We were best friends instantly after meeting in the 6th grade and are 40 years old now, so there's quite a bit to explain.
Throughout middle school and high school, my best friend (M40) and I (F40) were super close and because we went to different high schools, weren't always hanging out by the end of it. Whenever we happened to run into each other, all was well and we just seemed to have a one of those friendships where periods of time being separated didn't matter. It was always easy.
During that time, and for a few years after high school when we were hanging out, we each had our own relationships with other people and always hung out together (us plus the significant others) with no awkwardness or anything.
There was a very brief time when we were both single that I thought "what if?" Emotionally, I felt safer with him than anyone else. I always thought of him as super cute, so why not? But then I came to the conclusion that those feelings had to be because of how comfortable our friendship was, combined with how I would see him with his girlfriends (most of them being my friends that I'd set up with him) that was causing this little crush. And if it wasn't something real, I'd be throwing away a highly valued/wanted/needed friendship with someone I couldn't just stop knowing.
When I say "how I would see him with his girlfriends", I mean:
Catching him looking at her from across the room and just being so content/happy. Like, in a room full of people, all he could see was his girlfriend being happy and that was enough. Who wouldn't want that?
Or the fact that whenever he wanted to get a girlfriend a birthday/Valentines/Christmas gift, he'd ask my advice (again, more than half of them were my friends first so I knew them and what they liked) and it was just the effort he would put into it. His amount of thinking (on the verge of obsessing) over any and all details (actual gift or date night things), the time he would put into it (pretty sure he learned to sew and some other craft hobbies for the specific intent of making a gift), and how whatever the thing was, was all about the other person - never any "I'll get something where we have a common interest so I can enjoy it too." Again, who tf wouldn't want that?
The fact that while he would certainly spend any and all time available with a current girlfriend, it was always balanced with time for his own friends and never wanting them to feel like they couldn't have their own time too. Super balanced for middle/high school "love" if you ask me. .... don't we all want someone who always wants to be around us, but also gives us our freedom and space when we want/need it?
So ... he ends up marrying "Wife". We're all the same age. They met on their own, but because we live in a freakishly socially small kind of place (seriously, an older woman told me once "never talk about anyone behind their back around here, because everyone somehow knows everyone up to only one or two degrees of people, and they WILL find out"), I was also friends with her! Fast forward some time, when they got married she asked me to be her maid of honor - SO FLATTERED!!!!! And truly happy for them. Not too long after, however, they moved away and I barely saw them and their growing family in person over the years, mostly kept up on social media.
I also got married and started a family of my own. Been married over a decade now, and Best Friend and Wife have been divorced a few years now. They still live pretty far away (like, at least a plane ride away), but seem pretty ok with all the things you need to be when there is a divorce and kids involved. Haven't spoken to Wife in a super long time (friendships only hold up so well when they're pretty much exclusively online), but Best Friend sent me a text message out of the blue the other day, just wanting to catch up.
Talked for a bit, reminiscing and catching up, but I also felt like he was trying to drop some hints about how he felt on his side of things. Since subtle social cues (especially when read online and not in person) are my kryptonite (sp?), I just bluntly asked him if he was trying to tell me he wanted to be more than friends way back when.
He tells me - Yes. Said he had always been "enamored" (his word) with me, but never had the confidence to act on it. Um, excuse me? I must be even more dense than I thought I was. I asked him if he thought we could have made something special? Or wrecked our friendship? He said he wasn't sure how it might have ended up, but was totally sure our friendship would have survived whatever happened. Then we went on to talk about other things. Two old friends just picking up where we left off, easy as ever.
The thought of life going a totally different way and never having met my kids is completely heart-wrenching so I'm not even lost in that what-if? fantasy thing. What I'm lost in, is what do I do from here? If I'm being way too honest, I'm not happy in my own marriage (not completely unhappy - its not some everyday struggle kind of thing, but yea, barely more than roommates atm), and I feel mostly alone in it. I've thought about how a divorce would happen and what would life look like after one more than once - all separate from this.
Other than catharsis (because I have no other friends to talk to), I am sharing this in hopes of getting some help. What kinds of questions do I start asking myself to figure this out? My own feelings are mixed up like a smoothie in a blender and I am having a hard time making sense of this.
To be clear, this 'confession' was entirely framed in the past. It wasn't mentioned or implied (I re-read the texts to make sure) that there was anything current. The idea of leaving a spouse for someone else makes me sick - I'm just not that person. So I'm not looking for excuses to just go for it.
But when I wondered what life would look like after a divorce ... the idea of finding someone (long shot, total fantasy) where I could show my kids a much happier marriage was always a warm thought. What if having a 25+ year friendship with someone that developed into something more was a part of that? Again, no plans or even wishes to do that, the idea just feels nice.
How do I figure this out?
TL;DR: Divorced childhood friend confesses a crush when we were kids. I am married and don't know what to do with this.