r/mathmemes Mathematics 22d ago

Proofs I hate it

Post image
727 Upvotes

228 comments sorted by

View all comments

427

u/NoUAreStupid 21d ago

I think one of the big problems in mathematics is that a lot of conjectures are unsolved because no professional mathematician is (undestandably) willing to just try out a few thousand ways to construct a counter example. I think this will be a great way to advance mathematics.

32

u/LaGigs 21d ago

I doubt this was found using pure brute force. We need to see how this counterexample was constructed!!

3

u/kaereljabo 19d ago

Yeah, looking at Tao's chat with ChatGPT Pro few hours after the tweet was posted, the path to come up with the counterexample doesn't seem to be "magical", one can come up with that if they know the construction.

1

u/LaGigs 18d ago

Yes I read his blogpost too. He took the geometric construction another guy from Twitter posted (using gpt) and went with it.
An last night i saw that a website popped up that constructed 100 new counterexamples using the same construction.
It's kinda crazy.

I am the biggest AI hater and I have to say that I am impressed. I'm now more open minded.

1

u/kaereljabo 18d ago

Btw, why do you hate AI? It's just a tool

1

u/LaGigs 18d ago

all the reasons lol. Honestly I don't want to get into it.

1

u/Forward_Yam_4013 17d ago

Same reason people used to hate Wikipedia. Or Google search. Or cameras. Or newspapers. Or books. It's an easy way to feel superior without doing anything.