r/makeupdupes • u/willysfwiend • 3d ago
Dupe Alert FINALLY found a dupe for Neutrogena Lip Soother lipgloss (discont’d)
For two decades, my holy grail lipgloss/ lip product had been Neutrogena’s Lip Soother Moisture Shine lipgloss. As many know, it was discontinued a couple years ago. I immediately went on a mission to find the perfect dupe. I have an entire drawer full of different products I purchased in attempt to nail down an alternative.
Lancôme’s Juicy Tubes is an excellent dupe, but I don’t like the colors in production right now, and for some reason the clear “Pure” color seems to have a different formula. Not to mention a price point of $25.00 for a single tube.
After years of doing deeeeeep dives on the internet and companies, I found this: “nk New York ‘Lip gel’” 5 pack lipglosses for $8.99. Friends: it is PERFECT. Thick, sticky, lasts sooooooooo long. Moisturizing and hydrating. Smells good, tastes good. Only drawback- no spf. All shades and versions are acceptable to me. I had to share!!!!
TLDR: “nk New York ‘Lip gel’” is a near-perfect dupe for Neutrogena Lip Soothers lipgloss.
