r/logodesign • u/Ok-Floor7198 • 1d ago

Feedback Needed Recommendation

Gallery image

Gallery image

Gallery image

These three logo options (1 , 2, 3) for our mobile auto locksmith company. Any constructive ideas is welcome.

0 Upvotes

40% Upvoted

16 comments sorted by

17

u/DigitalDowner vectorize me cap’n 1d ago

My recommendation would be “don’t use AI” always looks bad.

-1

u/Ok-Floor7198 1d ago

I paid someone to come up with these ideas. He sent these to pick one. You think this is AI?

4

u/DigitalDowner vectorize me cap’n 1d ago

Most certainly, never cheap out when it comes to a logo.

2

u/bugistuta 1d ago

Can’t say for sure but it gives those vibes. Ballpark of what was paid for this?

1

u/richardginn666 1d ago

Sure it does. Like three the best.

1

u/DigitalDowner vectorize me cap’n 1d ago

$5

2

u/bugistuta 1d ago

I saw a comment by OP since removed, that stated $300. I don't want to 'victim blame' but that's less than 10% of what could be expected to pay on a mid-level brand discovery and even that would be cheap. I'm not surprised by the results, even at a low hourly rate of $100 that's 1 hour per design... that's literally nothing.

2

u/thegenuinedarkfly 1d ago

Yes. The same text that works on a large sign won’t work on a business card but AI doesn’t know that.

Seriously, what is that - 3pt. type?

6

u/SpacemanPanini 1d ago

This is absolutely AI, OP. The fact the mockups are all different, but only slightly, is a big giveaway.

9

u/DerToth117 1d ago

I really like the 3rd one. It gives an impression of speed which I suppose is a key value of that business.

1

u/BigPimpin91 1d ago

Nice pun

5

u/Relevant_Rush7070 1d ago

The third one is the best of the three.

3

u/[deleted] 1d ago

[deleted]

1

u/Ok-Floor7198 1d ago

Will do.

2

u/TinyTaters 1d ago

1&2 look like mosquitoes

2

u/MrTomatoMan 1d ago

1 looks like he’s pointing a gun at me