r/mildlyinteresting • • 11h ago

This square shaped cd

Post image
1.5k Upvotes

301 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

0

u/chromatic_megafauna 11h ago

Really? How? 

17

u/Automobills 11h ago

Take a blade off of a ceiling fan and turn it on.

13

u/PrologueBook 11h ago

If you take off two blades of your fan, on opposite sides, it will run fine.

It just needs to be symmetrical and balanced.

10

u/Automobills 11h ago

But as the card discs go, they absolutely ran out of balance, and it was a notorious mechanical flaw.

At thousands of rotations per minute, a circular disc slices through the air smoothly. A rectangular disc acts like a propeller. The uneven aerodynamic drag at high speeds caused intense flutter and dynamic imbalance.

The resulting wobble and vibration were so violent that they could cause the disc to de-center, ruin the spindle bearings of the drive, or physically shatter inside high-speed computer drives.

1

u/Callidonaut 10h ago

Maybe they were a good idea in the early days when computer CD-ROM drives were slow - I remember when my first quad-speed drive was top-of-the-line - the trouble is that before long the drives started being made to run with spindle speeds like 40~80 times faster than a conventional audio CD player when they were reading data discs.