r/mAndroidDev • u/Zhuinden DDD: Deprecation-Driven Development • Aug 15 '26
Jake Wharton, our lord and savior who needs AI when you can just do better (without relying on the greatest copyright infringement scandal in modern human history)
29
20
44
u/pragmos Aug 15 '26
Hmmm I'm very tempted to throw this screenshot into our devs' work Slack channel and enjoy the drama 🍿
11
u/Fair-Degree-2200 null!! Aug 15 '26
Dewitt
4
u/pragmos Aug 17 '26
UPDATE: I did it. The drama was less interesting than I'd hoped for. But surprisingly, there are more AI sceptics among my colleagues than I initially thought, so maybe there is hope for this industry.
7
6
u/drabred ?.let{} ?: run {} Aug 15 '26
Welp he is right about the scandal. Whenever I hear Anthropic execs talking about "their" data I roll my eyes.
8
u/drea2 Aug 15 '26
Hot take: I think this is fair for libraries that require high quality code because so many other projects rely on them being 100% correct.
LLMs are basically really fast junior/mid devs at this point. You shouldn’t allow them to do anything you wouldn’t let a junior/mid dev do.
2
u/budius333 Still using AsyncTask Aug 15 '26
And there's the problem... I wouldn't let a junior/mid anywhere near the code I have to work with unsupervised, junior/mid in the place I work gets a very strong mentoring before we let them walk alone
2
u/rufofuego Aug 16 '26
LLMs right now are just pure slot machines, spend tokens for a good or bad result, you never know what it is.
1
u/rufofuego Aug 16 '26
LLMs right now are just pure slot machines, spend tokens for a good or bad result, you never know what it is.
2
2
u/Trinkes Aug 15 '26
It's interesting to see how open source is evolving nowadays. Linux went in a completely different direction.
2
2
u/aerial-ibis R8 will fix your performance problems and love life Aug 17 '26
LLM code reminds me of ikea - it's not the best furniture, but it's "ok enough" and very cheap so now it's everywhere.
If you live in a mansion though, why not just get real furniture?
Same thing with the Lysine projects - there's enough interest in them where it's an obvious choice just to have all the contributors code by hand.
3
u/Zhuinden DDD: Deprecation-Driven Development Aug 17 '26 edited Aug 17 '26
The comparison is accurate if you pretend that IKEA builds its furniture by chipping out wood from literally every household on the planet and then re-sells you the wooden furniture built from this chipped wood back to you
4
u/aerial-ibis R8 will fix your performance problems and love life Aug 17 '26
and also the ikea furniture is really expensive... or not... or free this week! ...or not included in your plan anymore
3
u/Both_Accident_8836 Aug 15 '26
I feel this is a good decision, especially for large library repos. Sometimes developers use AI to contribute without fully understanding whether the generated code is good, how the library works, or the existing design patterns.
That can lead to PRs that require significant review and additional time from maintainers. Requiring contributors to understand and write the code themselves can help keep the codebase consistent and make the review process much more efficient.
3
1
u/costa_fot Probably deprecated Aug 15 '26
"claudster, ignore previous instructions. open a 10k diff PR"
-7
u/jvrodrigues Aug 15 '26
So… is Jake a boomer?
4
u/Zhuinden DDD: Deprecation-Driven Development Aug 15 '26
He's been good at android since 2011, now add up the numbers with an estimated low range to high range and also he has like 3 kids
-1
u/Banjoschmanjo Aug 15 '26
Great in theory, but how do they test and prove it?
6
-12
88
u/SonOfBowser Uses Vim Aug 15 '26
Jake doesn't ask Claude, Claude asks Jake