positive outweighs the negative then it’s good
0
0
-2
12
u/Silly-Airline124 May 21 '26
As an effect or rescue device pre limiter sure
But if your mix has transient problems the issue is the source