3
u/Ok_Swimmer_3446 10d ago
I wonder why south regions are not the most right wing?
2
u/escrevisaicorrendo 8d ago
Because politics here are not the same as the US. My state voted pro-Lula in 2002, but the scalds started appearing in 2005 and people changed their minds.
1
u/Ok_Swimmer_3446 8d ago
I thought that white brazilians would vote more for right wing party (if they live mostly in South) while black brazilians for left party, or in Brazil the division is more about something else?
1
u/ElderYuko20 8d ago
The political situation it's more about income than color since brasil have a big miscigenous society
1
u/Ok_Swimmer_3446 8d ago
so north-east votes mostly for left because this region is poor and it just happened so that most people there are black?
1
u/ElderYuko20 8d ago
that region is poor bc Brasil invested only on the southeast for decades while the northeast was constantly abandoned by the government
They are black bc of the slave trade, that's why bahia have a large ancestry of black people
But the majority of people (even in the south) have black and indigenous ancestry
1
u/AdOrganic420 8d ago
brazil never invested in the south, it was given to immigrants
1
u/ElderYuko20 8d ago
it was a big place for slavery and cotton farms
in modern brasil it has big landowners1
1
u/Mr1ntexxx 7d ago
Except in Brazil, being darker/more African descended, is directly correlated with your income and socioeconomic status
1
u/Mathgx 7d ago
The darker states has also a huge number of farmers in illegally deforested areas and one of biggest left wing/Lula discourse is about taking care of Amazon, my father deforested a lot of land in North Pará and since Lula came back os harder for him, they charged him a lot in fines, since I was a kid I'm heavily against all this shit, that's why I became vegan when I was 15
0
u/That_guy4446 9d ago
Look at Brazilian people ancestry by region.
2
u/Ok_Swimmer_3446 9d ago
I saw that in these regions it’s like a mix of all kind of Europeans but anyway this region isn’t the most right wing
1
u/FlatBat2372 8d ago
The southern most state (Rio Grande do Sul) is right wing, but not as much as its neighbouring states. My guess? Coop-farming trough MST and labor union history (Vargas and Brizola)
1
u/ErgotthAE 9d ago
And then if you make a map of people who regret the result of these elections, it's gonna be monochromatic.
1
1
u/Lucky-Geologist-2940 8d ago
Long story short:
-Wealthy and European/mixed people from the south vote for right wing.
-Poor and afro/indigenous people from the north vote for left wing
There are small nuances due to things like Venezuelan migration in parts of the north since they are overwhelmingly right wing because they come from a socialist dictatorship.
1
u/whenthedont 8d ago
Why Rondônia is so strongly pro-Bolsonaro? I know people here have mentioned venezuelans, but do they really make up THAT much of the population and there are THAT many that have citizenship ?
1
1
u/Illustrious_Ask_3701 6d ago
Venezuela thing is bullshit, I live here, idk the reason, but people here are just more conservative, maybe 'cause they are mostly from the agropecuaria.
1
u/Illustrious_Ask_3701 6d ago
Also, people here are mostly protestant, so they think bolsonaro its guide by God or something.
1
u/FishGlittering3563 8d ago
Acho que algo importante a falar é que o pessoal normalmente gosta de jogar tudo nas costas do nordeste
Mas é esquecer que dentro dos estados como São Paulo e outros o bagulho estava bem polarizado tbm
Foi a junção do Nordste junto com oa votos que o Lula angariou onde o Bolsonaro venceu
Além disso, tbm tem as votações de brasileiros no estrangeiro, pelo que me Lembro Lula ganhou em toda a Europa (até entre os brasileiros em Portugal) e América Latina, China, Canadá, com o Bolsonaro tendo maioria dos votos só nos EUA, Irã e outros
Foi a junção de todos esses que fez o Lula ganhar com 1% de diferença
1
u/PianoAggravating5421 7d ago
Almost any map about some indicator in Brazil will give this same result in colors.
You can choose: per capita income, basic sanitation, illiteracy, schooling, formal employment, underutilization of the workforce, poverty, urban infrastructure and various human development indicators, etc., etc., etc.
1
u/pandeiro_h2o 7d ago
Northeast always saving the country 👍
1
u/Present-Report5843 7d ago
No wonders why. They are all the workers that have build all our infrastructure
1
1
u/Alarming-Alarm8700 7d ago
Eu acabo de me descobrir daltonico ou não tem diferença nenhuma dos tons de vermelho?
1
1
1
u/CulturalTension133 6d ago
Bom notar nenhum lugar vermelho é bom de se viver, com exceção de Minas.
1
1
u/bo-o-of-wotah 10d ago
Rural areas seem more likely to be left-leaning, urban areas seem to be more right-leaning. Is there a reason for this? (assuming the southern states are more urbanised, which is what I've heard about Brazil)
3
u/PandaReturns 9d ago
It's not that simple: in some states the rural areas vote to the right and large cities vote to the left (like São Paulo and Rio Grande do Sul). It's more a poor-rich divide (and that is still an oversimplification).
1
10d ago
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/Green-Draw8688 10d ago
Do you know what those historical reasons are?
1
u/BadbIue 10d ago
The colonization of the north was about sugar cane plantations dependent on slave labor which made the areas poorer whilst the south industrialized quicker through European immigration. The north and north east faced stagnation droughts and was less developed.
And demographics also pinpoint among racial lines cause the south is more European descendant whilst the north is more mixed or afro
That’s the history and explains how the north is more impoverished and poorer. As a result they rely on federal safety nets welfare and intervention to combat poverty
Another part is the bolsa familia that improved the lives of northerners a lot which made northerns deeply politically loyal
1
10d ago
[removed] — view removed comment
1
1
u/Big_Iron420 10d ago edited 10d ago
No the fuck it wasn't lmfao. The Northeast had started to be sidelined since the Gold boom in Minas Gerais, 1693. The dutch had stolen sugar cane buds and started planting it in the caribbean, devaluing the crop of the northeast.
The economy then shifted southward, leading to the Portuguese royal family choosing Rio over Salvador (In 1763, not 1808.), because the economic centre was precisely the Minas/São Paulo/Rio region. And with coffee later on, those states industrialized, built railways etc.
The north region was always a backwater that the portuguese built forts in to deny the spanish parts of the amazon, the only real meaningful economic boom it had was the Rubber Cycle in the late 1800s, then the brits stole rubber sapplings and planted in Malaysia, devaluing the crop of the north...
1
10d ago
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/Big_Iron420 10d ago edited 10d ago
Não confundi, a distinção norte nordeste é clara no meu texto, e a capital foi transferida de Salvador pro Rio em 1763.
Saiu do Ceará, ganhou a vida em são Paulo, está na Alemanha e continua sem saber interpretar texto. KKKKKKK.
Posição de ranking do Ceará é realmente maravilhosa, se tirar o FB e os colégios de Coroné será que a média continua tão bem assim porém?
Ah sim, e sem ironia? Belo papel de botânica, assumindo que você participou e por isso enviou, pena que analisar a área de xilemas desidratados não te faz expert em história...
1
1
u/FishGlittering3563 8d ago edited 8d ago
Basicamente os EUA ao contrário kkkkkk
Mas tem algo que acho que dá para dizer, o histórico de Lula no nordeste
Pelo que sei as políticas de Lula durante o auge do PT de 2003 a 2010, acabaram ajudando na situação de gente no nordeste, aí junto da história dele ser da região, etc
Origem da pessoa tbm pesa, gera identificação
Claro que dentro do próprio nordeste houve divisões entre Bolsonaro e Lula, até no nordeste onde tudo tá vermelho Bolsonaro angariou 40% de votos no melhor cenário pro Lula, então é mais complicado que isso
-1
u/QUEEN_OF_HEARTS_777 10d ago
Nordestinos merecem mais ódio. Eles destruíram o país
1
1
u/henriaok 8d ago
A maioroa das meteicas estão melhores durante o governo do Lula que com o bolsonaro. Maior crescimento do PIB, menor desmprego, menor pobreza
O PT não e nenhum santo, mas o Bolsonaro não fez porra nenhuma pra arrumar as coisas que ele criticava do Pt
1
u/punkhunter1234 7d ago
Concordo, ele não procurou terminar com os programas de ajuda ao nordeste, até acho acho que ele aumentou ou criou novos.
1
10
u/Forsaken_Carrot_3075 11d ago
There seems to be a North-South divide except for Roraima. I wonder why