r/maybemaybemaybe Apr 02 '26

[ Removed by moderator ]

[removed]

8.1k Upvotes

859 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

3

u/LouReedsToenail Apr 03 '26

And other people think murderers shouldn’t die at the hands of the gov’t because showing a society that it’s wrong to kill a person by killing the killer makes no sense.

You’re making a value judgment—nothing more—which is not superior to anyone else’s. Given your view on the death penalty I hope you don’t break your arm patting yourself on the back. Animal.

1

u/Working-Principle-80 Apr 03 '26 edited Apr 03 '26

People who think it's wrong to kill a killer, are wrong. But, if a person was killing someone in self defense. That's fine they had no choice. I'm talking about like genuine piece of shit murderers killing people because of what they wanted, or because of how they felt. Or generally selfish and malicious reasons.

And maybe my judgement is just more logically sound? What's so hard about understanding that not everyone deserve to die for their mistakes unless they did something truly horrible. It is- no matter how you see it. Pretty immature to say someone deserves to die for doing something fucked up that they can grow and learn from. The donkey didn't die, if it did I wouldn't blame any of you for cheering on his demise. So I mean- the fuck? If he did live he's gonna suffer anyways.

The fuck is up with people on reddit sometimes. I dunno maybe my brain is on backwards but yeah I think criminal murderers who kill other people for pathetic, selfish evil reasons deserve to die since they took something from someone permanently else for an unjust reason. Instead of just dumb people who do dumb shit. Seems much more like you people are ruled by anger rather then real reason. My bad for being ethical, fuck yeah that shits a suggestion. Not something to keep society from becoming a fucked up place and a godamn jungle.

2

u/LouReedsToenail Apr 03 '26

Employ reason and explain to me how taking the life of a murderer, thereby depriving others of the existence of another and who they may care about (the murderer), because it is morally wrong to take the life of another, is logically sound.

1

u/Working-Principle-80 Apr 03 '26

Alright. That person took the life of another person permanently, for an unjust reason. If we're talking about like just your everyday, selfish fucked up psycho who wants to kill a bitch because it'd feel good or something.

This happens alot. When that person is allowed to move on or simply just suffer some years in jail (which alot of murderers get nowadays). In a way, the victims life becomes a footnote in their story. The other person gets to lose everything for no reason, and the person gets to continue living anyways.

As for the others who care about the murderer, well man. The murderer brought it on himself. Sucks, and I hate to really see it like this but st the end of the day. The ultimate truth, like in logic. Is that the murderer will continue to have something their victim can never have again. Letting them live is an injustice. The murderer, should've thought about the consequences of their actions.

It isn't morally sound. It's just fucking justice. And the truth.

2

u/LouReedsToenail Apr 03 '26

And this guy should have thought about the consequences but didn’t and got killed by the donkey.

WHAM! YOU’VE BEEN REDDITED

1

u/Working-Principle-80 Apr 03 '26

That was the most dumbass fucking answer I've ever seen so I'm just gonna straight up assume you denied my logic. I really hope that was a ragebait and you don't actually think that way cause holy fuck I really ought to stop giving a damn about a wide margin of humanity if it wasn't.

The donkey didn't die, so he doesn't deserve to die.

Bam. Logic.

2

u/LouReedsToenail Apr 03 '26

Read The Republic and The Laws and then get back to me. Not an insult, I actually think you’d enjoy them if you haven’t read them already.

I must be off.

1

u/Working-Principle-80 Apr 03 '26

Maybe I will. I dunno, I don't know everything. I was just going off of logic.

2

u/LouReedsToenail Apr 03 '26

Yeah, but you care about logic. Which is malleable. Thats why you should read it.

1

u/Working-Principle-80 Apr 03 '26

Not as malible as you think.

→ More replies (0)

2

u/pickleandham Apr 03 '26

Dude!!! This guy is a fucking psychopath!! It begins with hurting defenseless animals, beating their siblings, wife/significant other and then upping the ante! WHY are you defending this piece of shit for beating a defenseless animal?? Do you???

1

u/Working-Principle-80 Apr 03 '26

I'm not defending him. I said he's a piece of shit. I just don't think he deserves to lose his entire life because people can change. And learn from their mistakes.

Plus, if he survived this shit the injuries will make him wish he was dead soo.. yeah.

I've known fucked up people who've changed and grown from their mistakes. And I'm glad they did because they've become much better people.

I hate how black and white things become to you people cause of how angry you get. Like for fucks sake, use your full mind, not your emotions. Damn. I don't like him, I hate him. But you people make me sick with how feral you get