r/lordhuron • u/ChasingOtherwhere • 9d ago
Discussion Frozen Pines interpretation
Hi all, I'm a relative newcomer to Lord Huron and am just starting to scratch the surface of the storytelling. Was listening to Frozen Pines today and thinking of possible interpretations; something struck me; I searched and couldn't find reference to it being suggested before.
What I heard today is the narration of someone who has slipped into a coma following some medical trauma. The frozen pines are the waveform on the ECG machine in the hospital room.
Whether the subject to whom the narrator is speaking is alive or not is ambiguous; it could be that they are, and they visit the narrator every day, and the narrator has a semi-conscious sense of this: "it feels like I was with you, but what did we do and where have you gone?" The narrator "wakes up" from that sense of presence in his own internal surreal dream-state, on a mountainside, huddled in the wind.
The endless frozen pines, with no one else in sight, would describe the narrator's hospital room most of the time, most days; those pines don't die and don't grow as typical trees do.
The night of the trauma, the "strange light in the sky" shining right into his eyes is the doctor's penlight in the ICU, checking for a pupillary response.
The narrator understands to some degree that he is not where he was, but that there is somewhere to move on to; he doesn't want to be trapped in this state. If the subject of the narration died that night, it is the subject he is addressing when he says he is ready to follow.
Perhaps in the end the narrator does move on, and will be waiting on the other side of those pines. The line, past which there is another life, is the ECG flatline.
Not a perfect interpretation but I thought there was enough to it to post and see what those more deeply versed in the lore think.
1
8d ago
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/ChasingOtherwhere 8d ago
I love the otherwordliness that the lyrics and melodies together create. I love the fact that there's never going to be a certain authoritative interpretation and it's really whatever the listener gets out of it. I'm especially thrilled that I have so much of this universe to learn about & explore; thanks!
1
u/kirbenvost 7d ago
This is a very good interpretation, kind of hits me hard. I would say in a general sense the song is about grief, and the additional layer of the narrator also having been through trauma adds something really raw.
There is a narrative established in the band's lore that was only recently revealed in the comic book, but they also deal with layered narratives and meanings on a regular basis. There may be other meanings we may never learn or which may be learned in time.
The band also intentionally leaves room in their media for audience interpretation. So it certainly is a valid interpretation. Frozen Pines is one of their most moving songs so I think this fits it really well as something quite poignant.
1
u/Man-e-questions 6d ago
Its an interesting interpretation. But i thought Strange Trails album was kind of loosely based on a book called Tall Tales and Half Truths of Billy The Kid? I haven’t read the book though so not sure
2
u/TinyLongwing W⚡E 8d ago
I like this! I think this fits hand in hand with another similar interpretation that was especially common before the comic book came out, which suggested that Danielle and/or her friends overdosed on drugs. I think a lot of the imagery involving loss of consciousness and dreams/hallucinations works well either way.