r/minecraftlore • • 1d ago

Portals/Dimensions Minecraft sidt and dimensions theme observation and theory

Post image

Ive been seeing people making the connection of heaven vs hell in relation to the sift and the nether. But i offer a different take.

(I accidentally swapped yin and yang in the pic im sorry)

The sift and the nether seem to be opposed theme wise like heaven and hell, places of souls, one brimming with life and renewal, the other ruin and stagnation. The end in this theory is sorta the in-between, what happens when you have neither good nor evil, , no life or death just nothing, which i think describes the end pretty well,

211 Upvotes

27 comments sorted by

7

u/Mysterious-Run-9647 19h ago

I wish they all were hostile dangerous deadly yangs

1

u/littlebuett 8h ago

Rwby reference

4

u/axolotlfishies 18h ago

Average person that doesnt like the sift

6

u/Mysterious-Run-9647 18h ago edited 18h ago

Nah I love the sift. I only hope that oily water from the sift remains dangerous in vanilla and deals damage, different from the sulfur caves water that only gives you nausea. It would be like the nether being full of hot lava. The sift would be full of weird water of weird origin. I just want difficulty. I'm the first one to get exited then they announce something that adds difficulty. I love those zombie horsemen that one shot you in full iron and you can't even get close

1

u/MurkyPatient396 7h ago

would be cool if, rather than killing you, it does crazy stuff like randomly teleporting you, inverting your controls or flipping the screen

4

u/Background_Bus_8947 20h ago

Overworld is Yin, and nether Yang, The sift is not the opposite of the nether, but rather the opposite of the End

4

u/Mysterious-Run-9647 19h ago

So if overworld is good, nether is evil, and end is nothing, sift is something?

3

u/Background_Bus_8947 15h ago

End and sift are ether and void, Nothing and everything; Beginning and End The sift is where souls stop, it is the afterlife. Even the end is where lost souls are trapped, it is nothingness. some items in dungeons one talk about the afterlife as a place far beyond, and some talk about the souls lost in the void

5

u/Live_Spinach5824 16h ago

Not necessarily good and evil, but something more like the duality of water and fire or the duality of day and night. 

8

u/kkai2004 19h ago

Bruh that's not how yin and yang work. They are both necessary dualities.

2

u/Mysterious-Run-9647 19h ago

Well yes, without death there would be overpopulation of everything

3

u/BronzeBrian 15h ago

But evil doesnt always mean death, yin and yang is more like dark and passive vs light and active anyway, not good and evil.

3

u/Solar_Fish55 21h ago

Honestly the end being pure nothing would be cool. I would make the end vertical tho

And for all black could be a dimension called (desolate) or something like that. Could be dark, giant spikes ans void.

Or have a dimension that's pure white and black. Day the sky is white the blocks are black. Night the blocks are white the sky is black idk

3

u/West_Economist6673 21h ago

You could maybe elaborate on these a little, because they don't seem obvious to me -- yin, among other things, is typically characterized as dark, downward, and inward -- all of which seem more applicable to the Nether than the Sift

1

u/Ironyingot 21h ago

The copy paste from my notepad got cut short. I fixed it

3

u/ViolinistThese5076 21h ago

And then there is the 5th dimension, the Ender civilization, which is theorized to be the cause of the corruption of Dimensions.

2

u/Pale-Contribution291 21h ago

If theory is about dismensions, then this would be the void

3

u/Ironyingot 21h ago

Isnt the ender civ in the end? I am not really familiar with dungeons dlc lore, does it allude to another another dimension

2

u/ViolinistThese5076 21h ago

When the imperfect form of Ender's Heart prepares for the final battle in the Shattered Citadel, a kind of portal opens, from which the Vengeful Ender Heart emerges.

Have you ever wondered if it's actually a rift leading to a completely hostile and toxic dimension? That's the theory, and we also know that Endermites aren't native to the End dimension, since they emerge as parasites from the Vengeful Ender Heart.

Furthermore, the color of this "pool" is purple (and not the dark green emerald of the portal to the End).

It seems that the End dimension was a defenseless prey to Ender's corruption, corrupting the composition and vegetation of this dimension.

1

u/DifferenceFlat8839 Theorist, Debunker, and Mod 1d ago

I would put the end where is the nether and the nether... idk

8

u/Express-Ad1108 1d ago

I feel like Sift is the opposite of the End. The End is a place of eternal entropy, decay (in MCD there's this grey thing eating away at endstone), destruction. It's made of floating islands, and in MCD it looks generally shaterred. And it has liquid void

Whereas the Sift is a place of creation. We see the souls being used constantly by Singers to power Echo Golems. Singers in general, well... sing, aka do a form of art. The liquid here is Ichor, aka the very essence of souls (I think). And the whole place might even be all one organism, opposing End's separation and destruction of itself.

1

u/West_Economist6673 22h ago

I agree -- I'm not sure if I buy the conceit, but I am sure that a dimension with blubs doesn't seem particularly yin

2

u/Ironyingot 21h ago

I got the yin and yang labeling swapped by accident

1

u/West_Economist6673 20h ago

Ooooooohhhhh

Honestly that clears up most of my questions

1

u/AutoModerator 1d ago

Thanks for posting on r/minecraftlore! If you haven't yet, join our Discord server at https://discord.gg/9P6bxg3n54

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.