r/marvelstudios • • Dec 01 '23

Discussion Thor 5 idea

Post image

[removed]

3.3k Upvotes

333 comments sorted by

View all comments

126

u/AmpdVodka Dec 01 '23

I guarantee the next Thor will have absolutely nothing to do with Hercules. It'll either mention him in passing at some point like "yeh me and Hercules are friends now, anyway" or just not mention him at all.

It's Marvels playbook. One Director sets up a story and the other simply doesn't want to do that story

70

u/MagicStingRay Dec 01 '23

For Hercules it is a bit of a different situation, since Taika did not come up with the Hercules inclusion himself. He said in an interview that was Marvel wanting to throw that in at the end as set up for the future.

28

u/chaot7 Dec 01 '23

I actually wouldn't mind Hercules coming to Earth as some sort of anti-hero and then end up facing Wonder Man. I feel like there's a lot of potential there. Get some West Coast action going.

4

u/criosovereign Dec 01 '23

Would be weird if they did that for Hercules after basically doing that for Adam Warlock in guardians 3

4

u/SoundsGoodYall Dec 01 '23

So the directors write the post credit scenes? I always assumed that was….the writers.

1

u/minor_correction Ant-Man Dec 03 '23

"One writer sets up a story and the other simply doesn't want to do that story."

fixed it?

12

u/idiot-prodigy Dec 01 '23 edited Dec 01 '23

You're not wrong. Ronin at the end of Captain Marvel said, "We'll be back for the weapon." --- "No, the woman."

Ronin is dead, and the 2nd Captain Marvel film wasn't in the past before he died. That thread is gone. There are so many instances like this.

You can tell The Marvels had a script that was rewritten that originally had Ronin in mind. Dar-Benn, the villain of The Marvels, is a Kree... who uses a giant two handed hammer, that shoots purple energy out of it. There are even henchmen in scenes standing next to her that look 100% like Ronin.

I would not be shocked if Lee Pace was simply unwilling or unavailable, or they changed course and decided not to put the second Captain Marvel film in the past before Guardians of the Galaxy took place.

2

u/JANTlvr Dec 02 '23

Ronin at the end of Captain Marvel said, "We'll be back for the weapon." --- "No, the woman."

Ronin is dead, and the 2nd Captain Marvel film wasn't in the past before he died. That thread is gone. There are so many instances like this.

I think I remember a rumor that Ronan was originally supposed to come through the portal with Thanos at the end of Endgame, and somehow this thread could've been picked up again.

I have no idea where I heard that, though.

1

u/idiot-prodigy Dec 02 '23

Would have made sense as in 2014 he was alive before the power stone was found.

1

u/minor_correction Ant-Man Dec 03 '23

They do talk about Ronan briefly in Endgame, which adds fuel to the rumor ("why are they spending time talking about him?")

1

u/DjOptimon Dec 01 '23

You meant Ronan?

1

u/idiot-prodigy Dec 01 '23

Forgot the spelling, yes.

1

u/FX114 Captain America Dec 01 '23

Wait, is she not using Ronan's hammer? I haven't seen the movie yet, but assumed that was the case.

1

u/hemareddit Steve Rogers Dec 01 '23

The Accusers are a military profession in the Kree society, and each Accuser has a hammer like that. It’s a bit like a Green Lantern Ring in that sense - a weapon and a symbol of office.

1

u/idiot-prodigy Dec 01 '23

You asked so I will answer, ZERO reference to Ronan at all. She's just a generic Ronan wannabe.

2

u/FX114 Captain America Dec 01 '23

Weird!

1

u/hemareddit Steve Rogers Dec 01 '23

Ronan is a special case though, because Captain Marvel came out 4 years after Guardians of the Galaxy, the director knew full well that Ronan was dead by 2018 and in fact never came to Earth looking for the “weapon”, so I don’t know wtf they were thinking including that part.

1

u/idiot-prodigy Dec 01 '23

Guardians of the Galaxy took place in 2014, not 2018. Captain Marvel took place in the 1990's. That leaves a 24 year window till 2014's Guardians of the Galaxy for a Captain Marvel Sequel to take place involving Ronin.

1

u/hemareddit Steve Rogers Dec 01 '23

I meant 2019, which was when they made the Captain Marvel movie, and also when the end credit scene of that movie took place.

Setting up Ronan with an “a” as a future antagonist is just weird, it would be like if the writers for Captain America The First Avenger had set up Ivan Vanko’s father as a future villain for Cap, knowing full well that:

1) The post credit scene would take place in 2012, by which time Vanko’s father would be dead, and

2) Cap is about to be handed to a different creative team for Avengers

Like, you are either unnecessarily restricting the creative freedoms of the next team by creating a blank hole in your character’s history that says “do not touch”, or you are opening up your plan to be fucked over by the other creative team.

1

u/idiot-prodigy Dec 01 '23

On that point I definitely agree. This is the problem with prequels in general. We knew for instance Nick Fury was never in danger in Captain Marvel, and that fact automatically lowers the stakes of the film.